Myrtle's Pies

Directions Website Contact the business

Myrtle's Pie Shop is known for their variety of homemade pies. Call a day in advance to order a special whole pie or to reserve a slice or two!!
(542)

We have lots of whole & sliced pie available daily!! Pie, Pie and MORE pie!!!

10/29/2026

Good morning

Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
and Sunday from 10:00 to 2:00
and we do our discount pies at 3:00 or 4:00 depending on how fast I can get them ready (on Sunda)

cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing
or Blackberry cream cheese icing

pumpkin snickerdoodles
lemon shortbreads
and 99% gluten-free sugar cookies

pecan

Peach
blueberry
Apple
Dutch Apple
Dutch blueberry
cherry
red raspberry
strawberry rhubarb
rhubarb

RumChata pie
pumpkin pie
orange creamsicle pie (new recipe)
Tiramisu pie
key lime
Baileys and coffee pie
Alan's chocolate coconut
toasted coconut cream.. new
cherry cheesecake pie
banana cream
lemon overboard
lemon meringue
French silk
chocolate cream
Chocolate butter cream
peanut butter cream
coconut with cookie crust
coconut with pastry crust

have a great day!!!....

we now serve sweet tea
hot cocoa
canned soda (coke diet and Sprite)
and coffee with cocoa and fresh whipped cream.

Grab and stay or togo lunch today too...

Chicken salad on croissant with a side salad fruity chicken salad on croissants with a side salad
Myrtl's salad with chicken breast, Craisins, soft goat cheese, walnuts and apple slices....

Starting off with easy items.... and building from there.... like soup...etc....

Have a great day!

10/25/2026

Opening early for discounted pies....2:45 today

10/22/2026

Good morning......

Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. and Sundays from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. ....and we do discounts at 3:00 or 4:000p.m. on Sundays

***this Friday October 23rd we will close at 2:00 p.m. though***

Cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing or bourbon brown sugar icing or
Blackberry icing

Kahlua and coffee pie
Key lime
Tiramisu pie
custard
pumpkin
pumpkin overboard
lemon meringue
Peach lavender lemon
cake batter pie
chocolate cream
butterscotch banana
banana cream
coconut with pastry crust
coconut with cookie crust
monster peanut butter
chocolate peanut butter
malted chocolate French silk
French silk

Dutch Apple
Cherry
black raspberry
strawberry rhubarb
blueberry
apple
caramel apple
red raspberry
peach
pecan
no sugar added vert berry
99% gluten free very berry

have a great day!!

10/18/2026

Sold out

10/18/2026

Good afternoon....

Today is Sunday, October 18th... open until 2:00...

Discounts most likely at 3:00 instead of passing out numbers

10/17/2026

My post must not have gone through on Thursday?!
I apologize.

we are open today Saturday the 17th of October until 7:00 p.m.
and Sunday the 18th from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

and we will probably do discounts at 3:00 p.m. on Sundays....instead of passing out numbers at 3:00 (if I have time) otherwise we will open at 4:00 for discounts

Thanks

10/11/2026

Sold out tonight quickly and we are close tomorrow Sunday the 11th of October

10/11/2026

We usually hand out numbers an hour before we open but I am ready to go

so at 8:00 will be open for Discount pies

if it's a full price for instance $26.99 for a monster peanut butter.... we take 75% off of that price

if it is a pie that has several pieces it is $5

the discount does not include take and bake pies...
See you soon

10/10/2026

Depending on how fast I can put the discount pies together ....we might do discounts at 8:00 p.m.
if not ....I will pass out numbers at 8:00 to hold your place in line and open at 9:00 p.m.
I will post here if we open right at 8:00 p.m.

Address

927 N Main Street
Princeton, IL
61356

Website

https://myrtles-cafe-and-pie.hub.biz/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Myrtle's Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.