Buttercream Bake Shop

Buttercream Bake Shop This product was produced in a home kitchen not subject to public health inspection that may also process common food allergens.

If you have safety concerns, contact your local health department.

06/06/2026

Good morning! 🍪

It’s a good day to stop by the Princeton Farmer’s Market! I’ve got a table full of treats— buckeye cookies, loaded peanut butter, oatmeal cream pies, half baked chocolate chips and brookie sandwiches!

Swing by before the Princeton Mile and Shrimp Fest 🦐

06/05/2026

It’s been a busy day in the kitchen! I’m all ready for the market tomorrow! 8:30-12:00 at Soldiers and Sailors Park in Princeton.

Full menu (in order of video appearance 🤪):
-1/3 # Ganache filled Loaded Peanut Butter cookies
-Buckeye Cookies
-Oatmeal Cream Pies

and making their market debut:

- Half Baked (cookie dough stuffed chocolate chip cookies)
-Brookie Sandwiches (brownie cookies stuffed with chocolate cookie dough frosting)

Swing by for a treat before heading to the Princeton Mile or Shrimp Fest! It’s going to be a great weekend! ☀️ 🍪

**note: I accidentally wrote 8-12 on the reel, but the market hours are 8:30-12 🤪🤦🏻‍♀️

Another market sneak peek 👀 I’ll have the new cookie dough stuffed, giant chocolate chip cookies at Princeton’s Farmer’s...
06/04/2026

Another market sneak peek 👀

I’ll have the new cookie dough stuffed, giant chocolate chip cookies at Princeton’s Farmer’s Market this Saturday!

These fellas are amazing! A traditional chocolate chip cookie with a fun twist… the center stays soft and gooey thanks to the dough and the edges have a slight crispness to them. You don’t want to miss these!

Good morning y’all! The sun ☀️ is shining and it going to be a gorgeous day! Friendly reminder that I will be at Princet...
06/02/2026

Good morning y’all! The sun ☀️ is shining and it going to be a gorgeous day!

Friendly reminder that I will be at Princeton’s Farmer’s Market *this Saturday* from 8:30-12! The market is held at Soldier & Sailor’s Park across from the courthouse. There is a chance of rain on Saturday, and if it rains, then we will set up inside the Prouty Building (tons of parking in the lot behind there too!)

One of the options on this weeks’ menu is a fan favorite (and often requested cookie)… the Buckeye! A thick chocolate cookie topped with that classic peanut butter Buckeye filling and a milk chocolate ganache. These are rich, delicious and a favorite for a reason!

🎉 Farmer’s Market kicks off this Saturday! Please note I will **NOT** be there this opening Saturday due to prior commit...
05/28/2026

🎉 Farmer’s Market kicks off this Saturday!

Please note I will **NOT** be there this opening Saturday due to prior commitments. Stop by and support all the amazing vendors and I will see y’all next weekend 😊

(Keep your eyes on this page for next weeks’s menu reveal 👀)

👨🏼‍🌾 The Princeton Farmers Market will kick off the 2026 season beginning on Saturday, May 30th at Soldiers & Sailors Park! Join us every Saturday through October 31st from 8:30 AM - 12:00 PM for one of Princeton’s favorite seasonal traditions.

This year brings NEW vendors, fresh finds, handmade treasures, baked goodies, farm-fresh produce, yoga in the park with Arukah Institute of Healing, and so much more! We are ecstatic to welcome everyone back for another amazing season!

And don’t let Mother Nature fool you… if the weather doesn’t cooperate, the market WILL move indoors to the Prouty-Zearing Community Building because farmers market season waits for no one!

Tag your market bestie, share this post, and help us spread the excitement — Saturday mornings in Princeton just hit different!



Y’all ever want the cookie dough without the actual cookie? 🙋🏻‍♀️ Yep me too. If you’re looking for a delicious no bake ...
05/13/2026

Y’all ever want the cookie dough without the actual cookie? 🙋🏻‍♀️ Yep me too.

If you’re looking for a delicious no bake treat, check out this browned butter cookie dough.

(And if you’re feeling really fancy… you can use mini chocolate chips & chopped pecans in the dough, scoop it into balls, toss into the freezer for a bit and then dip them in melted Ghirardelli chocolate. And voila! You just made chocolate chip pecan cookie dough truffles 😉 )

Browned Butter Edible Cookie Dough:
1 c butter, browned (see below, I use salted butter)
1 1/4 c lightly packed brown sugar
1/4 c sugar
1/4 tsp salt
1/2 tsp baking soda (yes i know we aren’t baking this dough, but it adds to the flavor)
1 2/3 c heat treated flour (see below)
1 c mix ins (chocolate chips, M&m’s, nuts, etc)

Add your butter to a sauce pan and place over medium high heat. Stir occasionally until butter is amber in color and you have some browned bits in the bottom of the pan. Mine took about 6-7 minutes roughly. Pour the hot butter into a bowl, making sure to scrape all the browned goodness from the pan. Place the bowl in the fridge or freezer to let it set up. You don’t want the butter hard, but like a room temp softened butter consistency.

While the butter is cooling, heat treat your flour. Spread flour onto a parchment paper lined cookie sheet. Bake in a 350 oven for about 5-6 minutes. Alternately, you can also put flour into a microwave bowl & microwave for 45 seconds, stir, then another 45 seconds. Ideally, we are trying to get the flour to 160 degrees to kill any bacteria. If you use the oven method, I’ve found the flour doesn’t clump; if you use the microwave method use a whisk or sifter to get the lumps out of your cooled flour.

Once butter is cooled, cream it together with the sugars, vanilla and salt. Then add baking soda & flour. Stir well to combine. Add in your choice of mix ins (and feel free to measure with your heart 😆). NOTE: If your dough is too thick, add a tablespoon or two of milk to it.

Refrigerate any leftovers (I mean, is there even any leftovers? This is sooo good!)

🍎 🍏 Thank you for all you do! 🍏 🍎
05/04/2026

🍎 🍏 Thank you for all you do! 🍏 🍎

Did you know Teacher Appreciation week starts tomorrow? 🍎 🚌 I’ve got extra Reese’s peanut butter cookie cakes available ...
05/03/2026

Did you know Teacher Appreciation week starts tomorrow? 🍎 🚌

I’ve got extra Reese’s peanut butter cookie cakes available for pick up TODAY at the Princeton Library from 4:00-5:00. They’re packaged up and ready to show your “app-reeses-iation”!

If you’d like one, shoot me a message!
$6 each and payment can be made via cash, card or Venmo at pick up

05/03/2026

Reminder:
Teacher Appreciation cookie pick up is *tonight* at the Princeton Library from 4:00-5:00

04/25/2026

All set up at True Leaves in Princeton! This is a tiny little snippet into this amazing book store! Swing by, grab a treat, a new book and meet some local authors too!

Address

Princeton, IL
61356

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttercream Bake Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share