04/30/2026
We get a lot of questions about our ice cream cakes, so it’s time to lay it all out.
The Definitive Guide to Lake Effect Ice Cream Cakes
We keep eight cakes stocked at both locations whenever possible:
CHOCOLATE DREAM
Dark chocolate brownie and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch, topped with chocolate crunch and flake chocolate.
COOKIE DOUGH
Cookie dough and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch, topped with a chocolate chip cookie and mini chocolate chips.
RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE
Raspberry cheesecake and vanilla ice cream layers, filled with vanilla crunch, topped with raspberry candies and raspberry infused frosting.
EL GUAPO (The Handsome One)
Two layers of silver cloud vanilla ice cream filled with cinnamon crumbs, honey, and cinnamon chocolate, topped with cinnamon crumbs, honey, and cinnamon chocolate.
PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE
Peanut butter epiphany and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and crushed Reese’s, topped with Reese’s cups and peanut butter frosting.
SALTY CARAMEL CHOCOLATE
Salty caramel and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and mini salty caramel truffles, finished with a caramel drizzle.
OREO
Extra cookies, extra cream and vanilla ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and topped with mini Oreo cookies.
TRADITIONAL (with or without happy birthday writing)
Vanilla and house chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and topped with sprinkles.
Pricing
Small Traditional: $35 (serves 10-12)
Small Specialty: $39 (serves 10-12
Large Traditional: $45 (serves 14–20)
Large Specialty: $49 (serves 14–20)
Custom writing can be added to select cakes with at least one week’s notice. For custom requests, email our amazing cake maker Jo at [email protected]
If you have questions or need help choosing, stop in or send us a message!
Jason and Erik