Key West Cakes

Key West Cakes Paulie Bakes! Established in 2001 A custom cake shop, Paulie Bakes, started by Paulie and Steven in 2001.

We are still Paulie Bakes but due to computer searching we changed our name to Key West Cakes. We are still the same business and owners and with your continued patronage we hope to be for many years to come. WE ALSO MAKE A WIDE VARIETY OF CUPCAKES cinnamon buns, cookies, sliced cake. We have dinners to go, lasagne, baked ziti, chicken pot pies, and a different entree selection weekly.

So many years, so many memories, and so many moments shared together. Grateful for every chapter of our journey and exci...
09/05/2026

So many years, so many memories, and so many moments shared together. Grateful for every chapter of our journey and excited for all the years still ahead. - Paulie and Steven ❤️🧁🍰

Come celebrate and have some goodies to eat.
08/31/2026

Come celebrate and have some goodies to eat.

Our first ever customer of the month award goes to the wonderful Miss Jasmine!🎂🎉 Sweetest Customer of the Month! 🎉For th...
08/21/2026

Our first ever customer of the month award goes to the wonderful Miss Jasmine!🎂
🎉 Sweetest Customer of the Month! 🎉
For the love of cupcakes, we celebrate you!🧁❤️
Thank you for being one of our sweetest supporters!

Bread pudding fresh out of the oven! Guava Bread, Coconut Bread, and our Classic Bread Pudding. Get them before they're ...
08/19/2026

Bread pudding fresh out of the oven! Guava Bread, Coconut Bread, and our Classic Bread Pudding. Get them before they're gone!

It's our 25th Anniversary!
08/14/2026

It's our 25th Anniversary!

08/03/2026

So many flavors to choose from! Comment your favorite cupcake 🧁

Welcome to the new and improved Key West Cakes at 2510 North Roosevelt Blvd. Right next to GFS and Starbucks. We are ope...
07/29/2026

Welcome to the new and improved Key West Cakes at 2510 North Roosevelt Blvd. Right next to GFS and Starbucks. We are open from 9:30 am to 6:00 pm. Mon thru Sat. 🤩🍰🧁

07/27/2026

At long last our doors on White Street have officially closed tonight. 🥲
Our location on 2510 North Roosevelt, next to GFS will be open for business this Wednesday July 29th but feel free to come by tomorrow Tuesday the 28th to place your orders.
We can't wait to see you. 🍪🎂🍰🧁

Our new location is finally being pieced together. This has been a long project and I cannot wait to share it with you. ...
07/13/2026

Our new location is finally being pieced together. This has been a long project and I cannot wait to share it with you. Thank you all for your continued love and support for my little bakery. Love always - Paulie

Hot diggity dog!
07/11/2026

Hot diggity dog!

Address

2510 North Roosevelt Boulevard
Key West, FL
33040

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30am - 7pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 7pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 7pm
Thursday 10:30am - 7pm
Friday 10:30am - 7pm
Saturday 10:30am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Key West Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Key West Cakes:

Shortcuts

Share