Key West Cakes

Key West Cakes Paulie Bakes! Established in 2001 A custom cake shop, Paulie Bakes, started by Paulie and Steven in 2001.

We are still Paulie Bakes but due to computer searching we changed our name to Key West Cakes. We are still the same business and owners and with your continued patronage we hope to be for many years to come. WE ALSO MAKE A WIDE VARIETY OF CUPCAKES cinnamon buns, cookies, sliced cake. We have dinners to go, lasagne, baked ziti, chicken pot pies, and a different entree selection weekly.

"It's a dangerous business, Frodo, going out your door. You step onto the road, and if you don't keep your feet, there's...
05/31/2026

"It's a dangerous business, Frodo, going out your door. You step onto the road, and if you don't keep your feet, there's no knowing where you might be swept off to." - J.R.R. Tolkien

Spotlight on Peanut Butter Cup and Snickers cupcakesWe are still open on White Street, our moving process has been very ...
05/28/2026

Spotlight on Peanut Butter Cup and Snickers cupcakes
We are still open on White Street, our moving process has been very painful and full of construction delays but we are still hopeful that we'll be opening the new location soon 😌

Due to a shortage of pot in key west, we will not be serving chicken pot pie this week. Hopefully by next week we will h...
05/11/2026

Due to a shortage of pot in key west, we will not be serving chicken pot pie this week. Hopefully by next week we will have our pot pie tins back in stock.

Berries and Cream Cupcakes
05/09/2026

Berries and Cream Cupcakes

Apparently 51 is fun. Can anyone confirm or deny this? I'd ask Steven but he's 42 for the 8th year in a row 🤔
04/24/2026

Apparently 51 is fun. Can anyone confirm or deny this? I'd ask Steven but he's 42 for the 8th year in a row 🤔

Hazelnut cupcakes with Nutella
04/17/2026

Hazelnut cupcakes with Nutella

Order up! Cheeseburger in paradise 🍔
04/15/2026

Order up! Cheeseburger in paradise 🍔

One of the largest, heaviest, and unique wedding cakes we've made.Let us know what you think, do you like this idea for ...
04/13/2026

One of the largest, heaviest, and unique wedding cakes we've made.
Let us know what you think, do you like this idea for a wedding, or do you prefer a classic style.

It's all downhill from here baby!That reminds me, Does anyone happen to have the number to Kris Jenner's face lift surge...
04/07/2026

It's all downhill from here baby!
That reminds me, Does anyone happen to have the number to Kris Jenner's face lift surgeon...asking for a friend 👀🥴

Going through my gallery and I found a picture of this pirate ship cake we made almost ten years ago! I wish i had a bet...
04/06/2026

Going through my gallery and I found a picture of this pirate ship cake we made almost ten years ago! I wish i had a better picture of it 😅

Address

1014 White Street Ste 8
Key West, FL
33040

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30am - 7pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 7pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 7pm
Thursday 10:30am - 7pm
Friday 10:30am - 7pm
Saturday 10:30am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Key West Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Key West Cakes:

Shortcuts

Share