Mighty Fine Long Island

Mighty Fine Long Island Now open in Huntington 8am-8pm, Fri & Sat til 10 pm, with great pie, fun meals, coffee, cool cocktails to make your day Mighty Fine! 43 Green Street.

We can't wait to welcome you in and to share our pretty outdoor spaces.

You can now go onto our website and pre-order a Design Your Pie! We are making it even easier for you to create the pie...
07/15/2026

You can now go onto our website and pre-order a Design Your Pie! We are making it even easier for you to create the pie that is just right for you.

You will find our order form on our website: Mightyfinecafe.com
You can select from 10 fruits, three custards and three crusts including a special gluten-free crust.
We request 24 hours advance notice, but can often make a pie in the same day if you give the cafe a call at 631-683-5500.

We are open at 8 AM seven days a week serving an all day café menu with our renowned ribeye sandwich, breakfast sandwiches on buttermilk biscuits, cool salads and more.  Enjoy a cocktail anytime  and especially in our backyard garden bar where Happy Hour is every Friday Saturday and Sunday 3 to 6 PM. 

There's so much that I love in this photo. Lucy, my co-manager hyping up the kitchen team on a Friday afternoon. Ruth ...
07/12/2026

There's so much that I love in this photo. Lucy, my co-manager hyping up the kitchen team on a Friday afternoon. Ruth is smiling her shy smile back even though we can't see the front of her. The just right size of our "magic window" where we pass pies designed by customers into the kitchen to be baked. The multiple paper tickets tracking pies designed by customers. In the right corner is a giant container of fresh made apple pie filling. And hovering over all of it are the many boxes of Hal's Potato Chips that show up in our cookies and with our sandwiches and in our snacks.
We hope you will stop by soon for your own Mighty Fine time.
Open seven days a week at 8 AM
43 Green Street Huntington
631-683-5500

Funky music and the Norway England game tonight at the Upper Crust
07/11/2026

Funky music and the Norway England game tonight at the Upper Crust

07/02/2026

The heat moved us to put this staff pick on the menu! Stop in for an awesome Iced Latte Affogato. Add one of our housemade syrups if you like... Blueberry🫐.... Brown Sugar Cinnamon or other treat.

We are closed on the 4th of July. So stop in and pick up an apple pie, a blueberry crumb pie or other delight Friday and...
07/01/2026

We are closed on the 4th of July. So stop in and pick up an apple pie, a blueberry crumb pie or other delight Friday and Sunday 8 AM to 8 PM.
Call us for pre-orders. 631-683-5500
43 Green Street Huntington
Great indoor and outdoor seating, family friendly putting green and foosball table. Free parking across the street.
(And yes, this photo was taken in our café.)

Whatever time of day you come by, we have a wide variety of fresh made food and good drinks at Mighty Fine in Huntington...
06/26/2026

Whatever time of day you come by, we have a wide variety of fresh made food and good drinks at Mighty Fine in Huntington. Come in for breakfast or a warm chocolate chip cookie. Bring a friend for lunch for a beautiful salad or our famous ribeye sandwich. We offer a variety of gluten-free and vegetarian items. Happy hour cocktails Friday Saturday and Sunday 3 to 6 PM. And a casual all day menu that extends to dinner with treats like house roasted chicken that is loved by Erica Marcus of Newsday.  And we are family friendly with a putting green in our front yard and foosball in our backyard.
Open seven days a week at 8 AM
43 Green St Huntington
631 683 5500
Free parking across the street

Lots of great reasons to grab a friend and visit Mighty Fine in Huntington. We have beautiful outdoor seating and are h...
06/20/2026

Lots of great reasons to grab a friend and visit Mighty Fine in Huntington. We have beautiful outdoor seating and are hosting awesome live music for free on Sunday, June 28. Plus we have such wonderful food and pie that we made the cover of Newsday Explore Long Island section.

Our outdoor bar is called The Upper Crust and is open Friday Saturday and Sunday. Happy hour specials 3 to 6 PM each day. $10 cocktails and including espresso martinis, half-price glasses of wine and $6 beers. We have the World Cup on the TV.

And come visit the café any day. We are open seven days a week starting at 8 AM. Get your BEC sandwich on our homemade buttermilk biscuit. Dive into a ribeye sandwich, enjoy crunchy cool salads, and save room for some awesome pie.

Free parking across the street. Dog friendly front yard. Family friendly backyard with foosball and co****le and more.

Call us at 631-683-5500 with any questions.

Wow! Thank you Newsday for putting us on the cover. I guess we owe you a slice of that Peanut Butter Brownie Pie now.I...
06/18/2026

Wow! Thank you Newsday for putting us on the cover. I guess we owe you a slice of that Peanut Butter Brownie Pie now.
If you haven't made it to Mighty Fine yet, stop in any day for pie, cool cocktails and a ribeye sandwich. We open at 8 AM every day so you can get your BEC on our buttermilk biscuit.
Happy Hour Specials Friday Saturday and Sunday 3 to 6 PM indoors and at our lovely backyard bar known as The Upper Crust 
43 Green Street Huntington.
Free parking across the street.

Address

43 Green Street
Huntington, NY
11743

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 8pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Wednesday 8am - 8pm
Thursday 8am - 8pm
Friday 8am - 10pm
Saturday 8am - 10pm
Sunday 8am - 8pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mighty Fine Long Island posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mighty Fine Long Island:

Shortcuts

Share

Category