Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant

Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant Pie Shop and Restaurant. We make 34 different Pies Daily. We make everything from Traditional Pecan to Reeces (Peanut Butter & Chocolate) and Gooseberry.

Operating as usual

We are starting the Countdown to Carmel Arts & Design District PorchFest! September 19th our Pop-Up Pie Shop will be ser...
09/10/2021

We are starting the Countdown to Carmel Arts & Design District PorchFest! September 19th our Pop-Up Pie Shop will be serving up pies and with our favorite local bands. We will have slices and whole pies for sale. For whole pie pre-order and more info go to http://ow.ly/tQmJ50G7Uym

We are starting the Countdown to Carmel Arts & Design District PorchFest! September 19th our Pop-Up Pie Shop will be serving up pies and with our favorite local bands. We will have slices and whole pies for sale. For whole pie pre-order and more info go to http://ow.ly/tQmJ50G7Uym

Martha Stewart takes her best shot at Sugar Cream Pie. She forgot an important ingredient. Can you guess what it is?
08/27/2021
Martha Stewart’s Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie | Martha Bakes Recipes

Martha Stewart takes her best shot at Sugar Cream Pie. She forgot an important ingredient. Can you guess what it is?

Martha Stewart shares her recipe for the official pie of Indiana: the Indiana sugar cream pie (also known as a hoosier pie or desperation pie). This fruit-fr...

Just 3 days until Artomobilia at the Carmel Arts & Design District where we will be serving up some of our favorite pies...
08/25/2021

Just 3 days until Artomobilia at the Carmel Arts & Design District where we will be serving up some of our favorite pies from Sugar Cream Pie to Cherry Berry (pictured). You can find us on the corner of Main Street and Veteran's Way in Carmel.

Whole Pie PRE-ORDER for this event is available until midnight Thursday. visit www.mrswickspopup.com for more info

#pie #eatlocal #indiana

Just add fruit for a great pie! Have you ever used our baked shells with our fruit glaze to make your own pie. Having tr...
07/27/2021

Just add fruit for a great pie! Have you ever used our baked shells with our fruit glaze to make your own pie. Having trouble finding our baked shell in stores? Simply pick up a raw shell at most retailers (Kroger, Fresh Thyme, Meijer, Baesler's and more) and bake it yourself. Pro-tip poke the bottom of the empty shell with a fork to prevent bubbling.

Just add fruit for a great pie! Have you ever used our baked shells with our fruit glaze to make your own pie. Having trouble finding our baked shell in stores? Simply pick up a raw shell at most retailers (Kroger, Fresh Thyme, Meijer, Baesler's and more) and bake it yourself. Pro-tip poke the bottom of the empty shell with a fork to prevent bubbling.

*REMINDER* We will be closed on SATURDAY, JULY 24th. Sorry for the inconvenience. We will open back up with normal busin...
07/24/2021

*REMINDER* We will be closed on SATURDAY, JULY 24th. Sorry for the inconvenience. We will open back up with normal business hours on Monday, July 26th. Please share this post ☺️

*REMINDER* We will be closed on SATURDAY, JULY 24th. Sorry for the inconvenience. We will open back up with normal business hours on Monday, July 26th. Please share this post ☺️

It's almost the weekend. This strawberry shortcake recipe using Wick's Pie Crust is sure to be a nice treat on a hot day...
07/23/2021

It's almost the weekend. This strawberry shortcake recipe using Wick's Pie Crust is sure to be a nice treat on a hot day. Find us in your local grocery or online at Goldbelly

It's almost the weekend. This strawberry shortcake recipe using Wick's Pie Crust is sure to be a nice treat on a hot day. Find us in your local grocery or online at Goldbelly

Mrs. Wick’s will be closed on Saturday, July 24th. We will open back up with normal business hours on Monday, July 26th....
07/15/2021

Mrs. Wick’s will be closed on Saturday, July 24th. We will open back up with normal business hours on Monday, July 26th. Sorry for the inconvenience. Please feel free to share! Thank you!

Mrs. Wick’s will be closed on Saturday, July 24th. We will open back up with normal business hours on Monday, July 26th. Sorry for the inconvenience. Please feel free to share! Thank you!

Happy National Pecan Pie Day! Can you guess how many ingredients are in our pecan pie filling? There are just 6 in our c...
07/12/2021

Happy National Pecan Pie Day! Can you guess how many ingredients are in our pecan pie filling? There are just 6 in our crust.

Happy National Pecan Pie Day! Can you guess how many ingredients are in our pecan pie filling? There are just 6 in our crust.

07/12/2021

Good morning! We just wanted to let everyone know that we are having issues with our phone this morning. If you call in and it hangs up on you, we are not doing it on purpose. The issue is being worked on now, hopefully we will be back up and running smoothly soon! Sorry for the inconvenience.

07/04/2021

Happy 4th of July! Hopefully we make it to your table today. Thought we would share a new commercial we're running in the Indy market. Stay safe out there.

#America #july4th #pie #indy #visitindy #eatlocal #fireworks

Take your Chevy to the levy for this American Pie. Enjoy a happy and safe July 4th with this Hoosier favorite. Sold here...
06/29/2021

Take your Chevy to the levy for this American Pie. Enjoy a happy and safe July 4th with this Hoosier favorite. Sold here in Wi******er, Indiana groceries or online at wickspies.com. Share this post and Tag a friend or family member for a chance at a FREE PIE shipped directly to their door. We'll choose the winner on July 4th.

Take your Chevy to the levy for this American Pie. Enjoy a happy and safe July 4th with this Hoosier favorite. Sold here in Wi******er, Indiana groceries or online at wickspies.com. Share this post and Tag a friend or family member for a chance at a FREE PIE shipped directly to their door. We'll choose the winner on July 4th.

Fireworks, Family, Friends and Pie. Who are you celebrating Independence Day with? Tag them below for a chance at a FREE...
06/27/2021

Fireworks, Family, Friends and Pie. Who are you celebrating Independence Day with? Tag them below for a chance at a FREE PIE. Pickup in store, in your local grocery frozen section, or order online with Nationwide Free Shipping at www.goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

Fireworks, Family, Friends and Pie. Who are you celebrating Independence Day with? Tag them below for a chance at a FREE PIE. Pickup in store, in your local grocery frozen section, or order online with Nationwide Free Shipping at www.goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

July 4th is in 10 days! Celebrate Freedom with the most American dessert. Pick up a pie in store or online at Goldbelly....
06/24/2021

July 4th is in 10 days! Celebrate Freedom with the most American dessert. Pick up a pie in store or online at Goldbelly.com/wicks-pies
Have you ever added berries to one of our Sugar Cream Pies?

July 4th is in 10 days! Celebrate Freedom with the most American dessert. Pick up a pie in store or online at Goldbelly.com/wicks-pies
Have you ever added berries to one of our Sugar Cream Pies?

Fathers Day is Sunday. What do you get a dad that has everything. May sure you have pie for dessert. Our slightly salty ...
06/14/2021

Fathers Day is Sunday. What do you get a dad that has everything. May sure you have pie for dessert. Our slightly salty crust pairs great with a stiff drink. Between our Southern Pecan Pie or any of our other 38 flavors we have a pie for every dad. Reserve your pie today for pickup before 2pm on Saturday.

Fathers Day is Sunday. What do you get a dad that has everything. May sure you have pie for dessert. Our slightly salty crust pairs great with a stiff drink. Between our Southern Pecan Pie or any of our other 38 flavors we have a pie for every dad. Reserve your pie today for pickup before 2pm on Saturday.

Dad isn't into cake. He likes the slightly salty pie crust that goes great with a Guinness or a bourbon. Our bourbon whi...
06/12/2021

Dad isn't into cake. He likes the slightly salty pie crust that goes great with a Guinness or a bourbon. Our bourbon whipped cream recipe consists of Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Heavy Whipping Cream and powdered sugar. It's wonderful on top of our Sugar Cream Pie (not that it needs it).
If you can't make it in to the pie shop or to the many stores that carry us then Order online at www.goldbelly.com/wicks-pies and enjoy $20 off with LOVEDAD20. Order cutoff is Wednesday at noon for delivery by father's day.

Dad isn't into cake. He likes the slightly salty pie crust that goes great with a Guinness or a bourbon. Our bourbon whipped cream recipe consists of Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Heavy Whipping Cream and powdered sugar. It's wonderful on top of our Sugar Cream Pie (not that it needs it).
If you can't make it in to the pie shop or to the many stores that carry us then Order online at www.goldbelly.com/wicks-pies and enjoy $20 off with LOVEDAD20. Order cutoff is Wednesday at noon for delivery by father's day.

It's race day. Pie is served. Enjoy the long weekend. Show is your race day spread for a chance at free pie.#eatpie #ind...
05/30/2021

It's race day. Pie is served. Enjoy the long weekend. Show is your race day spread for a chance at free pie.

#eatpie #indy500

It's race day. Pie is served. Enjoy the long weekend. Show is your race day spread for a chance at free pie.

#eatpie #indy500

We are preparing for a big race weekend here at Mrs. Wick's. We will be open Saturday until 2:00 pm. Come out and get yo...
05/27/2021

We are preparing for a big race weekend here at Mrs. Wick's. We will be open Saturday until 2:00 pm. Come out and get your pies while supplies last!

Calling all Indy 500 fans! Near and far! Grab a pie and be the life of the party. Wick's Pies are available at Mrs. Wick...
05/24/2021

Calling all Indy 500 fans! Near and far! Grab a pie and be the life of the party. Wick's Pies are available at Mrs. Wick's along with over 30 flavors made by hand in the store. Find a pie the entire family loves.

Stop in and try one! We'd love to have you for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and pie! Call us at (765)584-7437 or stop in at 100 N Cherry St, Wi******er, IN 47394.

Calling all Indy 500 fans! Near and far! Grab a pie and be the life of the party. Wick's Pies are available at Mrs. Wick's along with over 30 flavors made by hand in the store. Find a pie the entire family loves.

Stop in and try one! We'd love to have you for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and pie! Call us at (765)584-7437 or stop in at 100 N Cherry St, Wi******er, IN 47394.

Are you hosting a RACE DAY party? We've got dessert covered! Call us at (765)584 - 7437 to place your order. With over 3...
05/21/2021

Are you hosting a RACE DAY party? We've got dessert covered! Call us at (765)584 - 7437 to place your order. With over 30 options to choose from find a pie everyone loves!

Mrs. Wick's is located at 100 N Cherry St, Wi******er, IN 47394 stop in for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Try the pie for dessert!

Are you hosting a RACE DAY party? We've got dessert covered! Call us at (765)584 - 7437 to place your order. With over 30 options to choose from find a pie everyone loves!

Mrs. Wick's is located at 100 N Cherry St, Wi******er, IN 47394 stop in for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Try the pie for dessert!

As your loved one's Graduation approaches or passes celebrate with a simple and delicious Mrs. Wick's or Wick's Pie. Wha...
05/18/2021

As your loved one's Graduation approaches or passes celebrate with a simple and delicious Mrs. Wick's or Wick's Pie. What is your grad's favorite pie?

Order by phone at (765)584-7437 or stop in and pick one up. If you aren't in town have a Wick's Pie shipped directly to your door with Goldbelly's Nationwide shipping. Order at goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

As your loved one's Graduation approaches or passes celebrate with a simple and delicious Mrs. Wick's or Wick's Pie. What is your grad's favorite pie?

Order by phone at (765)584-7437 or stop in and pick one up. If you aren't in town have a Wick's Pie shipped directly to your door with Goldbelly's Nationwide shipping. Order at goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

Today is National Apple Day 🍎🍏Some call it Apple Crumb and others call it Dutch apple. We think it's Delicious! Find it ...
05/13/2021

Today is National Apple Day 🍎🍏Some call it Apple Crumb and others call it Dutch apple. We think it's Delicious! Find it at Mrs. Wick's here in Wi******er.
#eatmorepie #pielovers #nationalappleday #fortheloveofpie #eatlocal #pie

Today is National Apple Day 🍎🍏Some call it Apple Crumb and others call it Dutch apple. We think it's Delicious! Find it at Mrs. Wick's here in Wi******er.
#eatmorepie #pielovers #nationalappleday #fortheloveofpie #eatlocal #pie

Happy Mother's Day! Join us in celebrating Moms everywhere! Tag your Mom in the comments below to enter her to win a FRE...
05/09/2021

Happy Mother's Day! Join us in celebrating Moms everywhere! Tag your Mom in the comments below to enter her to win a FREE PIE shipped directly to her door!

Wick's Pies is a family owned business; without the Moms involved, we wouldn't be here! We love you Mom!

Happy Mother's Day! Join us in celebrating Moms everywhere! Tag your Mom in the comments below to enter her to win a FREE PIE shipped directly to her door!

Wick's Pies is a family owned business; without the Moms involved, we wouldn't be here! We love you Mom!

Strawberry pie is back! Mrs. Wicks closes at 2 pm today. Stop in to pick up your pie order or grab a pie from the case! ...
05/08/2021

Strawberry pie is back! Mrs. Wicks closes at 2 pm today. Stop in to pick up your pie order or grab a pie from the case!

Have a great weekend!

Strawberry pie is back! Mrs. Wicks closes at 2 pm today. Stop in to pick up your pie order or grab a pie from the case!

Have a great weekend!

Today is the last day to order pies before Mother's Day! Call us at Mrs. Wick's at (765)546-7437 to place your order!We ...
05/07/2021

Today is the last day to order pies before Mother's Day! Call us at Mrs. Wick's at (765)546-7437 to place your order!

We hope you and your Mom can enjoy a piece of pie together this Mother's Day! We are excited to celebrate our Mom's, we'll see you tomorrow to pick up your pies! If you haven't placed an order it will be first come first serve tomorrow!

Today is the last day to order pies before Mother's Day! Call us at Mrs. Wick's at (765)546-7437 to place your order!

We hope you and your Mom can enjoy a piece of pie together this Mother's Day! We are excited to celebrate our Mom's, we'll see you tomorrow to pick up your pies! If you haven't placed an order it will be first come first serve tomorrow!

Tomorrow is the last day to order pies before Mother's Day! If you are in or around Wi******er, IN. Call us at (765)546-...
05/06/2021

Tomorrow is the last day to order pies before Mother's Day! If you are in or around Wi******er, IN. Call us at (765)546-7437.

With 36 flavors to choose from you can find a pie for everyone!

Tomorrow is the last day to order pies before Mother's Day! If you are in or around Wi******er, IN. Call us at (765)546-7437.

With 36 flavors to choose from you can find a pie for everyone!

🍓🍓Just in time for Mother’s Day! 🍓🍓Our fresh strawberry pie will be available this Saturday, May 8th! We always suggest ...
05/06/2021

🍓🍓Just in time for Mother’s Day! 🍓🍓
Our fresh strawberry pie will be available this Saturday, May 8th! We always suggest calling the restaurant and placing an order for one to guarantee you get yours. Orders need to be placed by Friday, May 7th. You can call the restaurant at (765) 584-PIES (7437). Our hours are Monday-Friday from 6:00 am-6:00 pm. Saturday we are open 6:00 am-2:00 pm.

🍓🍓Just in time for Mother’s Day! 🍓🍓
Our fresh strawberry pie will be available this Saturday, May 8th! We always suggest calling the restaurant and placing an order for one to guarantee you get yours. Orders need to be placed by Friday, May 7th. You can call the restaurant at (765) 584-PIES (7437). Our hours are Monday-Friday from 6:00 am-6:00 pm. Saturday we are open 6:00 am-2:00 pm.

Celebrate Cinco De Mayo with a new recipe! We call it the Pie-garita!Ingredients:1 package of Wick's fully baked pie she...
05/05/2021

Celebrate Cinco De Mayo with a new recipe! We call it the Pie-garita!

Ingredients:
1 package of Wick's fully baked pie shells
16oz. cream cheese, softenend
1 cup sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup lime juice
1 tbsp lime zest
1/4 cup sugar

Directions:
Crush 1 pie shell into crumbs and place in bottom of glasses
Mix filling ingredients ingredients together until smooth and spoon into glasses
Refrigerate for 2+ hours
Enjoy!

**Shells can be purchased at Mrs. Wick's

Call Mrs. Wick's today at (765)546-7437 to place your pie order before Mother's Day! The last day to order is Friday, Ma...
05/05/2021

Call Mrs. Wick's today at (765)546-7437 to place your pie order before Mother's Day! The last day to order is Friday, May 7, 2021.

Celebrate your Mom by bringing the dessert!

Call Mrs. Wick's today at (765)546-7437 to place your pie order before Mother's Day! The last day to order is Friday, May 7, 2021.

Celebrate your Mom by bringing the dessert!

If you live in or around Wi******er, the last day to order pies at Mrs. Wick's before Mother's Day is Friday, May 7, 202...
05/04/2021

If you live in or around Wi******er, the last day to order pies at Mrs. Wick's before Mother's Day is Friday, May 7, 2021. Pick from among 36 different flavors of pie and call (765)546-7437 to place your order. Celebrate your Mom with her favorite dessert this Mother's Day!

If you can't make it to Wi******er tomorrow is the deadline to order online. Order at goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

If you live in or around Wi******er, the last day to order pies at Mrs. Wick's before Mother's Day is Friday, May 7, 2021. Pick from among 36 different flavors of pie and call (765)546-7437 to place your order. Celebrate your Mom with her favorite dessert this Mother's Day!

If you can't make it to Wi******er tomorrow is the deadline to order online. Order at goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

04/29/2021
Wick's Pies Time for Mom_1.mp4

Mother's Day is right around the corner. Send mom pie so she doesn't have to bake for herself. Schedule your delivery date for next week. Shipping Nationwide on Goldbelly (shipping included) use code luvmama15 for $15 off your first order at www.goldbelly.com/wicks-pies

Happy Earth Day! Did you know we ship green? Our insulated foam is made from corn and fully compostable! We've been ship...
04/22/2021

Happy Earth Day! Did you know we ship green? Our insulated foam is made from corn and fully compostable! We've been shipping nationwide for the last 9 months, and we recently made this upgrade to our packaging to do our part in keeping our earth clean. All the plastic in our pie packaging is recyclable, and our ice packs are reusable as well. Don't forget to recycle the box!

Happy Earth Day! Did you know we ship green? Our insulated foam is made from corn and fully compostable! We've been shipping nationwide for the last 9 months, and we recently made this upgrade to our packaging to do our part in keeping our earth clean. All the plastic in our pie packaging is recyclable, and our ice packs are reusable as well. Don't forget to recycle the box!

Well it was a long journey with many flavors to overcome, but #SugarCreamPie was victorious in this year's #piemadness. ...
04/13/2021

Well it was a long journey with many flavors to overcome, but #SugarCreamPie was victorious in this year's #piemadness. Our bracket winner is @kevalina_davis she's getting 2 pies ship anywhere in the US.

Well it was a long journey with many flavors to overcome, but #SugarCreamPie was victorious in this year's #piemadness. Our bracket winner is @kevalina_davis she's getting 2 pies ship anywhere in the US.

Address

100 Cherry Street
Wi******er, IN
47394

Opening Hours

Monday 6am - 6pm
Tuesday 6am - 6pm
Wednesday 6am - 6pm
Thursday 6am - 6pm
Friday 6am - 6pm
Saturday 6am - 2pm

Telephone

(765) 584-7437

Services

  • Groups
  • Kids
  • Reserve
  • Takeout
  • Waiter
  • Walkins

Specialties

  • Breakfast
  • Coffee
  • Dinner
  • Lunch

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant:

Videos

Nearby restaurants


Other American restaurants in Wi******er

Show All

Comments

I just have to share... Today I stopped by & ordered a chicken salad sandwich to go. As I was driving away, I started to eat it and realized I had never tasted a sandwich like it before. It was good, but just did not taste like any chicken salad I had ever had. About half way through, I stopped so I could examine it. And I discovered it was not chicken salad, but potato salad! It was a potato salad sandwich! 😂 And it was actually really yummy! So thank you for giving me something I’ve never had before! 😆
Great job on the food this morning. Happy New Years
Cream pie is our the one we like best, will be in Indiana last of this July or first of Aug.😘
Love to eat at Mrs. Wick's when I'm in Wi******er. Wish I could have a piece of their Strawberry Rhubarb pie. It is my favorite!
Thank you Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant for offering carryout during this time! We had dinner from you tonight and really enjoyed it! The double bacon cheeseburgers were huge and tasted great, the salad we ordered was larger than expected and delicious, and the Alley Oop was way better than the other well known version offered by another chain. Looking forward to the sugar cream pie and peanut butter pie for desert later!
Our Aunt bought pumpkin pies directly from the factory. They look great and are wrapped in cellophane when you order them. Today when we went to go eat it we found out that it was actually peanut butter cream pie. I wouldn’t necessarily be upset except my boyfriend is allergic to tree nuts and he was the first to take a bite. There was no label on the pie and nothing on the internet at all. Can anyone tell what the ingredients are?
Thank you so much for your donation of pies for the Soldiers of the 2-13th Aviation Regiment in Fort Huachuca, Arizona! We all truly appreciate your support!
I'm back!!!!
Thank you Mrs Wicks Pies and Restaurant for making our visitor Wicks Pie day in Wi******er enjoyable. All staff was helpful , kind and professional. Food and of course the Pie was WONDERFUL.
Staff was awesome !!!! We wanted to take some pies back to South Carolina with us as my wife is from Wi******er & grew up eating there. As we had a 12 hour drive ahead of us we got there at 6:15 am and they made our ordered pies out of there bulk baking sequence so we didn't have to wait till 10:30 am. Will always be grateful for there extra effort
Lovely fall decor, great job Brittany Keen!!!!
Breakfast at Mrs. Wick's, new Fall decor is very lovely and seasonal. New entry way inviting, welcoming, informative and stylish!! Nice job Brittany!!!!