The Cookie Cottage WNY

09/03/2026

SOLD OUT!! As of 4:00 p.m. on Thursday September 3rd, we are officially sold out and on vacation for Labor Day!

We will return for normal hours at noon on Tuesday September 8th!

Have a wonderful weekend!!!

09/03/2026

3:30pm update-not sold out yet, but we're getting very very close!! When we are sold out and our last few orders are picked up we will be heading home to start our vacation! We will return on Tuesday at 12:00 p.m. for normal hours next week!

Blueberry Pie Bars-2
Strawberry Lemonade -8
Cotton Candy -1
Creamsicle -1
Orange Chocolate -1
Chocolate Strawberry -6
Crunch Berries -13

Pina Colada -8

09/03/2026

Guess what we have?????? Delicious Crumb bars

Apple Crumb bars (Full Pan) $15
Blueberry Crumb bars (Full Pan) $15

09/03/2026

Happy Thursday!! Reminder, we will be closing when we sell out today and will not be open again until noon on Tuesday 9/7.

Varieties for Thursday 9/3:

Chocolate Chip
Unicorn
Italian Ricotta
Trash
Cotton Candy
M&M
Cheesecake Sprinkle
Caramel Macchiato Thumbprints
The Blackout
Pumpkin
Molasses
Oatmeal Raisin
Creamsicle
Cherry Pie
Crunch Berries
Apple Crumb Pie Bar
Blueberry Crumb Pie Bar
Butterbeer
Sponge Candy Crunch
Cannoli
Strawberry Lemonade
Orange Chocolate
Cinnabomb
Chocolate Strawberry

Nut Varieties:
Peanut Butter
Pina Colada

Don't forget to stock up on WanderingGypsy Brewing Company lattes for the weekend!

We are fully stocked on Hoover's juice products including iced tea fruit punch lemonade and orange drink. We currently only have strawberry milk and whole milk. With our closure for the long weekend, we will not be getting a Hoover's delivery this week.

EZ Catering has chicken salad and the following $5 mini pies:
Apple Crumb
Chocolate Pecan
Peach

09/02/2026

Thank you to customer Laurie for the eggplant hubby used to make me some eggplant parm for dinner tonight!

I just realized I also forgot to take pictures of all the delicious produce that customer Becky brought us after we did cookies for her daughter's wedding!

09/02/2026

Happy Wednesday!! Open 12-6 today and tomorrow from 10 until we sell out! Closed Friday through Monday to celebrate Labor Day weekend with our families.

Fresh DiCamillos bread was picked up this morning.

Varieties for Wednesday 9/2:
Chocolate Chip
Italian Ricotta
Fireball
Cottage House
Caramel Filled Chocolate Chip
M&M
Unicorn
Confetti
Birthday Cake
Funnel Cake
Snickerdoodles
Oatmeal Raisin
Trash
The BIB
Brownie
Cotton Candy

Nut Varieties:
Peanut Butter
Caramel Pecan Turtle
The Hoff
Pistachio

Fully stocked on WanderingGypsy Brewing Company Matcha, Mocha, Banana Bread and Oatmeal Cookie Lattes!

EZ Catering has chicken salad, Beef Lasagna Soup and the following $5 mini pies:
Chocolate Cream
Apple
Apple Crumb
Triple Berry
Cherry
Chocolate Pecan

09/01/2026

Happy Tuesday, it's a warm first day of September, perfect cookie weather!

We are open today and tomorrow 12-6 and Thursday we will be open from 10 until we sell out, our best estimate is 4pm but we will keep you informed that afternoon.

We will be closed Friday 9/4-Monday 9/7 to celebrate a little vacation with our families.

LET US KNOW IF YOU NEED DICAMILLO'S BREAD BY 4:00 P.M. TODAY!! Tomorrow will be our only pickup this week.

Varieties for TUESDAY 9/1:
Chocolate Chip
Italian Ricotta
Fireball
Raspberry Thumbprint
Caramel Filled Chocolate Chip
M&M
Unicorn
Maple Brown
Churro
*NEW* Funnel Cake stuffed (stuffed with a new Funnel Cake Oreo-like cookie!)
Snickerdoodles
Oatmeal Raisin
Trash
Cottage House
Confetti
Birthday Cake
The BIB
Brownie
Cotton Candy

Nut Varieties:
Peanut Butter
Caramel Pecan Turtle
The Hoff
Pistachio

We're fully stocked on WanderingGypsy Brewing Company lattes!! $6 each:
Matcha
Mocha
Banana Bread
Oatmeal Cookie (dairy free)

Fully stocked on Hoovers whole milk, chocolate milk, strawberry milk, iced tea, fruit punch, lemonade and iced tea. We will NOT have a delivery this week since we will be closed on our normal delivery day.

EZ Catering has stocked up their cooler with classic chicken salad, Beef Lasagna Soup and the following $5 mini pies:
Chocolate Cream
Peach
Apple
Triple Berry
Apple Crumb
Cherry
Chocolate Pecan

09/01/2026

UPDATE TO OUR HOURS FOR THIS WEEK!!

TUESDAY 9/1
12-6

WEDNESDAY 9/2
12-6

THURSDAY 9/3
10-SOLD OUT
(LIKELY AROUND 4PM)

CLOSED FRIDAY 9/4-MONDAY 9/7

WE WILL BE ON VACATION TO CELEBRATE LABOR DAY

Send a message to learn more

08/30/2026

Added bonus that comes with selling WanderingGypsy Brewing Company bottled lattes? Pickup day means a delicious brunch with hubby! Biscuits-always-and their new apple garlic jam breakfast sandwich hit the spot!!

Extra bonus was that I was able to grab a pack of peach cobbler cinnamon buns for later from Rachel of Three Little Hens and chat with her about her bakery that will be opening in Youngstown!

Love seeing small businesses succeed!!

08/30/2026

Tray up an order with me!

This set is for my little buddy "Moose" who is turning 1!! These cookies were decorated last night, spent a little time in the dehydrator to set the icing, had their "photo shoot" and then were arranged on a tray for his party.

Happy birthday Moose!!!