Gray House Pies

Today’s Dumb Deal of the Day is officially loose.THE DUMB FOURFour Detroit-style pizzas.Cheese and Pepperoni.You choose ...
09/10/2026

Today’s Dumb Deal of the Day is officially loose.

THE DUMB FOUR

Four Detroit-style pizzas.
Cheese and Pepperoni.
You choose the combination.

SAVE $20.

We made exactly FOUR of these deals available because apparently we enjoy creating tiny pizza shortages.

The deal disappears tonight or when all four sell — whichever comes first.

GO GET THE DUMB DEAL.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

 # # KINDA DUMB DEAL OF THE AFTERNOONWe have a new sausage roll.There is one small problem.**It doesn't contain sausage....
09/09/2026

# # KINDA DUMB DEAL OF THE AFTERNOON

We have a new sausage roll.

There is one small problem.

**It doesn't contain sausage.**

This is generally considered a weakness in a sausage roll.

Instead, it contains **potatoes and cheese.**

Which raises an important question:

**What the hell do we call it?**

A Potato Roll?

No. That's bread.

A Cheese Roll?

Sounds like something involving Velveeta and a church basement.

A Potato & Cheese Roll?

Accurate, but it has all the marketing excitement of **Replacement Furnace Filter.**

A Vegetarian Sausage Roll?

There is no sausage.

Calling it a vegetarian sausage roll is like calling a canoe a **motorless speedboat.**

A Sausageless Sausage Roll?

Now we're getting somewhere.

So we turned to Britain.

The British invented sausage rolls, and they have names for things like **bangers, spotted dick, bubble and squeak, toad in the hole** and **Welsh rarebit**, which contains neither rabbit nor, as far as we can tell, Wales.

Surely these people could help.

They could not.

So for now we're calling them:

# # CHEESE & POTATO ROLLS.

Brilliant.

Twenty-two years of marketing experience right there.

Anyway, they're terrific.

Cheesy potato filling wrapped in flaky puff pastry and baked until we briefly forget that we're supposed to be figuring out what to call them.

And because they're new, we're doing an introductory deal.

We can't call it the **Dumb Deal of the Day** because:

**A)** This isn't particularly dumb. We're introducing a new product.

**B)** We already have a Dumb Deal of the Day running.

Please see the previous email if you've lost track of our increasingly complicated discount infrastructure.

Therefore, we proudly announce:

# THE KINDA DUMB DEAL OF THE AFTERNOON™

**CHEESE & POTATO ROLLS — $2 EACH.**

**TODAY ONLY.**

There is one additional complication.

Our marketing department was too lazy to put the $2 deal online.

Our marketing department is Pie Man.

So you cannot order the $2 deal online.

# # YOU HAVE TO COME IN.

Walk through the door.

Say something like:

**“I'd like some of those sausage rolls without the sausage.”**

We'll know what you mean.

Now, if you're thinking bigger—

Maybe you want **10**.

Maybe you want **24**.

Maybe you want **123**, which is an oddly specific number but we respect a person with a plan.

**Call the shop.**

We'll work something out.

With enough notice, we can probably make you a few dozen of these tasty little ditties.

Or perhaps **diddies.**

We briefly wondered whether the British call small delicious things “ditties.”

They do not.

A ditty is a short, simple song.

So technically these aren't ditties either.

Which leaves us exactly where we started.

We have made something.

It contains potatoes.

It contains cheese.

It is wrapped in puff pastry.

It costs **$2 this afternoon.**

And we have absolutely no idea what to call it.

# # COME EAT ONE.

Naming rights may eventually be awarded to the public.

— Gray House Pies

# # # OH, ONE FINAL MATTER.

This new product has created a serious accounting problem.

**Do Cheese & Potato Rolls count toward our ongoing effort to overtake Great Britain as the world's leading seller of sausage rolls?**

At first the answer seems obvious.

**No.**

They don't contain sausage.

And traditionally this has been one of the stricter requirements for something called a **sausage roll.**

However, the matter becomes considerably more complicated upon further examination.

**Exhibit A:** They were directly inspired by our sausage rolls.

**Exhibit B:** They're made exactly like our sausage rolls, except somebody removed the sausage and replaced it with potatoes and cheese.

**Exhibit C:** If you put a Cheese & Potato Roll next to a Sausage Roll and squint, you can't tell the difference.

This is accepted methodology in several branches of science.

And finally—and this is where we believe our case becomes extremely strong—

**we're betting the British are counting them.**

You cannot tell us a country with vegan sausage rolls, vegetarian sausage rolls, meatless sausage rolls and God knows what else is suddenly getting strict about the definition of sausage when somebody from Cleveland starts closing the gap.

So we're referring the matter to the **Gray House International Sausage Roll Competition Rules Committee**, which currently consists of Pie Man sitting at a desk.

A ruling is expected shortly.

Until then, we're putting an asterisk next to every Cheese & Potato Roll sold.

Britain has been warned.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

There were three pies.This was enough.The first was **CARAMEL APPLE PIE.**We peeled the apples.We baked the pie.Then we ...
09/09/2026

There were three pies.

This was enough.

The first was **CARAMEL APPLE PIE.**

We peeled the apples.

We baked the pie.

Then we poured our house-made caramel over the top.

It was a good pie.

Soon you will be able to get peanuts on top.

Then it will be a good pie with peanuts.

Life moves forward.

The second was **FRENCH ONION QUICHE.**

The onions were caramelized slowly.

There was thyme.

There was Swiss cheese.

The French had nothing to do with making it.

They will probably take credit anyway.

The third was **BUCKEYE CREAM PIE.**

This required more explanation.

We made peanut butter **crème pâtissière.**

That is French for pastry cream.

It tastes better in French.

We put it into a chocolate cookie crust lined with a thin layer of real chocolate.

Then came whipped cream.

Then chocolate ganache.

There was nothing left to add.

So we stopped.

These are the Pies & Quiche of the Week.

Come get them.

# # # ALSO:

There are still **FOUR DUMB DEALS** remaining from yesterday.

This was not the plan.

Dumb Deals are supposed to disappear.

These did not.

So they will remain available until **the end of today or until they sell out, whichever comes first.**

Then they will be gone.

The sun will set.

Tomorrow will come.

There will be other pies.

— Gray House Pies

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

Are you on the GOOEY BUTTER CAKE band wagon???How about a FREE slice this WEDNESDAY??Huh, you don't even know what Gooey...
09/08/2026

Are you on the GOOEY BUTTER CAKE band wagon???

How about a FREE slice this WEDNESDAY??
Huh, you don't even know what Gooey Butter Cake is?!?
Oh no!

Gooey Butter Cake: the uproarious rockstar of American desserts, flaunting its sumptuous audacity like a dessert daredevil. Imagine a sugar-coated pillow fight between clouds and rainbows, with a gooey wrestling match in the center. It's the dessert that turned gooeyness into an art form, leaving taste buds swooning like teenage fans at a pop concert. This confectionery diva has a gravitational pull stronger than a black hole of yumminess, with fans declaring it the official currency of dessert utopia. So addictive, it should come with a warning label: "Caution - may induce uncontrollable cravings and enthusiastic air guitar solos."

A little over the top? Maybe. Maybe not!
Anyway, enjoy a free slice with any $10 purchase THIS WEDNESDAY ONLY (and only if you mention this message - only people in 'our circle'
get FREE GOOEY CAKE.)
(blah blah blah 'legal' stuff; not available with any other promotion, discount or giveaway)

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

🚨 DUMB DEAL OF THE DAY 🚨Something brand new is hiding on our website.You haven’t seen it before.We’re not telling you wh...
09/08/2026

🚨 DUMB DEAL OF THE DAY 🚨

Something brand new is hiding on our website.

You haven’t seen it before.

We’re not telling you what it is.

We’re just telling you somebody screwed up the price.

$32.99 → $15.42

Only 8 exist at that price.

Find it before the other 7 people do. Link in bio or gray house pies dot com

We got so distracted hiding today’s **Dumb Deal of the Day** on our website that we nearly forgot something.**TODAY IS $...
09/08/2026

We got so distracted hiding today’s **Dumb Deal of the Day** on our website that we nearly forgot something.

**TODAY IS $5 TUESDAY.**

Which would have been unfortunate, since Tuesday is pretty much the only day when forgetting what day it is costs you money.

So you have two assignments:

**Find today’s Dumb Deal.**
**Then come indulge in $5 Tuesday.**

This may be the most financially irresponsible Tuesday we’ve ever organized.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

One of this week’s brand-new Flavor Drops is already on our website.**But that’s not the dumb part.**The dumb part is th...
09/08/2026

One of this week’s brand-new Flavor Drops is already on our website.

**But that’s not the dumb part.**

The dumb part is that we put a handful of them (8 to be specific) online at a spectacularly stupid price.

We’re not telling you what the new flavor is.

We’re not telling you where it is.

You have to go find it.

Look for:

**🚨 DUMB DEAL OF THE DAY 🚨**

Find it. Order it. And schedule your pickup between now and Saturday at 4 PM.

We are only offering eight of them at an insane price and only today. When they're gone, well, that means there are no more. Hmmm

These are **Pies of the Week**, not Pies of the Decade. You can’t squirrel one away at today’s dumb price for Thanksgiving.

When they’re gone, the dumb price is gone.

Tomorrow we’ll introduce all of this week’s new flavors like responsible adults.

**GO FIND THE DUMB DEAL →**

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

One of this week’s brand-new Flavor Drops is already on our website.**But that’s not the dumb part.**The dumb part is th...
09/08/2026

One of this week’s brand-new Flavor Drops is already on our website.

**But that’s not the dumb part.**

The dumb part is that we put a handful of them online at a spectacularly stupid price.

We’re not telling you what the new flavor is.

We’re not telling you where it is.

You have to go find it.

Look for:

**🚨 DUMB DEAL OF THE DAY 🚨**

Find it. Order it. And schedule your pickup between now and Saturday at 4 PM.

These are **Pies of the Week**, not Pies of the Decade. You can’t squirrel one away at today’s dumb price for Thanksgiving.

When they’re gone, the dumb price is gone.

Tomorrow we’ll introduce all of this week’s new flavors like responsible adults.

**GO FIND THE DUMB DEAL →**

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

Labor Day weekend is underway.There will be cookouts.There will be parties.There will be people standing around somebody...
09/05/2026

Labor Day weekend is underway.

There will be cookouts.

There will be parties.

There will be people standing around somebody's backyard holding paper plates and discussing whether 90 degrees is “really that bad if there's a breeze.”

And sooner or later, somebody will say:

**“What did you bring?”**

This is an important moment.

You have two choices.

You can proudly place a beautiful pie on the table.

Or you can reach into a plastic bag and pull out **a package of ginger snaps you bought at the gas station on the way over.**

Don't be that guy.

# # WE'RE OPEN TODAY 9–4.

And there is still plenty of time to stock up for the rest of Labor Day weekend.

Leading today's Department of Extremely Appropriate Holiday Desserts:

🇺🇸 **RED, WHITE & BLUE PIE**

Apples. Cherries. Blueberries.

It's delicious.

It's patriotic.

And, according to research we completely fabricated earlier this week, the three fruits combine to produce the powerful **Triple-Fruit Thermal Suppression Effect™**, helping cool the human body during a heat wave.

Apples are mostly water.

Water is cool.

Cherries are red like fire trucks, which spray water.

Blueberries are blue, which is the official color of cold.

Frankly, the science is overwhelming.

Then there's:

# # KEY LIME PIE.

The unofficial dessert of **hot weather, patios, cookouts and people wearing shorts they probably shouldn't.**

Cold. Creamy. Tart.

Key Lime has been one of our most popular summer gathering pies for years.

And researchers at the Gray House Institute of Pie-Based Thermoregulation have determined that Key Lime Pie activates the body's **Internal Air-Conditioning Response™.**

One slice: Cooling begins.

Two slices: Central air.

Three slices: You may need a sweater.

So there you have it.

Labor Day weekend.

90-degree weather.

People coming over.

Places to go.

# # BRING PIE.

Bring Red, White & Blue.

Bring Key Lime.

Hell, bring both and become the person everybody is actually happy to see walking up the driveway.

**WE'RE OPEN 9–4 TODAY.**

You've still got time.

Do not squander this opportunity and wind up standing at a gas station at 4:17 PM staring at ginger snaps.

Nobody deserves that.

— Gray House Pies

*None of our thermoregulatory research has survived peer review, primarily because we have never submitted it for peer review.*

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

It is Friday.More specifically: # # IT IS PIZZA FRIDAY.Tonight from **5–7 PM**, Gray House will once again fire up the o...
09/04/2026

It is Friday.

More specifically:

# # IT IS PIZZA FRIDAY.

Tonight from **5–7 PM**, Gray House will once again fire up the ovens and produce an irresponsible quantity of Detroit-style pizza.

This is your weekly reminder to:

# # GET IN HERE.

Come for dinner.

Grab a pizza.

Eat it hot.

Enjoy those crispy caramelized edges while they're doing whatever magical thing crispy caramelized cheese does to the human brain.

And because this happens to be **Labor Day weekend**, we have an additional suggestion:

# # BUY MORE THAN YOU NEED.

This is one of those rare occasions when poor impulse control is actually good planning.

People will be at your house Saturday.

People will be at your house Sunday.

Somebody will eventually say:

**“What are we doing for dinner?”**

And if you've planned properly, you will casually pull a Gray House pizza from the refrigerator like a person who has their life completely under control.

They reheat **beautifully**.

We know this because last weekend a neighbor reheated one on Sunday and immediately texted:

**“The pizza was phenomenal.”**

This has us reconsidering our entire business model.

Perhaps we should sell cold pizzas and make you people finish the job.

**Gray House Take & Bake.**

We make the pizza.

You provide the labor.

On Labor Day weekend.

There may be a flaw in this plan.

Anyway, they also **freeze beautifully for months**, so tonight you have options:

Eat one here.

Take one home.

Take three home.

Fill the freezer.

Become the emergency pizza provider for the entire Labor Day weekend.

But FIRST:

# # TONIGHT IS PIZZA NIGHT.

**5–7 PM.**

Seven Detroit-style pizzas.

Hot ovens.

Cold drinks.

Crispy edges.

And absolutely no reason for you to cook dinner tonight.

**GET IN HERE.**

And while you're here...

**BUY A BUNCH.**

Tomorrow You will be extremely impressed with Friday You.

— Gray House Pies

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

Address

26075 Detroit Road
Westlake, OH
44145

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Thursday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Friday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Gray House Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Gray House Pies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category