Old Fashioned Ice Cream

04/09/2026

Finally! IT’S TIME for our FLAVOR CONTEST VOTE! “Besitos de Coco” or “Neutron Star Blast”. Please look under each picture for flavor descriptions! Help us pick the winner of our 7th Annual Flavor Contest with FACEBOOK “likes” ~ Please VOTE here on our page - see steps for voting process below.

Step 1: for a vote to qualify- please like our page
Step 2 - go to the pinned post and VOTE for ONE of the finalists by “liking” the flavor picture.
Voting Ends 4/18 at Midnight. The total “Likes” will be counted and the flavor picture with the most “likes” will be our Winner! We’ll then make the winning flavor and it will be our “New Limited Time Flavor!” One Vote per person please (VOTE FOR ONE, NOT BOTH). The winning flavor will be notified & winner will receive ~ one 1/2 gallon of their flavor creation, one OFICS T-shirt and their photo posted on our social media to solidify their bragging rights!

Please note: Likes on the flavor “videos” will not be counted. Comments do not count as votes. Only votes on the corresponding flavor pictures on the PINNED Facebook post will be counted. Thank you.

Voting rules/details - Please “like” our page, then vote for one flavor picture. Voting for both flavors will disqualify your vote. Voting will end 4/18 at midnight - at which time we will tally the “likes” to determine the winner. The Facebook post/pictures will be screenshot for voting accuracy and will then be removed. Thank you for participating in our 7th Annual Flavor Contest.

04/05/2026

Open TODAY, Easter Sunday, 12pm to 10pm. We’re located just off Exit 36S of the SSP at 1025 Straight Path in West Babylon. 631-669-3020.

04/03/2026

Open Easter Sunday 12to 10pm. Located just off Exit 36S of SSP, at 1025 Straight Path in West Babylon. 631-669-3020

04/03/2026

Open Easter Sunday 12 to 10pm. Stop in for Easter Cakes, Pies and more - easy Grab & Go. We’re located just off Exit 36S of the SSP at 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon. 631-669-3020

03/13/2026

Yay!! It’s HERE! Time for our 7th ANNUAL FLAVOR CONTEST! Do you have an idea for a delicious Ice Cream Flavor? Now through March 20th - Stop in, pick up an entry form & submit your creation. Two finalists will be announced March 25th and Facebook voting will begin. Your vote will help decide the Winner. The winning creation will be our “New Limited Time Flavor” And of course, the winner will receive one 1/2 Gallon of their flavor creation & one of our Logo T-shirts. Enter our Flavor Creation Contest today! All entries must be submitted “in-store” only by 3/20/25 (please No email, No messenger, No phone entries, etc).

03/02/2026

Homemade Soft Serve: We’re twisting Lavender Haze (Lavender Honey) and Gold Rush (Vanilla Almond), We’re swirling Vanilla, Chocolate and for Vegan/NonDairy - we’re twirling New PEACH Dole Whip & POMEGRANATE Dole Whip! Stop in for a sample spoon- you’re gonna love it!!

03/01/2026

Lavender Haze is BACK! Soft Serve Lavender Honey Ice Cream. Stop in for a sample spoon- you’re gonna love it 💜

03/01/2026

02/24/2026

We will have a DELAYED opening today, Tuesday, February 24th. We appreciate your understanding as we wait for our snow removal company to arrive. We will keep you posted as to our opening time. We apologize for any inconvenience.

02/24/2026

We will have a DELAYED opening today!! We appreciate your understanding as we wait for our snow removal company to arrive. We will keep you posted as to our opening time. We apologize for any inconvenience.