Sarah's Pizza West Alex and Eaton

Shortcuts

• Address
• Telephone
• Opening Hours
• Alerts
• Claim ownership or report listing
• Request takedown

• 

  Want your business to be the top-listed restaurant in West Alexandria?

Sarah’s Pizza and Subs

Since 1990, Sarah’s Pizza has been providing Preble County with its signature pizza and subs by using fresh, high quality ingredients. The first Sarah’s Pizza was opened in Lewisburg in July of 1990 . The store opened under three simple philosophies: affordable prices, quality ingredients and top customer service. The store received immediate support from the residents and quickly found its role in the Lewisburg community. The success in Lewisburg lead to a second store located in West Alexandria less than two years later. Operating under the same business principals of the original Lewisburg location, the West Alexandria location was also quickly accepted and supported by the community. This led to opening a third location in Eaton . Once again, Sarah’s was quickly welcomed and supported by Eaton residents. Today, all three locations are still operating under the original business philosophies. Currently, the three stores combine to provide nearly all of Preble County with quality pizza and prompt delivery. Sarah’s continues to make fresh dough in house, homemade sauce, slices fresh mozzarella and provolone cheese and uses top quality vegetables that are hand cut and prepared in house. Sarah’s also continues to offer bigger pizzas at every size than most other restaurants. For example, a medium pizza at Sarah’s is the same size as a large pizza at national pizza chains. The Extra Large at Sarah’s is a massive 18 inches across. A letter from the owners: To the residents of Lewisburg, West Alexandria, Eaton and all of Preble County, Thank you for nearly three decades of support and allowing us to be a part of your community. It has been a privilege to call Preble County our home and we have enjoyed serving the area quality food each step along the way. It has been your support and business that has allowed us to become the go-to spot for Pizza in many of your homes. We look forward to many more years of making top quality pizza and subs made by our family to your family.