The Cake Lady

Name: The Cake Lady
Address: 2475 E. Pierceton Road, Warsaw, IN, 46580, US
Telephone: +15742532705
Price range: $$

Home
United States
Warsaw, IN
The Cake Lady

Custom desserts for every occasion! At least 2-week notice is required. Last-minute orders are based on availability. Desserts for all occasions!!

Order anytime at thecakeladyonline.net ✨

Thank you,
Sarah Haverstock-Owner Cheesecakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Brownies, Strawberries, Cakes, Shooter Cups and lot more!!

09/03/2026

Hey friends! The Cottage will be closed this weekend. I’ve had a lot going on personally, so any extra time I have this week is going towards getting custom orders finished up!
I’m hoping to open on Labor Day, so keep an eye out for an update! 💕🙏🤞🧁 Thank you all so much for understanding and for always supporting The Cottage! 💗
📸 of a few custom cakes I remembered to take!

08/30/2026

6pm update! Cheesecake slices, cake slices, and mini cheesecakes still available!

Happy Sunday! We're open until 8pm or sold out!

Banana pudding and Dirt pudding are back!!

Cookies
🥜Peanut butter puppy chow
🤩Toffee Chocolate Chip
🙌Frosted sugar
Plus Assorted cookie packs with 1 of each!

Cake slices
🍋Raspberry Lemon Cream
🫐Lemon Blueberry Cream
🎂Funfetti
🌟Chocolate Peanut Butter
🍫Chocolate
🍓Strawberry Tres leches
🌟Dulce de Leche Tre leches

Cheesecake slices
🍓Strawberry
🫐Blueberry
🍫Turtle
🥜Peanut butter
🍪Cookie dough
🍋Lime
😋Pecan Pie

Cheesecake mini packs
🙌Assorted flavors

Cupcake packs
👌🧁Assorted flavors 🧁👌

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter
😋Mint chip

🤩Pumpkin roll slices!

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
💲Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

08/29/2026

It's Saturday and we're open until 8pm or sold out!

Cookies
🥜Peanut butter puppy chow is BACK!!
🤩Snickerdoodles
🙌Frosted sugar
Plus Assorted cookie packs with 1 of each!

Cake slices
🍋Raspberry Lemon Cream
🫐Lemon Blueberry Cream
🎂Funfetti
🌟Oreo
🍫Chocolate
🍓Strawberry Tres leches
🌟Dulce de Leche Tre leches

Cheesecake slices
🍓Strawberry
🫐Blueberry
🍫Turtle
🥜Peanut butter
🍪Cookie dough
🍋Lime
🤩Caramel Apple Streusel
😋Pecan Pie

Cheesecake mini packs
🙌Assorted flavors

Cupcake packs
👌🧁Assorted flavors 🧁👌

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter
😋Mint chip
🥰Pecan Pie

🤩Pumpkin roll slices!

🎂Whole 6 inch cakes🎂

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
💲Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

08/27/2026

Happy Thursday, friends!! 🎉 The Cottage will be OPEN this weekend!
Saturday & Sunday | 12–8pm (or sold out!)
I am planning to have everything BOTH days!!

Cake slices will be back plus pecan pie cheesecake and pecan pie brownies ♥️🤤

Im also making a couple whole cakes and simple vanilla/chocolate cupcake packs as well!

I’ll also have lots of the usual goodies:
🍰 Cake slices
🍫 Brownies
🍪 Cookies
🧁 Cupcakes
🍰 Mini cheesecakes
🎃 Pumpkin rolls
🤎 Cookies

2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

08/23/2026

Sold out at 3pm! Good morning, friends! We're open Sunday 12-sold out. Smaller stock day.
Yesterday was our second biggest day ever in the Cottage!! 🥹💕 We restocked all day long and still couldn’t keep the shelves full! 🤯
With that being said, we stocked almost everything we made for both Saturday AND Sunday yesterday 😂 So today will be a little bit of a lighter day!

Assorted mini cheesecakes
🌟Pecan pie
🍓Strawberry
🫐Blueberry
♥️Biscoff

Cookies
🤩Frosted sugar
🥜Peanut butter

🍎Caramel Apple Streusel Cheesecake slices

Brownies
🤩Pecan pie
🥰Mint
🍫Peanut butter

08/22/2026

Happy Saturday! We're open until 8pm or sold out!
Updates will be made on this post.

Cookies
😋Frosted Sugar
🌟Snickerdoodle
🥜Peanut butter

Tin Cake
🎂White wedding
🥳Funfetti
🍫Chocolate
😋Oreo
🍫Salted caramel Chocolate

Cheesecake slices
🍓Strawberry
🙌Pean Pie
🫐Blueberry
🍫Turtle
🥜Peanut butter
😋Biscoff
🤩Caramel Apple Streusel

Cheesecake mini packs
🙌Assorted flavors - FALL flavor Apple Streusel and Pumpkin! These week be ready at 1pm!!

Cupcake packs
👌Assorted flavors

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter

🤩Pumpkin roll slices!

😋🍫Texas sheet cake slices🍫😋

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
💲Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

08/20/2026

Happy Thursday, friends!! 🎉 The Cottage will be OPEN this weekend!
Saturday & Sunday | 12–8pm (or sold out!)

I’m working on a NEW cheesecake flavor this week, and of all goes right, I’ll have Pecan Pie Cheesecake available this weekend! 🤤
Plus, the favorite Caramel Apple Streusel Cheesecake will be back! 🍎 And I’m hopefully squeezing in Texas Sheet Cake slices if time allows!
I’ll also have lots of the usual goodies:
🍰 Cake slices
🍫 Brownies
🍪 Cookies
🧁 Cupcakes
🍰 Mini cheesecakes
🎃 Pumpkin rolls
🤎 And SNICKERDOODLES ARE BACK!!
2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

08/12/2026

Hey friends! The Cottage will be closed this week. I had a pretty rough chest cold over the weekend, but I’m finally feeling much better! ❤️
Unfortunately, being sick put me a little behind and that just doesn’t leave enough time to get all of my custom orders finished plus bake everything for The Cottage this week. All custom orders will be made as usual!
Thank you and see you next week!

08/08/2026

SOLD OUT! Saturday 2:30pm update! Open till sold out!

Address

2475 E. Pierceton Road
Warsaw, IN
46580

Telephone

+15742532705

Website

http://www.thecakeladyonline.net/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cake Lady posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cake Lady:

Want your business to be the top-listed Restaurant in Warsaw?