Johnny Tomatoes Pizza

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Johnny Tomatoes Pizza New York style pizza right here in Venice, Florida!

10/12/2026

That crunch says it all 🤌🍕 Our thick, airy Sicilian crust with a golden, crispy bottom is made fresh in-house daily. Get it with any specialty pizza or your favorite toppings!

16” Sicilian pie, cut into 12 slices. You need to try this one!

NEW! Football Special 🏈🍕TWO 18" XL Classic Cheese Pies + 12 Wings (any style) + a 2-Liter Soda of your choice — just $45...
10/05/2026

NEW! Football Special 🏈🍕

TWO 18" XL Classic Cheese Pies + 12 Wings (any style) + a 2-Liter Soda of your choice — just $45!

The perfect game day spread. Available Sundays, Mondays, and Thursdays all football season. Toppings extra.

Stop by, call, or order online for pickup and delivery — 4260 S Tamiami Trail, Venice.
👉 Order Now: www.johnnytomatoespizza.com

10/03/2026

Homemade meatballs, the way they’re meant to be. 🍅

Three of our house-made meatballs, simmered in our homemade marinara sauce and ready to go Classic or Parm Style.

🍝 Classic: Sauce, dollops of whipped ricotta, romano and fresh parsley.

🧀 Parm Style: Sauce, grated mozzarella, romano and fresh parsley.

🍗 BREADED vs. UNBREADED — settle the debate!Which wing team are you on?🔥 Team Breaded — Crunchy Breaded Wings, all that ...
10/03/2026

🍗 BREADED vs. UNBREADED — settle the debate!

Which wing team are you on?

🔥 Team Breaded — Crunchy Breaded Wings, all that crispy golden crunch in every bite
🥗 Team Baked — Gluten-Free Baked Wings, lighter, crispy skin, no breading needed

Either way you win — both come in buffalo, garlic parm, BBQ, Mike's hot honey, sriracha, or plain.

Drop your pick in the comments and tell us your favorite flavor! 👇

Follow

Stop by, call, or order online for pickup and delivery — 4260 S Tamiami Trail, Venice.
👉 Order Now: www.johnnytomatoespizza.com

NEW! Friday Night Family Meal Deal 🍕Two 18" XL Classic Cheese Pies + 10 Garlic Knots + 4 Mini Cannoli + Four 20oz Drinks...
10/02/2026

NEW! Friday Night Family Meal Deal 🍕

Two 18" XL Classic Cheese Pies + 10 Garlic Knots + 4 Mini Cannoli + Four 20oz Drinks — just $49!

Feed the whole family. Toppings extra.

Stop by, call, or order online for pickup and delivery — 4260 S Tamiami Trail, Venice.
👉 Order Now: www.johnnytomatoespizza.com

10/02/2026

🍕 REVIEW OF THE WEEK 🌟

"Some of the best pizza we've had. We got bbq chicken, lasagna and vodka sauce pizza (with onions). Highly recommend and delivery was quick!"

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ — Mike P.

Love seeing folks discover their favorites across the menu — from BBQ Chicken to the Vodka Pie to homemade lasagna. That's what it's all about!

📍 Stop by, call, or order online for pickup and delivery — 4260 S Tamiami Trail, Venice.
🕔 Mon–Thu 3–8 PM | Fri 3–9 PM | Sat 11–9 | Sun 11–8
👉 Order Now: www.johnnytomatoespizza.com

That cheese pull though…🧀🤤Our mozzarella bread is made fresh to order, loaded with grande cheese, house made garlic oil,...
09/29/2026

That cheese pull though…🧀🤤

Our mozzarella bread is made fresh to order, loaded with grande cheese, house made garlic oil, and topped off with romano and parsley. Served with a 4oz side of marinara.

Perfect as an appetizer, a side, or honestly… the whole meal!

Address

4260 S. Tamiami Trail
Venice, FL
34293

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Telephone

+19414931515

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Johnny Tomatoes Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Johnny Tomatoes Pizza:

Shortcuts

Share

Category