Shelly Pie Pizza

Shelly Pie Pizza Hearty pizzas, italian specialties, daily specials and a full service bar. We have plenty of room but we highly recommend reservations, especially on weekends.
(1414)

Looking forward to serving you! Shelly Farren, Mike Aiello, and Jim Holland, who have enjoyed a friendship spanning over 30 years, established Shelly Pie with the vision of creating a family-style restaurant distinguished by its hearty pizza, authentic Italian specialties, and classic daily specials. The concept originated in 2010 when Mike and Jim initiated the purchase of the former Turtle Creek

VFW building. The acquisition process lasted nearly two years, culminating in May 2012 when they received the keys to their new establishment. Although they initially considered opening storage units and a refurbished furniture store, their plans shifted after learning that their long-time friend Shelly had recently lost her position at a renowned pizza establishment due to its closure. Following a meeting among the three, the direction for Shelly Pie was set. Joe Beers joined the team shortly after the restaurant opened and demonstrated unwavering dedication as he progressed within the company. Lisa Cochran became part of Shelly Pie in 2020, bringing valuable experience from her background in corporate dining. Both Joe and Lisa exhibited exceptional work ethic, reliability, and interpersonal skills. Recognizing their contributions, Shelly, Mike, and Jim welcomed them as business partners. While the founding trio remains actively involved behind the scenes, Joe and Lisa now serve as the primary representatives of Shelly Pie. Together, this group of five collectively oversees the unique style and quality that define Shelly Pie. With an extensive menu selection, Shelly Pie has become a cornerstone of the Turtle Creek community, providing a welcoming, sit-down, family-style dining experience.

06/29/2026
Stop in for a Yinzer!
06/29/2026

Stop in for a Yinzer!

06/29/2026

Today is the last day to get a half baked pizza before we close for a week! Get some so you can enjoy a Shelly Pie while...
06/29/2026

Today is the last day to get a half baked pizza before we close for a week! Get some so you can enjoy a Shelly Pie while we’re closed.

These were found at the Manor Valley Golf Course. If you know somebody who lost their keys, please pass this on to them....
06/29/2026

These were found at the Manor Valley Golf Course. If you know somebody who lost their keys, please pass this on to them.

Make sure you get a half baked Shelly Pie pizza. We will be closed all next week, for the holiday. From our family to y...
06/28/2026

Make sure you get a half baked Shelly Pie pizza. We will be closed all next week, for the holiday. From our family to yours have a safe and happy holiday.

Yinz Gotta Try Our Philly Cheesesteak Pasta!
06/28/2026

Yinz Gotta Try Our Philly Cheesesteak Pasta!

It’s Bloody Mary Sunday at Shelly Pie! They’re only $6.00 all day today.
06/28/2026

It’s Bloody Mary Sunday at Shelly Pie! They’re only $6.00 all day today.

Enjoy a Sangria at Shelly Pie.
06/27/2026

Enjoy a Sangria at Shelly Pie.

Address

912 Penn Avenue Extension
Turtle Creek, PA
15145

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 12pm - 8pm

Telephone

+14126462560

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shelly Pie Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category