Valley Subs Plus

Valley Subs Plus Just two people with one oven and a simple menu, celebrating 10 years of business! Pro ordering tip: Call Early! Phone lines get busy and sell outs happen!

Area's first: Old Forge Pizza, Calzone, Sweetie Pie (sweet, sweet garlic 🍕) and Italian Grinder.

Thursday Football Specials Featured Pizza: White Deluxe -Our traditional White Pizza with olive oil, seasonings and...
09/03/2026

Thursday Football Specials

Featured Pizza:
White Deluxe
-Our traditional White Pizza with olive oil, seasonings and cheese, no sauce. Topped with Ricotta, Tomatoes and Broccoli.
*NY Style, thin round crust
$15 Large, $13 Medium
*Old Forge, thick square crust
$14 - 6 cuts, $20- cuts

$9 Dippin Stix
$9 - 6 Cuts

09/02/2026

Wednesday Specials

$9 - 6 cuts
$15 - 12 cuts (Whole tray)
$26- TWO TRAYS
$13/$15 Calzone
3.99 HOMEMADE RICE PUDDING

08/30/2026

Sunday Specials, pre-orders accepted all day.

$9 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix
$9 - 6 Cuts
$15 - 12 cuts
$26 - 24 Cuts (TWO WHOLE TRAYS)
$3.99 Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

Taking pre-orders for the Rice Pudding! Should I make some with RAISINS?

FRIDAY Specials Below, open at 4, taking pre-orders all day. CALL AHEAD and avoid the rush, beat the sell-out!ALSO, if y...
08/28/2026

FRIDAY Specials Below, open at 4, taking pre-orders all day. CALL AHEAD and avoid the rush, beat the sell-out!

ALSO, if you have never attended one of the Sweet Valley Volunteer Fire Company bingo parties, you are missing out.. They are a BLAST! Save the date!

Specials

$9 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix
$25 Whole Tray + Large NY

Sweetie Pie Thursday Special$2 off Large Sweetie Pies, $1.75 off Medium $9 - 6 cutsAnd back by popular demand.....this w...
08/27/2026

Sweetie Pie Thursday Special

$2 off Large Sweetie Pies, $1.75 off Medium

$9 - 6 cuts

And back by popular demand.....this week only:
$3.99 CHOCOLATE CHIP CHEESECAKE!

Preorders always welcomed! CALL AHEAD and avoid the rush!

Sunday Specials, While supplies last, preorders welcomed! $20 TWO Large NY PIZZAS $11 One Large NY Pizza
08/23/2026

Sunday Specials, While supplies last, preorders welcomed!

$20 TWO Large NY PIZZAS
$11 One Large NY Pizza

SATURDAY TRAY SPECIALSCALL AHEAD and get your order on the board, we're taking pre-orders all day, call anytime!$9 - 6 c...
08/22/2026

SATURDAY TRAY SPECIALS
CALL AHEAD and get your order on the board, we're taking pre-orders all day, call anytime!

$9 - 6 cuts (half Tray)
$15 - 12 cuts (whole Tray)
$26 - 24 cuts (TWO WHOLE TRAYS)That's $7.98 off!!!!
$20 - Whole Tray, $12 Half Tray
MEAT LOVERS
***Another round of Oreo Cookies and Cream Cake by Sugar & Spice Bakery available tonight! Call to reserve one, they will sell out!

FRIDAY TRAY SPECIALS $9 - 6 cuts (half Tray)$15 - 12 cuts (whole Tray)$26 - 24 cuts (TWO WHOLE TRAYS)That's $7.98 off!!!...
08/21/2026

FRIDAY TRAY SPECIALS

$9 - 6 cuts (half Tray)
$15 - 12 cuts (whole Tray)
$26 - 24 cuts (TWO WHOLE TRAYS)That's $7.98 off!!!!
$20 - Whole Tray, $12 Half Tray
BUFFALO CHICKEN or CHICKEN BACON RANCH

08/20/2026

Thursday Specials

$9 - Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix
$9 - 6 Cuts
$15 - 12 Cuts
$25 - Whole Tray + Large NY

Wednesday Specials BelowPre-orders are not required, but appreciated!This Week's Dessert Menu: *OREO Cookies and Cream C...
08/19/2026

Wednesday Specials Below
Pre-orders are not required, but appreciated!

This Week's Dessert Menu:
*OREO Cookies and Cream Cake
*NY Style Cheesecake
(with or without Strawberry Topping)

Wednesday Specials

*Italian Stromboli Special
$12 Med, $15 Large

*Grinder Special (Ham, American or Italian)
$7 Half, $10 Whole Sub
(Add a small bag of chips for $.50!)

Address

5355 Main Road
Sweet Valley, PA
18656

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm
Sunday 4pm - 8pm

Telephone

+15704772022

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Valley Subs Plus posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category