American Pie Company

American Pie Company Made from Scratch Pies & Thoughtful Gifts

11/27/2025

Thank you all for your incredible patronage. It has been our honor to be a part of your holidays over the past five years. This is a bittersweet farewell, but we’re grateful for every memory made. While this chapter is closing, we’re excited to share that something new will be coming to this space in 2026. Stay tuned — and thank you again for all the love and support. ❤️

11/25/2025

BOGO = LAST CALL for PIE! 🥧

🤩Buy one, get one free!

We’re opening tomorrow (11/26) from 10a-2p to clear out the remaining inventory — come grab your favorites before they’re gone!

Full-Size Pies Available:
• Strawberry
• Strawberry Rhubarb
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• French Silk
• Coconut Cream
• Lemon Cream
• Key Lime

Mini Pies Available:
• Apple
• Cherry
• Mixed Berry
• Strawberry Rhubarb
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• French Silk
• Coconut Cream
• Pecan
• Chocolate Pecan
• Bourbon Pecan

Don’t miss out — once they’re gone, that’s it! ✨

💳 CC Only

11/22/2025

🥧 Update!
Only a few full-size pies left, but we still have plenty of mini pies available!

We’re here until noon — stop by while they last! 🎉

💳 CC Only

📣 Inventory Pie Sell-Off! 🥧We’re clearing out ~200 full-size pies plus lots of mini pies!📅 Sale Dates & Times👉 Friday 11...
11/19/2025

📣 Inventory Pie Sell-Off! 🥧
We’re clearing out ~200 full-size pies plus lots of mini pies!

📅 Sale Dates & Times
👉 Friday 11/21 | 7 AM–4 PM — Frozen only
👉 Saturday 11/22 | 7 AM–12 PM — Frozen only
👉 Wednesday 11/26 | 10 AM–2 PM — Frozen full-size, frozen minis & baked minis

🥧 Pricing
• Full-size pies: $20
• Mini 4-packs (frozen): $17.50
• Mini 4-packs (baked): $20
(Minis are mix-and-match in 4-packs!)

💳 Payment: Credit card only
🚫 No reservations — first come, first served!

Come stock up while supplies last! 🎉

11/16/2025

Pick up times for Temple Baptist IXL fundraiser this week are M-F 7a-4p. Sa 7a-12p. Remaining full and mini pie inventory to be determined and for sale soon.

10/13/2025

With heartfelt gratitude, we announce our closure as of today.

We will continue to honor all prior commitments and will share details soon regarding the sale of our remaining inventory.

To our valued customers, thank you for your support over the years. Your loyalty and patronage have meant the world to us.

10/03/2025

***We’re still in search of a new owner***

📣 Cafe & Coffee Shop For Sale ☕🥧
It’s with a heavy heart that we share the news: American Pie Company will be closing its doors on December 24, 2025.

🔹 Business for Sale – $75,000
Includes all furniture, fixtures, equipment, and accessories — everything you need to hit the ground running!

🔹 2,500 sq ft Space for Lease – $2,500/month ($12/sf)
Available starting January 1, 2026

Terms negotiable.

If you've ever dreamed of owning a cafe or expanding your current business, this is your chance. Serious inquiries only, please email [email protected] for more details.

Thank you to all our customers for your patronage over the years — we’re beyond grateful! Thank you to all our friends and family for the support.💛

Hi Pie Friends! We're having to close up shop just a little earlier than normal on Saturday due to some staffing challe...
10/02/2025

Hi Pie Friends! We're having to close up shop just a little earlier than normal on Saturday due to some staffing challenges. We appreciate your patience and understanding and we'll be brewing as usual next week. Thanks for being the best supporters we could ask for!

The best mornings look like this:
09/23/2025

The best mornings look like this:

Hot Ham and Swiss on a Croissant for lunch this week!
09/22/2025

Hot Ham and Swiss on a Croissant for lunch this week!

Busy day at the shop: 100 mini fruit pies and 100 gooey butter cake pieces going out to ECC tomorrow!
09/18/2025

Busy day at the shop: 100 mini fruit pies and 100 gooey butter cake pieces going out to ECC tomorrow!

Address

1017 N Olive Street
Sullivan, MO
63080

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 3pm
Tuesday 7am - 3pm
Wednesday 7am - 3pm
Thursday 7am - 3pm
Friday 7am - 3pm
Saturday 8am - 3pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when American Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category