East of Chicago - Sugarcreek

09/21/2026

🥖🔥 MONDAY NIGHT SUB SPECIAL! 🔥🥖

2 — 12” SUBS FOR ONLY $15.99! 😋

📅 Monday Night
⏰ 4–8 PM

Grab TWO of your favorite 12” subs and save! ❤️

🍕 East of Chicago – Sugarcreek

09/21/2026

🍂🍕 Fall changes are here at East of Chicago! 🍕🍂

We’re excited to welcome new management team members and new faces to our team! ❤️ New weekly specials coming soon! 🍕

🍁 New Fall Hours 🍁
Sun–Thurs: 4–8 PM | Fri: 1–8 PM | Sat: 11 AM–8 PM
Currently closed Tuesdays — but that will be changing soon! 👀

🍕 East of Chicago – Sugarcreek 🍂

09/05/2026

05/11/2026

Kicking the week off with Pirates traveling to Indian Valley today. JV will be at home on the Hill. ⚾️🏴‍☠️ Let’s Go!!!

05/11/2026

05/08/2026

Call in to East of Chicago from now till 8pm and get a one topping pizza for just $10!! 🍕🍕🍕mention you saw it on fb!

05/04/2026

🚨 Don’t Forget, Sugarcreek! 🚨

Starting tonight, East of Chicago is officially open on Mondays! 🍕🙌

That’s right — no more sad Monday dinner decisions 😎
We’re now serving up your pizza favorites every Monday from 4PM–8PM!

✔️ Pickup
✔️ Delivery
✔️ Online Ordering
✔️ DoorDash

Start your week the right way… with pizza 🍕❤️
See you tonight!

05/01/2026

🚨 We’re NOT closing! 🍕❤️

Just clearing up some confusion — East of Chicago in Sugarcreek is still OPEN and not going anywhere!

We’re simply leasing out the other side of the building (our former dining room space), but the pizza shop is still fully open and running like normal. 😎

That means we’re still here for:✅ Carryout✅ Delivery✅ Online Ordering✅ DoorDash

We’re just putting the extra space to good use — but your pizza is staying right where it belongs. 🍕❤️

Still serving Amish Country one slice at a time

04/30/2026

🚨 Big Change at East of Chicago – Sugarcreek 🚨

Our buffet and dining room are now officially closed.

The good news? We’re still here serving up all your favorites for:
🍕 Pickup
🚗 Delivery
📱 Online Ordering
🛵 DoorDash

We’ll continue doing what we do best — keeping Sugarcreek fed, one pizza at a time. ❤️

Also… the dining room side of the building is now available for lease!
Interested in the space? Message us for details.

Thank you for continuing to support East of Chicago Sugarcreek! 🍕

04/27/2026

🚨 BIG NEWS, SUGARCREEK! 🚨

Starting Monday, May 4th we’ll officially be OPEN ON MONDAYS! 🍕🙌

No more Monday pizza cravings going unanswered 😎Now you can kick off the week with your East of Chicago favorites!

✅ Pickup✅ Delivery✅ Online Ordering✅ DoorDash

Mondays just got a whole lot better 🍕❤️