The Pie Lady on 5

The Pie Lady on 5 As a Home Based Vendor I am offering pies that you can order by phone, then pick up at my roadside Hi, I'm Carlene, The Pie Lady on 5. I have five children, 16 grandchildren, and I've been baking pies for over 40 years.
(38)

I made my first pie more than 40 years ago , trying to snag a man. I've been married for 40 years, so that should tell you how good the pie was! My specialty is an old-fashioned sugar cream pie, my own secret recipe, that family and friends can't get enough of. Please go to my website, thepieladyon5.com for complete menu and pricing.

Operating as usual

One more day to get signed up for a fun evening. Come on out and learn some awesome tips on how to take the stress out o...
06/15/2021

One more day to get signed up for a fun evening. Come on out and learn some awesome tips on how to take the stress out of making pie dough. It's gonna be a fun time!

There are still openings available for our Perfect Pastry event with the "Pie Lady on 5", Carlene Staller! Call, come in, or email to save your spot. Register and pay by Wednesday June 16 to be a part of this fun downtown event. sales @ shophomecraft.com

Good Morning Pie Lovers. I hope you all had a wonderful weekend. Mine started out pretty good and then we had a big hicc...
06/14/2021

Good Morning Pie Lovers. I hope you all had a wonderful weekend. Mine started out pretty good and then we had a big hiccup. Water damage in the kitchen. Unfortunately I will be closed for awhile until we can get things fixed. I can't be in the kitchen working while I have workers in there fixing the mess. Oh well, it is what it is. I'll keep you posted on when I open up again. Here is a picture of just 2 or the many machines in my kitchen and basement working to dry things out before the floor gets taken up.

Good Morning Pie Lovers. I hope you all had a wonderful weekend. Mine started out pretty good and then we had a big hiccup. Water damage in the kitchen. Unfortunately I will be closed for awhile until we can get things fixed. I can't be in the kitchen working while I have workers in there fixing the mess. Oh well, it is what it is. I'll keep you posted on when I open up again. Here is a picture of just 2 or the many machines in my kitchen and basement working to dry things out before the floor gets taken up.

Final copy proofed and heading back to the printer today. It will hit the market sometime in the next month or 2. The pr...
06/03/2021

Final copy proofed and heading back to the printer today. It will hit the market sometime in the next month or 2. The printer is swamped so you will have to wait just a little longer for this Gem of a Pie Book. I will keep you posted😊

Final copy proofed and heading back to the printer today. It will hit the market sometime in the next month or 2. The printer is swamped so you will have to wait just a little longer for this Gem of a Pie Book. I will keep you posted😊

Mark your calendars for a fun time. Friends and Pie, it doesn't get much better than that.
05/27/2021

Mark your calendars for a fun time. Friends and Pie, it doesn't get much better than that.

Join us for Perfect Pie night with the Pie Lady on 5, Carlene Staller. Carlene will demonstrate her pastry making technique, and participants will recieve a pastry cutter, a 16" x 16" canvas pastry cloth and recipes for both Carlene's perfect pastry and pecan pie filling. And, we will all enjoy Carlene's Blueberry Crumb and Blueberry Cream pie!
Call to register today - limit 24 per class.

Sign up for a fun evening of PIE
05/19/2021

Sign up for a fun evening of PIE

Join us for Perfect Pie night with the Pie Lady on 5, Carlene Staller. Carlene will demonstrate her pastry making technique, and participants will recieve a pastry cutter, a 16" x 16" canvas pastry cloth and recipes for both Carlene's perfect pastry and pecan pie filling. And, we will all enjoy Carlene's Blueberry Crumb and Blueberry Cream pie!
Call to register today - limit 24 per class.

This is music to my ears and what every Pie Baker wants to hear." My father-in-law stated your Cherry crumble pie was th...
05/10/2021

This is music to my ears and what every Pie Baker wants to hear.

" My father-in-law stated your Cherry crumble pie was the best he has ever tasted and your pecan was mouth watering delicious."

I'm busy the first part of the week, but Thur, Fri. and Sat. are good days to order pies. I still have apples and there ...
05/10/2021

I'm busy the first part of the week, but Thur, Fri. and Sat. are good days to order pies. I still have apples and there is plenty of rhubarb if you are interested in either of those. Just take a look at the menu and order at thepieladyon5.com

The Rhubarb is beautiful this year. It is growing wonderfully. Don't delay in ordering Rhubarb pies before the season en...
05/05/2021

The Rhubarb is beautiful this year. It is growing wonderfully. Don't delay in ordering Rhubarb pies before the season ends. Rhubarb Cream will be making an appearance at my house on Mother's Day. I have grand children staying with me the rest of this week so I won't be taking any more orders for Mother's Day, but you can certainly order a pie for next week.

Hey all my Fort Wayne friends, head on down and get some pie mix and listen to some awesome music
05/05/2021

Hey all my Fort Wayne friends, head on down and get some pie mix and listen to some awesome music

"The rhubarb cream pie was delicious "πŸ˜‹This is what I love to hear from my wonderful customers. Thanks Norma!
05/04/2021

"The rhubarb cream pie was delicious "πŸ˜‹

This is what I love to hear from my wonderful customers. Thanks Norma!

"The rhubarb cream pie was delicious "πŸ˜‹

This is what I love to hear from my wonderful customers. Thanks Norma!

Sounds like the place to be
04/30/2021

Sounds like the place to be

Pecan pie for sale. Message me.
04/27/2021

Pecan pie for sale. Message me.

Pecan pie for sale. Message me.

Order from The Pie Lady on 5 and have it in time to make for Mother's Day!!!!. Order online at thepieladyon5.com
04/27/2021

Order from The Pie Lady on 5 and have it in time to make for Mother's Day!!!!. Order online at thepieladyon5.com

Order from The Pie Lady on 5 and have it in time to make for Mother's Day!!!!. Order online at thepieladyon5.com

Matt came all the way from Chicago just to get pies. He even brought his friend along from Connecticut. I love it when p...
04/22/2021

Matt came all the way from Chicago just to get pies. He even brought his friend along from Connecticut. I love it when people come from far and wide to get a delicious home baked pie. Thanks Matt, you made my day!

Matt came all the way from Chicago just to get pies. He even brought his friend along from Connecticut. I love it when people come from far and wide to get a delicious home baked pie. Thanks Matt, you made my day!

Hey all you apple pie lovers out there. I just scored some Macintosh apples, which are one of the varieties I use for Ap...
04/21/2021

Hey all you apple pie lovers out there. I just scored some Macintosh apples, which are one of the varieties I use for Apple Pie. Let me know if that sounds absolutely delicious to you and I can fix you up next week. Order at thepieladyon5.com

Hey all you apple pie lovers out there. I just scored some Macintosh apples, which are one of the varieties I use for Apple Pie. Let me know if that sounds absolutely delicious to you and I can fix you up next week. Order at thepieladyon5.com

I'm taking orders for all you Rhubarb Lovers out there. Rhubarb Cream, Rhubarb Crumb and 2 crust Rhubarb Pie.  Doesn't t...
04/19/2021

I'm taking orders for all you Rhubarb Lovers out there. Rhubarb Cream, Rhubarb Crumb and 2 crust Rhubarb Pie. Doesn't that sound heavenly.

I'm taking orders for all you Rhubarb Lovers out there. Rhubarb Cream, Rhubarb Crumb and 2 crust Rhubarb Pie. Doesn't that sound heavenly.

Mother's Day is coming soon. Don't delay in getting your πŸ₯§ordered. Here is just one of the offerings for Mom's special d...
04/16/2021

Mother's Day is coming soon. Don't delay in getting your πŸ₯§
ordered. Here is just one of the offerings for Mom's special day. Coconut Sugar Cream, it is so yummy. Please place your orders online at thepieladyon5.com where there is a list of available pies for Mother's Day.
Have a great day.

Mother's Day is coming soon. Don't delay in getting your πŸ₯§
ordered. Here is just one of the offerings for Mom's special day. Coconut Sugar Cream, it is so yummy. Please place your orders online at thepieladyon5.com where there is a list of available pies for Mother's Day.
Have a great day.

I know we have a few weeks, but Mother's Day will be here before you know it. Please get your orders in early so I can m...
04/06/2021

I know we have a few weeks, but Mother's Day will be here before you know it. Please get your orders in early so I can make all of you Happy Customers. Order at thepieladyon5.com. I have the list of available pies for Mother's Day

I know we have a few weeks, but Mother's Day will be here before you know it. Please get your orders in early so I can make all of you Happy Customers. Order at thepieladyon5.com. I have the list of available pies for Mother's Day

I have 2 pecan pies to sell for $10 each, that is a discount of $4 per pie. I'm not sure what happened, but they kinda f...
04/06/2021

I have 2 pecan pies to sell for $10 each, that is a discount of $4 per pie. I'm not sure what happened, but they kinda fell and I don't feel good about selling them for full price. Let me know if you are interested, and if not I will just freeze them for my family. They will certainly taste the same, just not the prettiest. Thanks

The Pie Lady on 5 is excited to promote a new product for Rolling Pin Bakehouse. Natalie has perfected our famous sugar ...
04/05/2021

The Pie Lady on 5 is excited to promote a new product for Rolling Pin Bakehouse. Natalie has perfected our famous sugar cream pie into a mix that you can purchase. It is available on both her website, Rollingpinbakehouse.com and mine, thepieladyon5.com AT THE MOMENT, IT'S ONLY AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP. Check it out. Now you have 2 choices. Let one of us make it for you or purchase the mix and make it yourself. Either way is a win, win situation for you.

The Pie Lady on 5 is excited to promote a new product for Rolling Pin Bakehouse. Natalie has perfected our famous sugar cream pie into a mix that you can purchase. It is available on both her website, Rollingpinbakehouse.com and mine, thepieladyon5.com AT THE MOMENT, IT'S ONLY AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP. Check it out. Now you have 2 choices. Let one of us make it for you or purchase the mix and make it yourself. Either way is a win, win situation for you.

My grandma, Ruth Garshwiler opened a restaurant when she was 65 years old. She had no experience, other than she was an ...
03/20/2021

My grandma, Ruth Garshwiler opened a restaurant when she was 65 years old. She had no experience, other than she was an excellent cook and an even better Pie Baker. At 65 I am writing and publishing a Pie Cookbook. I'd say I'm pretty thankful for a grandma who knew it didn't matter your age, the only thing that mattered was your determination. Thanks Grandma, you have certainly inspired me.

My grandma, Ruth Garshwiler opened a restaurant when she was 65 years old. She had no experience, other than she was an excellent cook and an even better Pie Baker. At 65 I am writing and publishing a Pie Cookbook. I'd say I'm pretty thankful for a grandma who knew it didn't matter your age, the only thing that mattered was your determination. Thanks Grandma, you have certainly inspired me.

03/20/2021

The website is fixed

03/19/2021

If your Easter order doesn't go through at thepieladyon5.com, please contact me through messenger and I will get back with you. Thanks

It' always fun to look back at all the great things that have come my way. Click the photo below to see the whole interv...
03/16/2021
Pie Lady on 5 shares tips for best pie crust

It' always fun to look back at all the great things that have come my way. Click the photo below to see the whole interview.

The last official day of summer is almost a month away. That change means a shift in seasonal produce and the ingredients we use to cook. Summer provides cherries and with fall comes pumpkin- all p…

03/15/2021

Natty makes the best videos. And the Best Sugar Cream Pie. Hmm I wonder where she got that recipe, lol.

I'm so proud of Natalie and what she is accomplishing in her business. For all you Sugar Cream Pie lovers that want to m...
03/15/2021

I'm so proud of Natalie and what she is accomplishing in her business. For all you Sugar Cream Pie lovers that want to make one yourself, now you can. Check it out, you will be glad you did.

I'm loving the sunny morning 🌞. Be sure to get your Easter Orders in by March 22nd. I'm heading out of town and won't be...
03/13/2021

I'm loving the sunny morning 🌞. Be sure to get your Easter Orders in by March 22nd. I'm heading out of town and won't be home until a few days before Easter, so I gotta be all prepared for my baking day. You will be so glad you have my pies to adorn your Easter table.

I'm loving the sunny morning 🌞. Be sure to get your Easter Orders in by March 22nd. I'm heading out of town and won't be home until a few days before Easter, so I gotta be all prepared for my baking day. You will be so glad you have my pies to adorn your Easter table.

Good morning! 🌞 Don't ask why I'm up this early I have no idea, lol.  Don't forget to get your Easter πŸ‡ orders in by Mar...
03/08/2021

Good morning! 🌞 Don't ask why I'm up this early I have no idea, lol. Don't forget to get your Easter πŸ‡ orders in by March 22nd. Please go to the website, thepieladyon5.com to check out what is available. Have a great day. I know I will.

Good morning! 🌞 Don't ask why I'm up this early I have no idea, lol. Don't forget to get your Easter πŸ‡ orders in by March 22nd. Please go to the website, thepieladyon5.com to check out what is available. Have a great day. I know I will.

How will you be celebrating Pi day this year? I hope you will make The Pie Lady on 5 part of whatever you have planned. ...
03/05/2021

How will you be celebrating Pi day this year? I hope you will make The Pie Lady on 5 part of whatever you have planned. I will be baking on the 13th, so mark your calendars, and place your orders at thepieladyon5.com

How will you be celebrating Pi day this year? I hope you will make The Pie Lady on 5 part of whatever you have planned. I will be baking on the 13th, so mark your calendars, and place your orders at thepieladyon5.com

Went to Wabash this morning to buy a new washing machine and in the process took an order for 3 of my famous Sugar Cream...
03/02/2021

Went to Wabash this morning to buy a new washing machine and in the process took an order for 3 of my famous Sugar Cream Pies. When you make a great product you always have to be willing to tell people about it. Thanks Greg at Wabash Appliance, I made a good purchase and so did you!

Went to Wabash this morning to buy a new washing machine and in the process took an order for 3 of my famous Sugar Cream Pies. When you make a great product you always have to be willing to tell people about it. Thanks Greg at Wabash Appliance, I made a good purchase and so did you!

March is here and I'm hoping Spring is around the corner.  It's time to start thinking about Easter Pies.  Easter orders...
03/02/2021

March is here and I'm hoping Spring is around the corner. It's time to start thinking about Easter Pies. Easter orders will need to be in no later than March 22nd. I will offer the following pies for your enjoyment.
Carlene's Sugar Cream
Chocolate Sugar Cream
Coconut Sugar Cream
Cherry Crumb
Peach Crumb
Pick up will be Saturday April 3rd from 4-6pm.
Place orders on thepieladyon5.com

March is here and I'm hoping Spring is around the corner. It's time to start thinking about Easter Pies. Easter orders will need to be in no later than March 22nd. I will offer the following pies for your enjoyment.
Carlene's Sugar Cream
Chocolate Sugar Cream
Coconut Sugar Cream
Cherry Crumb
Peach Crumb
Pick up will be Saturday April 3rd from 4-6pm.
Place orders on thepieladyon5.com

In case you can't see me I am over here doing the Happy Dance. It finally happened. Baking With The Pie Lady on 5 is at ...
02/24/2021

In case you can't see me I am over here doing the Happy Dance. It finally happened. Baking With The Pie Lady on 5 is at the printers. It was sent today and I am beyond excited. I will have a proof copy in my hands in the next week or so πŸ“• . I hope to have books ready to ship by the end of April.

In case you can't see me I am over here doing the Happy Dance. It finally happened. Baking With The Pie Lady on 5 is at the printers. It was sent today and I am beyond excited. I will have a proof copy in my hands in the next week or so πŸ“• . I hope to have books ready to ship by the end of April.

Yum, Cherry πŸ₯§ fresh from the oven.πŸ˜‹
02/24/2021

Yum, Cherry πŸ₯§ fresh from the oven.πŸ˜‹

Yum, Cherry πŸ₯§ fresh from the oven.πŸ˜‹

I was so disappointed months ago when I found out I wasn't going to be able to use the printer I had wanted.Fast forward...
02/15/2021

I was so disappointed months ago when I found out I wasn't going to be able to use the printer I had wanted.

Fast forward. Today I have found a printer that is timely, great to work with and will do the cookbook πŸ“• like I want it done at a price that is in my budget. πŸ’²

This company has reached out to me and followed up in a timely fashion. ⏰

My patience has paid off.

Pro Tip: When one door πŸšͺ closes, another door opens

I was so disappointed months ago when I found out I wasn't going to be able to use the printer I had wanted.

Fast forward. Today I have found a printer that is timely, great to work with and will do the cookbook πŸ“• like I want it done at a price that is in my budget. πŸ’²

This company has reached out to me and followed up in a timely fashion. ⏰

My patience has paid off.

Pro Tip: When one door πŸšͺ closes, another door opens

CHOCOLATE SUGAR CREAM PIE🍫⁠⁠It's a Valentine's miracle! I will not be in sunny CA this year, I ⁠⁠am staying home, just s...
02/04/2021

CHOCOLATE SUGAR CREAM PIE🍫⁠
⁠
It's a Valentine's miracle! I will not be in sunny CA this year, I ⁠
⁠
am staying home, just so I can bake your Valentine's Pie.πŸ’•β 
⁠
Well, that may not be totally true, but I will be home 🏠 this ⁠
⁠
year for Valentines orders. Don't delay, get your order in ⁠
⁠
soon. May I suggest the always DELICIOUS CHOCOLATE ⁠
⁠
SUGAR CREAM. Believe me you won't be disappointed.⁠
⁠
Valentines Day orders will be picked up on Feb. 13th..

CHOCOLATE SUGAR CREAM PIE🍫⁠
⁠
It's a Valentine's miracle! I will not be in sunny CA this year, I ⁠
⁠
am staying home, just so I can bake your Valentine's Pie.πŸ’•β 
⁠
Well, that may not be totally true, but I will be home 🏠 this ⁠
⁠
year for Valentines orders. Don't delay, get your order in ⁠
⁠
soon. May I suggest the always DELICIOUS CHOCOLATE ⁠
⁠
SUGAR CREAM. Believe me you won't be disappointed.⁠
⁠
Valentines Day orders will be picked up on Feb. 13th..

Address

4391 S State Road 5
South Whitley, IN
46787

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Pie Lady on 5 posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Pie Lady on 5:

Videos

Category

Nearby restaurants


Other South Whitley restaurants

Show All

Comments

Rhubarb pie was AMAZING! If y'all haven't tried The Pie Lady On 5's pies, go git ya one! You won't be disappointed! Thanks, Carlene! My mom and I enjoyed every morsel!
My Yummy Sugar Cream Pie
Yesterday I picked up Rhubarb Cream and Cherry Crumble pies from The Pie Lady on 5! They are both amazing and I savored every bite! When you eat the WHOLE crust and none is left on the plate you know you've got a great pie! They were yummy for breakfast too! I'll be back soon Carlene! Thank you!
Watched your segment on the Create TV (PBS) entitled "A Few Good Pie Places" ~~ your sugar cream pie looked amazing. Wishing the best in your adventures.
Thank you again for making the pies for Craig's open house. His wife is hooked on the chocolate sugar cream and Tom and I agree you make the best pecan pie we've ever had!
Do you do Cobblers?
Will it be okay to freeze one of your sugar cream pies to serve at a later date?
Watched you on A Few Good Pie Places.....jealous ! NY state doesn't let you sell pies from your driveway 😟
If you have not tried it, order the Cherry Cream Crumble pie......best ever!
Cindy Norris you need to get Dad a sugar cream pie from her πŸ˜‰
I have a wish! Someday I wish I can try some of your sugar cream pie ! A gal can wish ! Inspiring work!