The Bay Street

The Bay Street Delicious fine dining, all homemade with a Louisiana Flare, famous Martini Bar and a Sushi food truck
(610)

Jerry and Deannie Newby new owners are creating amazing dishes from Filet mignon to Seafood Newby - lobster crab bisque, Pork and Veal chops also don the menu - very unique to Key West Food and New Orleans food The Martini Bar has over 200 on its expansive Menu - created and inspired by DeannieMartini. Lindsey lou and Angelic Angela are there to guide you thru and find what you are looking for .

.Casual Cozy atmosphere with a great Bay Street Family to serve you and some old Sodus Point Charm - always here to make magic happen. Make those reservations as we book up fast - 315-483-2233 ..heres to another great season./.

Just a lil look at the new Back Alley Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s at the Baystreet. Going to be the best summer ev...
06/02/2026

Just a lil look at the new Back Alley Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s at the Baystreet. Going to be the best summer ever and we are so excited for what the top of the hill has to offer. Open Thursdays to Mondays for us and check out their page for hours and menu. Everything we both offer is fresh, homemade and made with love ❤️. Come let us all make magic happen for you this season!!!!

🦞🚨 INTRODUCING OUR FOOTLONG LOBSTER ROLL! 🚨🦞

This isn’t just a lobster roll… it’s a FOOTLONG lobster roll loaded from end to end with sweet lobster meat!

We’ve already sold 7 of these monsters, and it’s easy to see why! Have it made hot with butter, cold with mayo, or any way you want it.

Perfect for sharing… or keeping all to yourself. We won’t judge! 😎

No matter how you order it, you really can’t go wrong.

📍 Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s
🕒 Open Early Today at 3 PM
🦞 Footlong Lobster Roll
🍋 Made Your Way
🔥 Fresh • Loaded • Delicious

Come get yours!

Monday fun day at the Baystreet!! Come play on this gorgeous sunshiny day. Back Alley Grill is cooking up all your fa...
06/01/2026

Monday fun day at the Baystreet!! Come play on this gorgeous sunshiny day. Back Alley Grill is cooking up all your favs. Foot long lobster rolls are a huge hit… trying their truffle butter one tonight !!!! Bar menu is featuring lobster tacos and filet mignon sliders. Mix and match to surf and turf it !! Ocean Delite seafood platter is flying out the door as an appetizer or dinner.. Dining room has roasted rack of lamb and shrimp and scallops Louisiana in a spicy green onion butter sauce over angel hair pasta !!! Mamas carrot cake, strawberryrhubarb pie or one of our amazing dessert martinis will round out your culinary experience. Hope everyone is getting ready for an amazing last summer season with us on top of the hill !!!

Best of luck guys. Nice having another place to enjoy in our village
06/01/2026

Best of luck guys. Nice having another place to enjoy in our village

Ok so yeah. This is my absolute fav. They had my heart when they decided to join us and allow me to enjoy this delicio...
05/31/2026

Ok so yeah. This is my absolute fav. They had my heart when they decided to join us and allow me to enjoy this delicious treat. Truffle mushroom is now only one of my favs they offer !!!

🍔 TRUFFLE SHUFFLE SMASH BURGER 🍔

This one is for the mushroom lovers! 🤤

Our perfectly smashed beef patty is topped with melted Swiss cheese, a generous pile of sautéed mushrooms, and finished with rich, savory white truffle butter on a soft bakery roll.

Simple. Decadent. Absolutely unforgettable.

✨ One bite and you’ll know why it’s called the Truffle Shuffle.

📍 Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s
🕓 Open now until 10pm!

Who’s ordering one tonight? 👇🍔🔥

One of mine and Jerry’s favs. Check it out tomoro kids. Reopen at 4 pm. These guys are rocking the the back alley gril...
05/31/2026

One of mine and Jerry’s favs. Check it out tomoro kids. Reopen at 4 pm. These guys are rocking the the back alley grill and bringing all new Amazing foods !!! Chicken French Sammy is one of my favs and the dill pickle smash is another amazing gf option. Come see what Ben and Brittany our doing in our Back Alley. Call and reserve a table In our bar area and enjoy their delicious food and our amazing bar cocktails !! See yall soon !!

🍔 The Flying Dutchman 🍔

No bun? No problem.

Juicy smash burger layered with melty American cheese, sandwiched between thick-cut grilled onion discs and wrapped in a crispy cheddar cheese crust. That’s right—completely gluten-free and packed with bold flavor in every bite.

🔥 Crispy cheese crust
🧅 Grilled onion “bun”
🧀 Melty American cheese
🍔 Double smash patties
✅ Gluten-Free

The burger for those who want all the flavor and none of the bun. One bite and you’ll understand why it’s called The Flying Dutchman. ✈️🍔

And don’t forget the delicious imprint coffee
05/30/2026

And don’t forget the delicious imprint coffee

Sounds like lunch tomoro. Support local all. You know I’m trying that pickle pizza !!!
05/30/2026

Sounds like lunch tomoro. Support local all. You know I’m trying that pickle pizza !!!

05/30/2026

Tell us what you think. !!!

Send a message to learn more

Woohoo kids it’s Friday. Come enjoy all the deliciousness in one spot at the top of the hill. Amazing Martinis 🍸, fabu...
05/29/2026

Woohoo kids it’s Friday. Come enjoy all the deliciousness in one spot at the top of the hill. Amazing Martinis 🍸, fabulous fine dining, scrumptious seafood bar and Back alley food truck with all your smashing favorites. Going to be a great season to get to the Point and enjoy all our lil village has to offer… support local all. Open 4 pm for the bar and Giussepinas Back alley Grill and 5 pm for fine dining. Call 483-2233 after 1 pm for reservations

Address

8427 Bay Street
Sodus Point, NY
14555

Opening Hours

Monday 4pm - 10pm
Thursday 4pm - 10pm
Friday 4pm - 11pm
Saturday 4pm - 11pm
Sunday 4pm - 10pm

Telephone

+13154832233

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Bay Street posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category