The Bay Street

The Bay Street Delicious fine dining, all homemade with a Louisiana Flare, famous Martini Bar and a Sushi food truck
(611)

Jerry and Deannie Newby new owners are creating amazing dishes from Filet mignon to Seafood Newby - lobster crab bisque, Pork and Veal chops also don the menu - very unique to Key West Food and New Orleans food The Martini Bar has over 200 on its expansive Menu - created and inspired by DeannieMartini. Lindsey lou and Angelic Angela are there to guide you thru and find what you are looking for .

.Casual Cozy atmosphere with a great Bay Street Family to serve you and some old Sodus Point Charm - always here to make magic happen. Make those reservations as we book up fast - 315-483-2233 ..heres to another great season./.

07/17/2026
Herewe go kids.  Good luck out there to all you fisherman.  See y’all after your fun filled days
07/16/2026

Herewe go kids. Good luck out there to all you fisherman. See y’all after your fun filled days

Week  #2 of pan seared Halibut with a cheese souflee or basil saffron sauce.. Roasted Rack of lamb with a Demi glaze ove...
07/16/2026

Week #2 of pan seared Halibut with a cheese souflee or basil saffron sauce.. Roasted Rack of lamb with a Demi glaze over garlic mashed potatoes ..16 oz certified angus beef Ribeyes and halibut and crab chowder is our soup. The bar is running some good ole comfort with my spaghetti wrapped cheese sticks with home made sauce and fresh mozerella baked to perfection..lobster taco and all oysters are back fresh from the Chesapeake bay!! Mangus farm blueberry lemonade martinis are flowing this weekend and save some room for all mamas homemade deserts including black cap pie and cheesecake…Back Alley grill is open for lunch and dinner Thursday to Tuesdays as well !! So make those plans to Come enjoy all the top of the hill has to offer all in one great place.. fine dining, lite bar menu, massive martini menu and banging food truck. Hope to see y’all this weekend. Call for reservations Thursday to Mondays after 1 pm 315-483-2233

07/14/2026

Music 🎶 Tuesday on July 14 at the Ball Field for the Neighborhood Association of Sodus Point - NASP from 6-8pm. Make sure to swing by the Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s behind The Bay Street at 5pm to grab dinner, bring your chair, and enjoy some 🎶 on the field.

Just saying. Our guy Ben And Gephen are out there in this heat and ready to serve the masses.  We got the ultimate Owen ...
07/14/2026

Just saying. Our guy Ben And Gephen are out there in this heat and ready to serve the masses. We got the ultimate Owen nachos and an açaí bowl and it was amazing. That sandwich is no joke. Karmy Jon loved it too. Thanks for feeding us again Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s on this hot Tuesday. It was nice to not have to cook !!!

Music 🎶 Tuesday on July 14 at the Ball Field for the Neighborhood Association of Sodus Point - NASP from 6-8pm. Make sure to swing by the Back Alley Grill by Giuseppina’s behind The Bay Street at 5pm to grab dinner, bring your chair, and enjoy some 🎶 on the field.

Woohoo check this out guys !!!   I know what I’m having tomoro
07/14/2026

Woohoo check this out guys !!! I know what I’m having tomoro

🔥 Tuesday Staff-Inspired Special: The Ultimate Owen 🔥

Some of the best menu ideas come straight from our crew, and this one earned a spot as our Tuesday special.

Introducing The Ultimate Owen—a toasted sub piled high with chopped burger, bacon, and Cooper Sharp, then finished with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, jalapeños, and our signature smoky chipotle aioli. Every bite is packed with bold flavor.

This one is only available Tuesday (tomorrow), so don’t miss your chance to get it!

Who’s grabbing one tomorrow? 🍔🥖🔥

So blessed to have a moment with these long time friends.  We were slammed and they chose to hang and enjoy our place, f...
07/13/2026

So blessed to have a moment with these long time friends. We were slammed and they chose to hang and enjoy our place, food and atmosphere long enough for us to get a chance to catch up and then get some pix. Luvs you Dottie and Bob and grateful for our moments together xoxo

This… This is Sodus Point.  So much good here, places, people, businesses and sights.  Make the trip..Thanks to all who ...
07/12/2026

This… This is Sodus Point. So much good here, places, people, businesses and sights. Make the trip..Thanks to all who always support our village and lil piece of paradise we call home

Sodus Point has become one of those places I return to again and again. It feels far enough away, but close enough that it still feels like home. Every trip I find something new and I know I’ll keep finding reasons to come back.

As a photographer, I don’t think I’ve ever run out of things to capture here. Whether it’s the lighthouse, the beach, or simply the way the light hits the water, there’s beauty in every direction if you take the time to look.

No matter the weather, there’s always something beautiful to photograph. I have been during the heat of summer and the dead of winter. Summer brings the beach to life with warm days and beautiful sunlight. Winter transforms the lake into something dramatic and powerful with the sun being hidden behind clouds and snow heavy on the sand. Every visit feels a little different, and that’s part of what keeps me coming back. Photo developed and scanned by // 7/8

Save the date for Mondays in July.  We are doing seafood and surf and turf at the bar !!! New menu items this week so ma...
07/12/2026

Save the date for Mondays in July. We are doing seafood and surf and turf at the bar !!! New menu items this week so make those plans and grab those friends for the hottest spot in the Point. Pair it with your favorite martinis or specialty cocktails, Dont forget to save room fo desserts like mamas homemade cheesecake and carrot cake or Youngman farms strawberry ice cream cakes..Back alley grill has awesome seafood lobster roll features and their new claw father burger too so come check us out. Reservations in the bar area is highly recommended as we fill up fast. Also outdoor seating available on our porch for all this deliciousness !!!! 315-483-2233 after 1 pm for reservations Thursday to Mondays !!

Address

8427 Bay Street
Sodus Point, NY
14555

Opening Hours

Monday 4pm - 10pm
Thursday 4pm - 10pm
Friday 4pm - 11pm
Saturday 4pm - 11pm
Sunday 4pm - 10pm

Telephone

+13154832233

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Bay Street posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share