The Bay Street

The Bay Street Delicious fine dining, all homemade with a Louisiana Flare, famous Martini Bar and a Sushi food truck
(610)

Jerry and Deannie Newby new owners are creating amazing dishes from Filet mignon to Seafood Newby - lobster crab bisque, Pork and Veal chops also don the menu - very unique to Key West Food and New Orleans food The Martini Bar has over 200 on its expansive Menu - created and inspired by DeannieMartini. Lindsey lou and Angelic Angela are there to guide you thru and find what you are looking for .

.Casual Cozy atmosphere with a great Bay Street Family to serve you and some old Sodus Point Charm - always here to make magic happen. Make those reservations as we book up fast - 315-483-2233 ..heres to another great season./.

Surf and Turf Monday is here. Filet mignon sliders and lobster tacos. Also our new cheesy jumbo crab cake toast topped ...
08/31/2026

Surf and Turf Monday is here. Filet mignon sliders and lobster tacos. Also our new cheesy jumbo crab cake toast topped with ribeye steak is sure to be delish…Call and reserve those tables as we fill up fast. !!! Dining rooms last week of halibut and roasted rack of lamb. New menu week coming up for the holiday weekend so make those plans and grab those friends to kick off the end of summer season !!!! 315-483-2233 Thursday to Mondays after 1 pm. Back alley grill is rocking tonight too for their last couple Mondays. So come let Ben fill your Belly’s with all your summer favorites. Lobster rolls, claw fathers and our new CAB burgers from Palmers direct to you markets !!! Soo delish and yummy try a claw father burger tonight for surf and turf. Garlic lobster atop a smash burger is really delightful !! Bar and BAG open at 4 fine dining and lite bar menu at 5

08/30/2026

Remember tomoro is surf and turf Monday s in the bar area ..Make those plans and come enjoy all we have to offer Reserve a table for you and your friends !!

Luvs us some youngman farm markets !!!
08/30/2026

Luvs us some youngman farm markets !!!

Woohoo the weekend is here. Come celebrate Baystreet and Back Alley Grill style. Open 4 pm for bar and BAG and 5 pm for...
08/28/2026

Woohoo the weekend is here. Come celebrate Baystreet and Back Alley Grill style. Open 4 pm for bar and BAG and 5 pm for fine dining and lite bar menu. Hope to see you all

Just a heads up we will be closed Sunday September 13-17 th for our annual after Labor Day break. You all have been ama...
08/27/2026

Just a heads up we will be closed Sunday September 13-17 th for our annual after Labor Day break. You all have been amazing showing us love and support this season and we want to give our staff the same. They have worked countless hours mastering, creating and executing their crafts and showcasing ours. We have been through a lot together this season for sure with lots of challenges, personal issues, losses, gains and families needs.. We have grown so much together this year and it’s all so bittersweet. Please take the time to spend with your own families to make the memories, take the pictures and for gods sake..Eat the cake !!!! We love you all and are ready for a lil bit of down time before our favorite time of the year starts. Thanks to all the new and old friends we’ve been blessed with over our 30 years in this business

08/27/2026

Week #2 showcases pan-seared halibut with cheese soufflé or basil saffron sauce, lobster bisque, 16 oz Ribeyes, and Roasted Rack of lamb. The bar menu includes hot honey chicken sliders and lobster tacos, with fresh oysters in stock for the last two weeks of summer. Come and indulge in fine dining, paired with our exceptional martini menu. Our hours of operation are Thursdays through Mondays, with bar and Back Alley Grill hours beginning at 4 pm and fine dining and lite bar menu starting at 5 pm. To make reservations, please call us at 315-483-2233.

Don’t forget to make those plans to come spend the last two weeks of summer with us !! Reservations highly recommended s...
08/25/2026

Don’t forget to make those plans to come spend the last two weeks of summer with us !! Reservations highly recommended so call 315-483-2233 Thursday to Mondays after 1 pm. We are closed Tuesday and Wednesdays. We only accept reservations thru our house phone lines. Thank you and continue enjoying all Sodus Point has to offer !!!! Also a huge thank you to all those who take the magnificent pix of our lil piece of paradise. Heres some of the pix of our fun filled season so far with you all!! Drop yours let’s see what you got !!!!!!

Apple tasting tour is coming up !!! Fall is the best time of year here in upstate NY. We will have lots of yummy App...
08/25/2026

Apple tasting tour is coming up !!! Fall is the best time of year here in upstate NY. We will have lots of yummy Apple Martinis 🍸 these next two months

Address

8427 Bay Street
Sodus Point, NY
14555

Opening Hours

Monday 4pm - 10pm
Thursday 4pm - 10pm
Friday 4pm - 11pm
Saturday 4pm - 11pm
Sunday 4pm - 10pm

Telephone

+13154832233

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Bay Street posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category