Costello's Pizzeria

Costello's Pizzeria Costello's Pizzeria is located at 45 S New York Road in the Smithville section of Galloway Township.!

We are open year-round and offer Dine in, pick up & local deliveries orders.

🌈 Calm before the storm… but there’s gold at the end of the rainbow. ✨ Happy Friday from Costello’s!
09/25/2026

🌈 Calm before the storm… but there’s gold at the end of the rainbow. ✨ Happy Friday from Costello’s!

🚨 Last call for this week’s Smithville specials! 🚨It’s Friday, which means today is your last chance to grab the Vodka M...
09/25/2026

🚨 Last call for this week’s Smithville specials! 🚨

It’s Friday, which means today is your last chance to grab the Vodka Margherita Pizza, Chicken Cutlet Caprese Salad, Vodka Bomb Sub, or Sicilian Baked Ziti before next week’s specials take their place! 🍕🥗🥖🍝

Which one are you ordering before they’re gone? Available for pickup, delivery, and dine-in at Costello’s Smithville! ❤️💚

We are hiring for delivery drivers at all 3 of our locations. Please stop in to any of our shops for an application!
09/24/2026

We are hiring for delivery drivers at all 3 of our locations. Please stop in to any of our shops for an application!

Smithville, there’s still time to try this week’s specials! 🙌🍕The Vodka Margherita Pizza, Chicken Cutlet Caprese Salad, ...
09/24/2026

Smithville, there’s still time to try this week’s specials! 🙌🍕

The Vodka Margherita Pizza, Chicken Cutlet Caprese Salad, Vodka Bomb Sub, and Sicilian Baked Ziti are all available today and tomorrow. Which one are you grabbing before the week is over? 👀

Stop in, order pickup, or get your favorites delivered! ❤️

09/23/2026

Another Sponsor Alert!

🍕 A HUGE THANK YOU TO COSTELLO'S SMITHVILLE 🍕

Galloway PAL would like to give a special thank you to Costello’s Pizzeria in Smithville, NJ, for being a valued sponsor and supporting our youth and community!

Your generosity throughout the years has helped Galloway PAL continue providing positive opportunities and experiences for local kids. We truly appreciate your support!

Thank you, Costello’s Pizzeria, for supporting Galloway PAL!

Fun Fact: Costello's has three locations! Smithville, Galloway, and Hammonton! They just relocated to Smithville Square, moving from Smithville Village and currently at 45 S New York Rd, Smithville, NJ 08205!

Try out some of their new menu items!

Thank you from Galloway PAL!

🚨 YOU ASKED… WE LISTENED, SMITHVILLE! 🚨Before we relocated, our daily specials were a Smithville favorite — and one of t...
09/22/2026

🚨 YOU ASKED… WE LISTENED, SMITHVILLE! 🚨

Before we relocated, our daily specials were a Smithville favorite — and one of the things we’ve been asked to bring back the most. Well… THEY’RE BACK! 🍕🍝🥪

But we’re switching things up a little! Instead of a different special every day, we’ll be featuring 4 WEEKLY SPECIALS available Monday–Friday, giving you all week to try them. 🙌

Each week, expect a new lineup featuring pizzas, subs & pastas that you won’t find on our everyday menu! Our Parmesan pasta dinners will be sticking around on the regular menu, but we’ll also be rotating in a different pasta special every week. 👀

🔥 THIS WEEK’S LINEUP:
🍕 Vodka Margherita Pizza — $13.99
🥗 Chicken Cutlet Caprese Salad — $13.99
🥪 Vodka Bomb Sub — $15.99
🍝 Sicilian Baked Ziti — $15.99

Available Monday–Friday for pickup, delivery & dine-in!

Smithville specials are officially BACK — which one are you trying first?! 👇

🏈 FOOTBALL SUNDAYS ARE BETTER WITH COSTELLO’S! 🏈Game day = good food, cold drinks & FOOTBALL SPECIALS! 🔥🍕🍗Every Monday, ...
09/20/2026

🏈 FOOTBALL SUNDAYS ARE BETTER WITH COSTELLO’S! 🏈

Game day = good food, cold drinks & FOOTBALL SPECIALS! 🔥🍕🍗

Every Monday, Thursday & Sunday during football season, grab one of our game-day bundles featuring pizza, tails, wings, cheesesteaks & more! 🙌

Whether you’re watching from the couch or catching the game with us, we’ve got you covered.

📍 Smithville • The Nest • Hammonton
🚗 Pick Up • Delivery • Dine-In

🏈 FOOTBALL + COSTELLO’S = THE PERFECT COMBO.
Call ahead and get your order in before kickoff! 🍕🍗💚

🍔🔥 SMITHVILLE IS STACKED. 🔥🍔Whether you’re going smash burger or crispy chicken, you really can’t miss with this lineup ...
09/19/2026

🍔🔥 SMITHVILLE IS STACKED. 🔥🍔

Whether you’re going smash burger or crispy chicken, you really can’t miss with this lineup 👀

🌶️ Italian Long Hot Smash Burger: bold, cheesy & bringing the heat
🥓 BBQ Bacon Smash Burger: BBQ sauce, crispy bacon, onion rings, & sliced cheddar cheese.
🔥 Crispy Chicken Chipotle Ranch: crispy butter milk fried chicken thigh loaded chipotle ranch & bacon

Three heavy hitters. One tough decision. 🤤

📍 Costello’s Smithville
Pickup • Delivery • Dine-In

Midweek slump? We’ve got the cure. 🤤🔥🥖 Chicken Cutlet Caesar — crispy chicken cutlet, romaine, parmesan & Caesar dressin...
09/16/2026

Midweek slump? We’ve got the cure. 🤤🔥

🥖 Chicken Cutlet Caesar — crispy chicken cutlet, romaine, parmesan & Caesar dressing on a toasted garlic roll.

🌶️ Nashville Chicken Sandwich — crispy, spicy and bringing the heat.

🔥 Spicy Chicken Parm — breaded chicken cutlet, marinara, melted cheese & a little extra kick, all on a toasted garlic roll.

Wednesday calls for something GOOD. 🙌 Stop by Smithville and let us handle dinner! 🍕🥪

Address

45 South New York Road
Smithville, NJ
08205

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+16096520378

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Costello's Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Costello's Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category