Commander Cody's Seafood

Commander Cody's Seafood Fresh fish market(open daily ) and lobster tank. Take out food & Outdoor Seating available with limited indoor dining.

Please wear face covering when entering market and to pick up food. Commander Cody's Seafood is a fresh fish market featuring a live lobster tank. We have a variety of local fish and shellfish as well as fish from the Gulf Coast. Take-Out style dining with tables available inside and picnic tables on our covered patio. THURSDAY'S are our SENIOR DISCOUNT 10%OFF fish market only, not available on lo

bsters or Local Peconic Bay Scallops. Summer Menu features Lobster Clambakes, perfect for sunsets at the beach. Lunch is served from 12noon-2:30pm on Thursday to Sunday and dinner is served from 4pm-8:30pm NIGHTLY(9pm Fri./Sat.) Lobster Rolls available summer season only.

08/15/2021

Thanks everyone for another successful weekend. Be sure to get your orders in EARLY for your preferred pick up time.

FYI...
WE WILL BE CLOSED WEDNESDAY AUGUST 18TH!

08/11/2021

WE ARE CLOSED TODAY WEDNESDAY AUGUST 11TH. SEE Y'ALL TOMORROW.

07/31/2021

GET YOUR ORDERS IN EARLY TODAY FOLKS (CALL AFTER 11AM). SERIOUSLY. IF YOU TRY TO CALL IN @ 5PM, EXPECT A LONGER THAN USUAL WAIT. WE ARE A TEAM OF 3 TODAY AND WE WILL DO OUR VERY BEST TO ACCOMMODATE YOU, BUT WE ASK FOR YOUR PATIENCE TODAY.

07/24/2021

Get your food orders in early for dinner pick up(4pm-8:30pm).
Expect longer than usual wait times(especially if you do not pre-order) as we have limited staff this season.

Serving limited lunch today:
LOBSTER ROLLS OR FRIED CHICKEN BASKET.
Shrimp cocktail available as always.
No raw bar.

WE THANK YOU IN ADVANCE FOR YOUR UNDERSTANDING AND PATIENCE.

07/22/2021

TONIGHT'S SPECIALS...
COD FISH-N-CHIPS $23
BLACKENED TUNA $26

07/16/2021

Due to the extreme heat in our kitchen today, we will not be offering "broiled entrées" tonight. No pastas as well.

07/07/2021

FYI...
Our kitchen will be closed on Wednesdays! Fish market will be open.

Cold bbq fried chicken platter. Available in our "grab-n-go" fridge.
07/01/2021

Cold bbq fried chicken platter. Available in our "grab-n-go" fridge.

06/30/2021

CHILLED LOBSTER PLATTERS ARE BACK IN STOCK.🦞
PERFECT FOR THE ⛱

06/14/2021

Wednesday June 15th...
We will open @ 3pm for the FISH MARKET. Dinner @ 4pm.

06/09/2021

Limited dinner menu this evening. No broiled entrées or pasta. Dinner available from 4pm-7:30pm. We close @ 8pm.

Address

41 Smith Street
Shelter Island, NY
11964

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 2:30pm - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Telephone

+16317491851

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Commander Cody's Seafood posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category