Shelter Island SLICE

10/01/2026

The ovens are hot, and the $25 deal is calling! 🔥

🍕 Plain Pie
🥗 House Salad
🧄 4 Garlic Knots
💰 All for just $25!

09/30/2026

09/27/2026

Shelter Island Slice will be closed tomorrow, Sunday, September 27.

We’ll be back Wednesday at 11:30 a.m., just in time for 2 for $25 Heroes, Trivia, and more!

Stay safe, stay dry, & we’ll see you soon! ❤

09/26/2026

Frankie’s still slinging pies! 🍕🌧️

Shelter Island Slice is open today from 11:30 AM–4 PM for pizzas only (Frankie kindly let the crew stay home and cozy up!).

Grab your pizza now and hunker down later.

09/24/2026

Happy Pizza Thursday!

🍕 Plain Pie
🥗 House Salad
🧄 4 Garlic Knots
💰 All for just $25!

09/20/2026

🎉 There’s a LOT to celebrate at Slice today! 🏈🍕

It’s Frankie’s birthday (shhh… don’t tell him we told you 🤫👑), AND it’s 🏈 Football Sunday AND it’s pick any TWO for $22!

09/18/2026

This just in according to Joe…
“Check your horoscope.. YOU need that spinach and artichoke pizza in your life.” 🤣

09/17/2026

🍕 Pizza Thursday at Slice! 🍕
The ovens are hot, and the $25 deal is calling! 🔥

🍕 Plain Pie
🥗 House Salad
🧄 4 Garlic Knots
💰 All for just $25!

09/16/2026

🌟 WEDNESDAYS AT SLICE 🌟
Your midweek plans just got a whole lot tastier! 🍝🍻

🍴 2 for $25 Heroes
🧠 Trivia starts at 6 PM
🍺 $5 drinks for trivia participants

Grab a friend, bring your A-game, and come hungry! 🏆

09/13/2026

Skip the Sunday scaries and get the 2 for $22 at Shelter Island Slice—because the only thing you should be stressing about is which two to choose.