Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria

08/12/2026

The Real Chef is not just a job position and definitely not for everyone to fully understand what it means!

06/26/2026

The web is a marvelous grind:

PP: “Good pizza!”

TR: “Rocco delivered to our vacation home and was extremely friendly and nice. Good pizza.”

KF: “The pizza is amazing, and the owner is very nice and hospitable and I appreciate it being so close to my house.”

JS: “Order to go, customized pizza and made just the way I wanted! Salads were just as ordered and included extra cheese and dressing. Rocco and his team are amazing!"

KE: “Nicest service I’ve had in a long time. Feels like talking with family”

RW: “Rocco ---your food never lets us down. Was in there last night and meet a local who said it was her first time there. She loved your pizza. If you live close to Sarasota and have never been here --you need to go there See ya next time Rocco”

NC: “Delivery made exactly on time and super hot. Looks delicious.”

MD: “Lived in New York, I know my pizza this place had the crust just like it and the taste. I had pepperoni with jalapeños something | like and came out just right, very fresh hot pizza”

MC: “Came here Friday night. Staff was absolutely warm and inviting. Rocco was awesome, he treated us like family. Pizza was fresh and not overdone with seasoning. Me and my friend loved this place and would gladly go back if we find ourselves in the Sarasota area again.”
JU: “Service and pizza is perfect. Crispy thin crust. Fresh. Exactly what I'm looking for. Best in town.”

KW: “Great authentic Italian pizzeria. No matter what you order, you will enjoy it in this familial atmosphere.”

MM: “Pizza was great. I love anchovies and not all the pizza places have it”

LR: “So delish! Definitely will be back when we are in town. The gluten free pizza was so good! I love the thin crust and the toppings were really good as well. If you are gluten free this place is a must try.”

MD: “I work across the street and frequent Fresh Mozzarella. Rocco and his staff have always been awesome and the food is amazing, very authentic, original and fresh. Very homemade and not something you can get from a chain or franchise. Because it is so good sometimes it's a little busy so you may have to be patient but it is so worth it. Perfection really. Prices are great for real home cooked food. It's so good it remind me of my trip to Italy.”

NI: “I am very impressed by the way you treated the Selby library with the fresh delicious healthy foods you prepared for this Cooking Demo just as requested also. You were the BEST CHEF WE EVER HAD!!!

SH: “We did delivery… the webpage was incredibly well laid out and the pizza surpassed our expectations! Will definitely order again!”

KP: ”I had a spectacular meal tonight! My pizza was just perfect size and tasted incredible 🤩”

RM: “Good Pizza and Calzone”

DF: "Love their Supreme Pizza"

JP: “Fresh Mozzarella Pizza is ALWAYS amazing! Food and service is the best! Rocco is from ITALY so KNOWS pizza and is just a downright cool person.”

SO: “Pizza was delicious and the sauce was perfect - not too sweet. Would definitely recommend.”

JN: “Pizza was delicious and the sauce was perfect - not too sweet. Would definitely recommend."

TM: “This is real pizza, real fast. Great quality every time. It's my go to pie whenever in in SRQ”

CC: “The pizzas are very good; they are delicious.”

top10 Sarasota Sarasota County Government The Ritz-Carlton, Sarasota Must See Sarasota Yocal SRQ Food & Wine Food Network Kitchen Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria

05/25/2026

happy Memorial Day!
we are open as normal hours!
thank you for helping community stay strong!

05/02/2026

So many Food Lovers, Thank you everyone:

TS: “Great place and it’s a local place that everyone goes to and delicious!”

DC: “Fell in love with first bite. Treat your buds to a taste of heaven A true treasure"

SD: “This is the best pizza in town! We enjoy the food, hospitality,
it’s a wonderful place to visit. Try the white pizza!”

NP: “The pizza is amazing. I just got a cheese pizza and it is everything you want in a pizza."

BA: “Rocco and his team are great and food is delicious”

AT:” Very good pizza! Very thin. Awesome sauce!”

VM: “food was good and service was on time.”

JP: “One of our FAVORITES!! Pizza is A-MAZING and pizza is my favorite food group! Yes...I love it THAT much! Rocco is so kind, accommodating and FROM Italy so... knows pizza and it's perfection!”

JD: “Great place for pizza! Order on the app, pizza is ready on time. The crust is thin and crispy, can tell it is handmade.”

ML: “ Excellent pizza”

MD: “Upon arrival was greeted immediately, Chef Rocco’s pizza is the best. I am a former New Yorker and critical of my pizza, Highly recommend!”

DS: “I had the stromboli and garlic knots! Great food.”

AD: “Great neighborhood pizza shop! Downtown but without the parking jams. Ordered numerous times for work pizza parties. Always hot, fresh and on time! Try the white pizza!”

Jnfr: “Great place for pizza! Order on the app, pizza is ready on time. The crust is thin and crispy, can tell it is handmade."

JF: “I found this restaurant smelling tbe pizza driving by in my car with my car windows down. I stopped and went in . I ordered a pizza to go . I have never eaten anything as wonderful as the pizza from this restaurant . I recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants to enjoy authentic Italian pizza . I had never eaten the real thing until I went inside the restaurant that day I smelled it driving by.”

Rocco Cartia Chef Rocco Cartia Malin Cartia

04/17/2026

New reviews from the web:

NM: “Authentic and delicious”

CV: “Fresh Mozzarella’s has delivered pizzas for our Tennis party at Payne Park Tennis Center a few times now. I’ve used their app, which is very easy to use to pre-order and schedule the delivery. Every time they have been on time, the pizza has been hot and fresh, and it is ABSOLUTELY delicious. I definitely recommend their pizza and their service!”

DS: “I had the stromboli and garlic knots! Great food”

AT: “Very good pizza! Very thin. Awesome sauce!”

BW: “Quick decision for dinner with a busy evening. So glad, Stromboli and Cannoli!”

DR: “Tonight I had Fresh Mozzarella delivered. Jeffrey was such a great delivery guy. All smiles. The wedding soup and bruschetta were a perfect light dinner. So flavorful…tasted home-cooked. We have ordered from this place so many times. I think we’ve tried the whole menu. Fresh Mozzarella never disappoints. Five stars!”

FG: “top of the line pizza place, authentic ppl and quality pie.”

VM: “food was good and service was on time"

MP: ”Food was very good especially white pizza and Rocco was dedicated to outstanding service”

SR: “New local, first time customer. Will 10/10 be back!”

AP: “Delicious! Thin crust, cheese/sauce ratio is on point, friendly staff, great prices.”

Y: “Outstanding pizza. Highly recommend the white pizza, the calzone or the Spicy Mixed Sub but I can't imagine going wrong with anything.”

PA: “One of the best pizzas in Sarasota, definitely number 1 for take out; authentic Italian, amazing crust, fresh flavors and made with love by the owner himself. They close early (10 PM on weekends), and that's the only thing that kept me from knowing this pizza joint before! Will be back for sure!”

BD: “I am a Retired road warrior and probably have had Pizza all over US Canada and Europe… This place is great and Rocco makes it happen. Highly recommend.”

CP: “Fresh food made to Order. Pizza is great. Calzone and do NOT miss the Cannoli!”

DD: “Staying at a hotel so ordered delivery. Sandwich was great, the cake was good…”

JP: “Great food!”

EC: ”Service was good, order taken promptly and food delivered quickly. The caprese salad, the white, pepperoni, cheese pizzas and cannolis we had were great. Cin cin!”

Cjp: “The two large slices of cheese for $5 is a deal you can’t beat. Very delicious. I will be coming here often whenever I am in Downtown Sarasota for work. Service was prompt, and food came out piping hot. Nice job Rocco.”

04/17/2026

Great times ahead for these young talented soccer players, it was great to have these amazing families around for the end of the season party! 2016 Girls Black!

04/05/2026

02/23/2026

Fun “ Fresh Cooking Classes ”. Feel free to check our schedule for the remaining classes in February at https://www.signupgenius.com/go/10C044DABA92FA6F9C25-60216274-fresh #/

02/23/2026

If you’re wondering where to park at Fresh Mozzarella:
https://maps.app.goo.gl/7qjmdXst2s2RrLsS6

02/19/2026

Cooking Classes at Fresh Mozzarella!
Below its February’s schedule.
Please express your interest by signing up at:
https://www.signupgenius.com/go/10C044DABA92FA6F9C25-60216274-fresh #/
3 spot left for Friday 02/20 class!
2 spot left for Sunday 02/22 class! to sign up follow the link above, send a message here, text/call 4086076032 or email [email protected]
and we’ll sign you up you asap!