Criminal Baking & Catering Company

10/21/2026

Maple Pecan Pie 🍁 🥧

But wait!

Are those pistachios in there too?

Nuts! Just nuts!

Get your Thanksgiving order in before other weird stuff starts happening. Link to order is in our bio.

10/18/2026

Chocolate cream pie is on our Thanksgiving menu this year! Don’t worry, so are favorites like pumpkin, maple pecan, sweet potato. I will stop taking orders when I get to the point where I feel like a wild turkey….or like drinking wild turkey 🦃
Here’s the link: https://www.hotplate.com/criminalpieandpantry/40cbee92-4043-47ef-8994-5436486b0cf5
or email me at [email protected]

10/17/2026

Need something to do tomorrow, Saturday 10/17, from 11-2ish pm? Join us for a Deep Dish Quiche Class! I have 3 spots. Email me by 9am at [email protected] to enjoy brunch while learning how to make it 😁

10/14/2026

🥧 PIE CLUB: October Flavors Are Here, and November Is Coming!

There’s still time to join us for our fourth-week pickup in October! If you’ve been thinking about joining Pie Club, now’s your chance to bring some deliciousness to your dinner table.

OCTOBER FLAVORS
🐷 Pulled Pork Pie — hearty, savory comfort food.
🍠 Sweet Potato Pie — seasonal sweetness in every bite.
🥕 Veggie Pie — cozy, satisfying fall goodness.

COMING IN NOVEMBER
🦃 Turkey Dinner Pot Pie — Thanksgiving comfort food tucked into a flaky crust.
🍄 Mushroom Stew Pie — a hearty vegetarian option.
🎃 Pumpkin Pie — a seasonal classic!

Why join Pie Club? Reliable monthly pie at a discount plus 10% off at the shop! Pie tastings to enjoy new flavors and make pie-lovin’ friends. It’s a delicious way to simplify dinner, feed your family, and support a local small business.

Less time worrying about what’s for dinner. More time enjoying what matters. ❤️

Don’t miss October’s fourth-week pickup! Sign up now and get ready to fall in love with Pie Club.

DinnerMadeEasy SupportLocal PieLovers

10/12/2026

Thanksgiving! Get your pumpkin pie with or without chocolate and/or a number of other delicious items! Need a vegetarian main course? Try our mushroom stew pie - it can even be vegan. Need gluten-free options? We have got you covered! Order soon - we are taking a limited number of orders 😁

THANKSGIVING MENU:
https://www.hotplate.com/criminalpieandpantry/40cbee92-4043-47ef-8994-5436486b0cf5

10/10/2026

327 South A Street is where the pie’s at! Pie Club pickups are happening! Tomorrow we have a pie tasting from 2-4pm with tastes of sweet potato, short rib pot pie, and more! This is a very casual tasting :)
There will be take n bake pie for sale as well!

10/08/2026

The Living Room, an amazing local organization supporting women and children, has a great thrift store now! Check them out!

The Living Room Thrift store will be open this weekend. Come shop for cozy fall cashmere and wool sweaters, amazing furniture finds, the vintage and designer pieces you have come to expect from out store, and much much more.

Open Friday and Saturday 10-4 and Sunday 11-3
1701A Piner Road

Have donations? We accept donations Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday from 10am-3pm at the store.

Your purchases from, and donations to, The Living Room Thrift generate funding for our programs, as well as providing items directly to our participants. Thank you for all of your generosity!

10/04/2026

So much caking this weekend!
1) Our Chocolate Berry Affair Cake
2) Earl Grey Orange
3) Vegan Pumpkin / Roasted Apples & Caramel

09/29/2026

I’m waving bye to the last of my blossoms for cakes out of my garden, but hello dried flowers for autumn & winter! 🍂 ❄️

Speaking of delicious cakes, we are booked through 10/10, so get those mid & late October orders in now!

You can place cake and pie orders on our revamped online store art criminalbakingcompany.com or email me at [email protected]!

Our Thanksgiving menu will be out next week!

09/27/2026

Friday. What a night! 🥧❤️

Thank you to everyone who came out to celebrate the opening of the Pie Club with us! Seeing so many familiar faces (and meeting some new ones!) made this little dream feel very real.

Jason Farnham, you were pretty magical on electric piano!

Papillon Floral Design & Vintage, we couldn’t ask for better conspirators! We love sharing this space with you!

And now… it’s time for the pies to begin! 🥧

Our first Pie Club pickup is October 9th, and that evening will also be our next Pie Club tasting — so if you’ve been thinking about joining, now is the time!

✨ Monthly pies
✨ Twice Monthly Free Pie tasting
✨ Sweet AND savory options
✨ And plenty of delicious reasons to look forward to the 2nd & 4th weekends of each month!

Sign up now to be part of the club and make sure you’re in for our October 9th pickup and tasting!

We can’t wait to share this with you. ❤️🥧