Wagner Pie Co.

Wagner Pie Co. Welcome to Wagner Pie Co. We are an allergy friendly home baking business.

Here is the Easter menu for this year! Please send a message on this page or my personal page to order! As always, all o...
02/26/2026

Here is the Easter menu for this year! Please send a message on this page or my personal page to order! As always, all orders are appreciated 🩷

Good Morning! Easter is around the corner and I will be dropping that menu soon!!
02/26/2026

Good Morning! Easter is around the corner and I will be dropping that menu soon!!

If anyone is needing a pie for Thanksgiving, please reach out!
11/06/2025

If anyone is needing a pie for Thanksgiving, please reach out!

Happy September 🪾🍁
09/01/2025

Happy September 🪾🍁

08/13/2025

Hey everyone! I know it's been awhile since I've posted, but life happens. I have been asked if I was still baking and I am. Anytime you need something, feel free to message on my personal page or business page. I do have a full time job at the elementary school plus raising our 3 growing boys during sports season.

04/06/2025

If anybody needs to order for Easter, please reach out to me! I will be making Bunny Bait boxes again for $10 which includes the chocolate covered popcorn, M&Ms, pretzels and sprinkles & comes with chocolate covered pretzels.

03/28/2025

Hello, it's me! I will be posting my Easter offerings in the coming days... it's been a busy couple of weeks. We welcomed Baby Logan on St. Patrick's Day & are adjusting as a family of 5. 🐰

This loss is immeasurable. Many knew my Grandma Faye as the pie baker at Windell's Cafe for many years. I was fortunate ...
01/12/2025

This loss is immeasurable. Many knew my Grandma Faye as the pie baker at Windell's Cafe for many years. I was fortunate to watch her navigate through a kitchen my whole life. She would hold conversation, but she would include side notes like "once you start a Coconut pie, you can't walk away." She had phenomenal fudge cookies that cannot be compared. She also had a habit of always having a cake in the freezer "in case she had company." We will miss her smile and her sweet personality for years to come. 🙏

Thank you to everyone that has ordered this year! As 2025 rolls in, I will be taking a little break until Easter as I'm ...
12/31/2024

Thank you to everyone that has ordered this year! As 2025 rolls in, I will be taking a little break until Easter as I'm currently in my 3rd trimester! Keep an eye out for Easter specials as it gets closer
-- Courtney 🥧

Pies for a wedding!? Why not! Bride chose a variety of pies for her big day
10/11/2024

Pies for a wedding!? Why not! Bride chose a variety of pies for her big day

Hey everyone! I know it's been awhile since I've posted. Lots of BIG things in the Wagner house! YES, I AM STILL BAKING!...
09/18/2024

Hey everyone! I know it's been awhile since I've posted. Lots of BIG things in the Wagner house! YES, I AM STILL BAKING! I took on a new full time job that gives me more flexibility with baking. I plan to bake over the holidays as I am able... because we are expecting Baby #3. Please reach out for your holiday needs ~~Courtney

Address

Santa Claus, IN
47579

Telephone

+18123939139

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Wagner Pie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category