The Brick Oven Bistro

The Brick Oven Bistro Two Families...Two Countries...Two Friends The Sortino Brothers have been bringing authentic Sicilian cooking to Sandusky, Ohio since 1952. Salute!
(873)

Two Italian families immigrated to this country in search of a better life…
Alexander Scagnetti from Codroipo in Northern Italy in 1904 and Michele Sortino from Modica, Sicily in 1952. These men never knew each other, but their families would meet and form a lasting friendship based on mutual respect and an entrepreneurial spirit. George Sortino, son of Michele, and Lynn Middleswarth, husband to Alexander Scagnetti’s granddaughter, have created a strong bond over the years and both share a love of cooking. Their family ristorante, Sortino's Little Italy, has become a local favorite serving up dishes using recipes passed down from generation to generation. Both George and his brother James have first-hand experience using brick ovens in their homes. They felt the community also needed a restaurant which offered the unique flavor and texture this cooking technique brings to food. The Middleswarth family accepted the challenge and, reminiscent of old Italy, The Brick Oven Bistro was born. With a combination of traditional northern Italian and Sicilian taste, George and Lynn created a menu of appetizers, gourmet pizzas and delectable sandwiches which are fired in our brick oven. Youngest son, Shane, transformed the old Howard Johnson’s into a cozy, Italian eatery, while his older brothers, Benjamin and Geoffrey, see to the daily operations. It truly is a family affair. Come join our families, from Italy to the USA…we welcome you not only as patrons, but as friends.

Due to a water heater failure and the fact that we can’t get it replaced until Monday, we are forced to close for the we...
09/18/2026

Due to a water heater failure and the fact that we can’t get it replaced until Monday, we are forced to close for the weekend. We can’t operate safely without hot water and safety will always be our number one priority. We want nothing more than to serve you fresh, delicious food and we apologize for any inconvenience this may cause for our customers. We will resume our regular hours next week. Thank you for understanding. ☝️🔥🍕🥲😔

09/16/2026
We just got in a BA Dubai Chocolate Stout! Sounds tasty! Stop in and try one! 🍫
09/11/2026

We just got in a BA Dubai Chocolate Stout! Sounds tasty! Stop in and try one! 🍫

PASTA POMODORO!!! 🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅Tomatoes are tasting so good right now, so we made a fresh pasta sauce with some amazing cher...
09/11/2026

PASTA POMODORO!!! 🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅

Tomatoes are tasting so good right now, so we made a fresh pasta sauce with some amazing cherry tomatoes! We have a limited amount of sauce, so get it while we got it!!! We are also still offering our Caprese Pizza featuring heirloom grape tomatoes this weekend while they last. ☝️🔥🍕🍅

CAPRESE PIZZA AND WATERMELON MOJITOS!!!Caprese Pizza is back! The base is extra virgin olive oil. The heirloom grape tom...
09/05/2026

CAPRESE PIZZA AND WATERMELON MOJITOS!!!

Caprese Pizza is back! The base is extra virgin olive oil. The heirloom grape tomatoes are the star of the show. It’s also topped with fresh basil, three cheese blend, ricotta, shredded parmesan, fresh mozzarella, balsamic reduction, and lemon zest.

Also available for a limited time is our fresh watermelon mojito! The purée is made from fresh watermelon. We also have a watermelon margarita available! For those who don’t drink alcohol, we have a super tasty watermelon/coconut/lime mocktail!

It’s hot out there. We think these offerings will help you keep cool. Get it while we got it! ☝️🔥🍕🍅🍉

We were able to acquire some really amazing locally grown grape tomatoes! STAY TUNED for what we are going to do with th...
09/02/2026

We were able to acquire some really amazing locally grown grape tomatoes! STAY TUNED for what we are going to do with them! ☝️🔥🍕🍅

🔥🍕NEW PIZZA ALERT🍕🔥Meet Lexi! She is a hospitality wiz with a quick wit and a knack for knowing just what our customers ...
08/22/2026

🔥🍕NEW PIZZA ALERT🍕🔥
Meet Lexi! She is a hospitality wiz with a quick wit and a knack for knowing just what our customers need. She does a little bit of everything around here and has become an integral part of our team! She’s holding our new feature the Tri-Tip Philly Cheesesteak Pizza! The base is our house made Alfredo. It’s topped with some amazing thin sliced Prime Tri-Tip Steak, caramelized onion, roasted red pepper, green pepper, fresh jalapeños, our three cheese house blend, and a horseradish sauce drizzle when it comes out of the oven! It’s so good! Stop by and say hi to Lexi and get one of these delicious pizzas! ☝️🔥🍕🥩🧅🫑🌶️

It never gets old hearing people say that we served them the best pizza they have ever had! We want everyone to have an ...
08/14/2026

It never gets old hearing people say that we served them the best pizza they have ever had! We want everyone to have an amazing experience when they dine with us! We really appreciate all of you! Thank you 💚☝️🔥🍕!!!

FLAVOR ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED!!!This is a brand new pizza has minimal ingredients but so much flavor. The base is extra vi...
08/07/2026

FLAVOR ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED!!!
This is a brand new pizza has minimal ingredients but so much flavor. The base is extra virgin olive oil. It’s topped with organic broccolini, sliced sweet Italian sausage, our three cheese house blend, and crushed red pepper. When it comes out we top it with a house made garlic aioli. Delicious!!! Get it while we got it! ☝️🔥🍕🥦🧄

Bistro Burger Pizza is back!!! Get it while we got it!!! ☝️🔥🍕🍔
08/01/2026

Bistro Burger Pizza is back!!! Get it while we got it!!! ☝️🔥🍕🍔

Address

1012 Cleveland Road
Sandusky, OH
44870

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 9pm
Thursday 4pm - 9pm
Friday 12pm - 10pm
Saturday 12pm - 10pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Brick Oven Bistro posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Brick Oven Bistro:

Shortcuts

Share

Category