The Back 40 A1A

09/05/2026

Calling all peanut butter lovers… this one’s for you!

Rich, creamy peanut butter cheesecake baked over a buttery Nutter Butter cookie crust, then finished with a smooth layer of peanut butter topping, a swirl of peanut butter buttercream, and of course, a Nutter Butter cookie on top.

Sweet. Salty. Creamy. Peanut buttery in all the right ways.

Come grab a slice before they’re gone — because resisting this one is Nutterly impossible to pass by and it’s only available here at The Back 40 A1A!!

09/03/2026

New special!! We took a little New York deli tradition and gave it a Back 40 A1A twist!

The Cold Datil Pastrami starts with a full 6 oz. of thinly sliced deli-style pastrami, stacked with Swiss cheese, cool & crunchy Island Slaw, slivered red onions, and a generous spread of our housemade Datil Mustard — all piled high on marble rye.

It’s classic deli meets Minorcan flavor.
New York meets St. Augustine. 🗽🌴

Cold. Stacked. Tangy. A little spicy. And definitely not your average pastrami sandwich.

Only at The Back 40 A1A — Where The Neighborhood Begins.

09/02/2026

STA Trivia tonight at Back 40 A1A at 6:30!

Free answer: Montreal Expos.

09/01/2026

Just in time for Date Night!!

08/29/2026

08/26/2026

STA Trivia tonight at Back 40 A1A at 6:30!

Free answer: lethologica.

08/24/2026

Summer flavor you’ll only find at The Back 40 A1A!!

08/24/2026

🚨 BE ON THE LOOKOUT! 🚨

A Florida Man has been spotted hiding out at Back 40 A1A… and reports indicate he is ARMED & DELICIOUS. 😂

The Florida Man Beef Melt is wanted in connection with coffee & herb-crusted roast beef, Applewood bacon, sharp cheddar, slivered red onion, and Datil horseradish sauce — all pressed hot on a toasted hoagie. 🤤🔥

Authorities advise DO NOT attempt to resist.

Come apprehend one while you can.

📍 Last known whereabouts: The Back 40 A1A.

Wanted for crimes against hunger. 🚔🥪

08/21/2026

Start your weekend off with a full, happy belly!!