Sweet Siblings

06/12/2026

Thanks to the Put-in-Bay Chamber of Commerce & Tourism Bureau for the Foodie Friday feature! Known for our sweets, but don't sleep on lunch. 😎

Our Lunchbox Specials are available daily from 11 AM–3 PM and are perfect for island employees and visitors looking for a quick, fresh meal.
Sandwiches and salads starting at just $11.99.

Order online, skip the wait, and grab lunch on your schedule. Made with Ryan's homemade breads, focaccia, and spreads. https://order.toasttab.com/online/sweet-siblings-258-toledo-ave

📍258 Toledo Ave
🕚 Open Daily 11 AM–9 PM

Grab lunch. Stay for dessert.

Foodie Friday: Sweet Siblings 🍦🍪

Sweet Siblings is the perfect stop when you’re craving something sweet on Put-in-Bay! Featuring ice cream, cookies, cupcakes, brownies, sundaes, and more, this family-owned shop has plenty of treats to help you cool off and enjoy your island getaway. Whether you’re grabbing a scoop after dinner or treating yourself during a day of exploring, Sweet Siblings has something for everyone.

📍 Stop by 258 Toledo Ave. and see what’s on the menu!

What’s your favorite dessert order?

06/12/2026

🍦 Sweet Siblings is proud to be part of the Shores & Islands Ohio Sweet Treats Trail!

If you're exploring Put-in-Bay this summer, stop by for homemade ice cream, fresh baked cookies, strawberry shortcake, and other sweet treats made right here on the island.

📍258 Toledo Ave
Open Daily 11 AM–9 PM

Discover the Shores & Islands Ohio Sweet Treats Trail! Indulge in local sweets, visit top dessert spots, and earn rewards on this tasty adventure.

06/11/2026

Fresh Ohio strawberries showed up this week, so naturally we turned them into Homemade Strawberry Shortcake. 🍓

Stop in for lunch, a scoop of ice cream, or dessert and give it a try.

📍258 Toledo Ave
Open Daily 11 AM–9 PM

06/08/2026

🌈 Happy Pride Day, Put-in-Bay! 🌈

Whether you're spending the day enjoying Pride events around the island or just soaking up a beautiful June day, we hope you'll stop by Sweet Siblings for lunch, a sweet treat, or a scoop of ice cream.

And if you're making plans for tomorrow, our friends at Frosty Bar still have tables available for their Drag Brunch on Tuesday featuring great food, entertainment, and lots of fun.

Reserve your table here:
https://tables.toasttab.com/restaurants/7b26e3d6-37d2-4996-a9ed-628236fb350b/reserve?partySize=4&dateTime=2026-06-09T11:00:00.000-04:00

Have a safe, fun, and colorful Pride celebration! 🌈

06/07/2026

Looking for a place to land this afternoon?

Stop by Sweet Siblings for lunch, ice cream, cookies, and a little shopping while you're enjoying your Sunday on the island. Make it a Sunday Funday!

📍258 Toledo Ave, Put-in-Bay
🕚 Open today until 9 PM

06/05/2026

🎨 Shop Local Today!

The Put-in-Bay Island Artists are set up next to Sweet Siblings today from 11 AM–5 PM featuring handcrafted jewelry, artwork, candles, and one-of-a-kind island creations.

While you're here, stop into Sweet Siblings for one of Ryan's homemade focaccia sandwiches, a fresh baked cookie, or a scoop of ice cream.

📍258 Toledo Ave
Open 11 AM–9 PM

06/04/2026

Strawberry milkshakes. Mom Made S'mores Cookies. Cookies & Cream Cookies.

A few of our favorite sweet treats are waiting for you at Sweet Siblings.

Open daily from 11AM–9PM at 258 Toledo Ave. Enjoy your treats on the patio while the kids play, and don't forget - dogs are always welcome, too.

See you soon!
https://sweetsiblingspib.com

06/02/2026

Lunch just got easier. 🥪🥗

Sweet Siblings Lunchbox Specials are available daily from 11AM–3PM for just $11.99. Choose from a variety of fresh sandwiches and salads and skip the lunchtime wait!

Available for online pickup orders only.

Order online: sweetsiblingspib.com

06/02/2026

☀️ Sweet treats, friends, and a little time to play.

These boys know how to spend a summer afternoon! Stop by Sweet Siblings for a sweet treat, grab a seat on the patio, and let the kids enjoy the playground.

Whether you're craving a cookie, an ice cream sandwich, or just a reason to slow down and enjoy the day, we've got you covered.

📍 258 Toledo Ave, Put-in-Bay

06/28/2025

Make your next stop, your sweetest stop. Sweet Siblings Put-in-Bay 🍨
🍨