Sweet Siblings

Sweet Siblings Sweet Siblings is an Put-in-Bay Island Dessert Destination opening in May of 2024!

08/07/2026

This isn’t AI, our patio has to be the prettiest place to enjoy a sweet or savory! Treat yourself ♥️

07/30/2026

Lunch is just a few clicks away! 🍽️ Skip the wait and order online at SweetSiblingsPIB.com.

🥪 Lunchbox Specials • 11 AM–3 PM • $11.99
⏰ Open Daily • 11 AM–10 PM
📍 258 Toledo Ave • Put-in-Bay

07/25/2026

Good food makes every island adventure better. ❤️ Stop in for fresh sandwiches on our house-baked bread, homemade treats, and your favorite ice cream.

* 258 Toledo Ave.
* Open Daily • 11 AM–10 PM
* SweetSiblingsPIB.com

07/23/2026

Come on in and treat yourself! 🥕🍰 Our homemade carrot cake is fresh, delicious, and one of our customer favorites. Stop by and grab a slice before it's gone! Open 11am-10pm

07/22/2026

We have our famous ice cream sandwiches available for you daily!!!

Happy National Ice Cream Day! 🍦❤️There's no better excuse to treat yourself! Stop by for your favorite scoop, sundae, sh...
07/19/2026

Happy National Ice Cream Day! 🍦❤️

There's no better excuse to treat yourself! Stop by for your favorite scoop, sundae, shake, or frozen treat and celebrate with us.

📍258 Toledo Ave.
🕙 Open Daily until 10 PM

Homemade just tastes better. ❤️Some of the best treats at Sweet Siblings start with family. Ryan & Kim's mom, June Stoib...
07/18/2026

Homemade just tastes better. ❤️

Some of the best treats at Sweet Siblings start with family. Ryan & Kim's mom, June Stoiber, baked these homemade chocolate chip cookies for the Put-In-Bay Community Swim Sail Junior Bay Team Dinner, and they disappeared fast. 🍪

June's baking has always been part of the Sweet Siblings story, and that homemade tradition continues every day in our kitchen.

📍258 Toledo Ave
🕚 Open Daily • 11 AM–10 PM

07/16/2026

Smoke from the Canadian wildfires has created poor air quality across Put-in-Bay today.

Residents and visitors are encouraged to limit time outdoors and stay indoors whenever possible.

If you need a place to get out of the smoke, our doors are open. Whether you're stopping by Sweet Siblings, Frosty Bar, or The Carriage House, we're here to welcome you indoors.

Stay Safe. 💙 The Stoiber Family

07/03/2026

POV: You just found the best way to cool off on Put-in-Bay🍦☀️

Address

258 Toledo Avenue
Put-In-Bay, OH
43456

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sweet Siblings posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category