Wise Guys Hoagies

Wise Guys Hoagies A homage to South Jersey hoagie shops. Steaks, Cutlets, Cold Cuts, and more!

Fourth of July is around the bend! 🎆Wise Guys will be closing at 4, but this gives everyone plenty of time to snag some ...
07/02/2026

Fourth of July is around the bend! 🎆
Wise Guys will be closing at 4, but this gives everyone plenty of time to snag some hoagies, potato salad and pasta salad for the parade or to take and enjoy while watching the fireworks! (Make it easy and order ahead with our online ordering!) Bonus, you can snag a drink to go for the social district at The Front! We’re so excited for our first fourth as Wise Guys.

Mitchell st. is open now!!! Come on in or order online! Perfect with a beer at our front bar or take it to go and enjoy ...
06/12/2026

Mitchell st. is open now!!! Come on in or order online! Perfect with a beer at our front bar or take it to go and enjoy time in nature, on the boat, or golfing!

Welcoming the Johnny Roast Beef v2.0House wagyu roast beef, house made vinegar peppers, fontina cheese, shaved onions, a...
05/31/2026

Welcoming the Johnny Roast Beef v2.0
House wagyu roast beef, house made vinegar peppers, fontina cheese, shaved onions, arugula and house made horseradish dijonaise.

Newest addition. Chicken cheesesteaks, seasoned with our house seasoning! Here we are featuring the #21 Billy batts sub...
05/26/2026

Newest addition. Chicken cheesesteaks, seasoned with our house seasoning! Here we are featuring the #21 Billy batts sub chicken, add sun-dried tomato’s. Absolutely delicious. We also offer the chicken cheesesteak as its own sandwhich! #23 Ralph Cifaretto; mayonnaise, chicken, fried onions, wise guys “wiz”, and topped with banana peppers. Come check it out.

Did you know we deliver??? Check out our online menu (link in bio) to see if you fall within DoorDash’s delivery radius!...
02/12/2026

Did you know we deliver??? Check out our online menu (link in bio) to see if you fall within DoorDash’s delivery radius! Chef is holding #12, the Silvio Dante! Our take on a chicken parm, it’s got our signature housemade chicken cutlets, vodka sauce, and melted mozzarella and provolone. To quote the man himself, “where did they get this bread, the bread museum?”

02/07/2026

#1. Carmine Lupertazzi
Italian cold cut, provolone, lettuce, onion, mayonnaise and hot pepper relish.

We are now accepting carryout orders for Super Bowl Sunday. Log onto our website at the link in our bio to place yours! ...
02/07/2026

We are now accepting carryout orders for Super Bowl Sunday. Log onto our website at the link in our bio to place yours! This is our #21 Billy Batts. 7oz shaved ribeye steak, fried onions, sharp provolone, Japanese mayo, hot cherry peppers, shredded lettuce, and hoagie dressing.
Now go get your shine box Tommy!

You can also follow on Instagram to see more.
02/07/2026

You can also follow on Instagram to see more.

Address

422 East Mitchell Street
Petoskey, MI
49770

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Wise Guys Hoagies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category