Mighty Fine Pizza

Mighty Fine Pizza Mighty Fine Pizza in Downtown Petoskey is a locally owned pizzeria that cuts no corners and uses only the finest, freshest ingredients available.

We offer pizza, burgers, wings, and more. Pick-up and delivery are available. Mighty Fine Pizza is your cherished local pizzeria, dishing up award-winning pizzas crafted with love from scratch. Our homemade dough, sauce, and fresh, hand-chopped ingredients are what sets us apart from others; there is nothing francised about Mighty Fine Pizza. Nestled in the heart of Downtown Petoskey, we spare no

effort in ensuring that every taste and every quality check meets the highest standards. Our menu contains mouthwatering pizza options, salads, tempting appetizers, grinders, and sweet desserts. At Mighty Fine Pizza, there's something for everyone to enjoy.

What is this tasty creation? A Pizzarrito! Our homemade dough-wrapped burrito-style, stuffed with all your favorite topp...
06/04/2026

What is this tasty creation?

A Pizzarrito! Our homemade dough-wrapped burrito-style, stuffed with all your favorite toppings. It’s a must-try. 🌯🍕

📲 Call (231) 347-3255 and get your hands on this filling bad boy.

Who agrees that everything is better with butter?! That includes our breadsticks and seasoned crust. We paint that butte...
06/02/2026

Who agrees that everything is better with butter?!

That includes our breadsticks and seasoned crust. We paint that butter on just to ensure we don't miss a spot!

🔗Visit mightyfinepizza.com/menu/ to view our full menu, including our flavored pizza crust and breadsticks. You don't want one without the other.

Get your summer BBQ fix with a Pizza twist! 🍕 Try our June Special, the Up North BBQ Pizza, loaded with BBQ sauce, mozza...
06/01/2026

Get your summer BBQ fix with a Pizza twist! 🍕

Try our June Special, the Up North BBQ Pizza, loaded with BBQ sauce, mozzarella cheese, chicken, roasted corn, red onions, and crispy bacon. No grilling needed, pick up the phone and savor the flavors of summer. Small: $20 Medium: $22 Large: $26

Call (231) 347-3255 to satisfy your summer BBQ cravings!

Dinner getting expensive? Not at Mighty Fine 🍕Fun fact: the most expensive pizza in the world costs $12,000. Meanwhile, ...
05/31/2026

Dinner getting expensive? Not at Mighty Fine 🍕

Fun fact: the most expensive pizza in the world costs $12,000. Meanwhile, over here, you can feed your cravings without needing a second mortgage 😅

Today is your last chance to grab our Mighty May Deal: a medium 3-topping pizza and a small salad for just $25.

Because $25 tastes way better than $12,000. 📲 Call (231) 347-3255

Someone is spicing up their weekend. Are you?Whether you like spicy, sweet, or salty, make it a Mighty Fine weekend. 📲Ca...
05/29/2026

Someone is spicing up their weekend. Are you?

Whether you like spicy, sweet, or salty, make it a Mighty Fine weekend.

📲Call (231) 347-3255 to order.

How does this simple receipt save you money? Do you throw your receipt away the minute you get it? Well, don't! Save you...
05/27/2026

How does this simple receipt save you money?

Do you throw your receipt away the minute you get it? Well, don't! Save your yellow receipts and redeem them for $1.00 each towards your next purchase.

Excludes wings and brownies. Max 20 per visit and pick up only.

Call (231) 347-3255 to order.

We apologize for any inconvenience; we are closed 5/25/26 today for summer maintenance.
05/24/2026

We apologize for any inconvenience; we are closed 5/25/26 today for summer maintenance.

Do you like fruit on your salad? If so, this is calling your name! Our seasonal spinach and strawberry salad, topped wit...
05/24/2026

Do you like fruit on your salad? If so, this is calling your name!

Our seasonal spinach and strawberry salad, topped with candied pecans, feta, red onion, and homemade poppy seed balsamic dressing, is back by popular demand for a limited time. Order while you can!

Small: $12.00 Large: $16.00

Call (231) 347-3255 and enjoy every bite. Open 3:00 pm-8:00 pm

Sometimes change is good, especially when it looks like this. Have you tried our white sauce pizza? Try it and tell us w...
05/22/2026

Sometimes change is good, especially when it looks like this.

Have you tried our white sauce pizza? Try it and tell us what you think.

🔗Visit mightyfinepizza.com/menu/ to view our menu and check out all our tasty options.

Only two weeks left to eat lunch or dinner for only $25.00!Don't miss our Mighty May deal: a medium three-topping pizza ...
05/21/2026

Only two weeks left to eat lunch or dinner for only $25.00!

Don't miss our Mighty May deal: a medium three-topping pizza with a small salad for only $25.00.

Call (231) 347-3255 to take advantage of this deal.

Address

222 E. Mitchell St. On The First Block Of Petoskey’s Mitchell Street Gaslight District
Petoskey, MI
49770

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 3pm - 10pm
Sunday 3pm - 9pm

Telephone

+12313473255

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mighty Fine Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mighty Fine Pizza:

Shortcuts

Share

Category