The Bagel Mill Petaluma

Call Directions Website Contact the business

The Bagel Mill Petaluma Organic, sourdough bagels made with freshly milled flour. Handmade in Petaluma, CA.

Cranberry Almond Chicken Salad Sandwich 🍂🥯Sweet cranberries, crunchy almonds, and chicken tossed with honey, mustard, ce...
10/14/2026

Cranberry Almond Chicken Salad Sandwich 🍂🥯

Sweet cranberries, crunchy almonds, and chicken tossed with honey, mustard, celery, and red onion. A delicious, protein-packed lunch with a little fall flavor in every bite!

For when you’re craving fall vibes, but the forecast says 80s all week. 🍎🍂Our Apple C***r Lemonade with cold foam is ref...
10/13/2026

For when you’re craving fall vibes, but the forecast says 80s all week. 🍎🍂

Our Apple C***r Lemonade with cold foam is refreshing and creamy, with cozy spices and a hint of apple. A little taste of fall, served cold.

***rLemonade

Delicata Squash, Caramelized Onion & Herb Cream Cheese 🌿🍂Our seasonal cream cheese brings together organic roasted delic...
10/09/2026

Delicata Squash, Caramelized Onion & Herb Cream Cheese 🌿🍂

Our seasonal cream cheese brings together organic roasted delicata squash, sweet caramelized onions, and fresh thyme and rosemary for a savory spread full of cozy fall flavor.

Pair it with our freshly baked sourdough bagels for a delicious autumn breakfast or lunch at The Bagel Mill in Petaluma. 🥯

Vibing with her bagel on a Wednesday ✨I’m grateful to make food that my girls enjoy—and that I feel good about feeding t...
10/07/2026

Vibing with her bagel on a Wednesday ✨

I’m grateful to make food that my girls enjoy—and that I feel good about feeding them seven days a week 🥯

Our bagels are made with long-fermented sourdough, 30% freshly milled whole grains, and organic ingredients, all by hand by our talented bakers.

Now, if I could just get them to try a flavor other than cinnamon raisin… 😂

Fall Latte Flight 🍂☕️Find your new fall favorite! Try all four seasonal flavors with a flight of mini lattes, each made ...
10/06/2026

Fall Latte Flight 🍂☕️

Find your new fall favorite! Try all four seasonal flavors with a flight of mini lattes, each made with a single shot of Land and Water Coffee espresso.

🎃 Pumpkin Spice — Made with real, roasted sugar pie pumpkins.

🍎 Apple Butter — Made with Sebastopol heirloom apples.

🍪 Cashew Cookie Butter — Vegan & gluten-free, with the cozy flavor of a warm spice cookie.

🍁 Salted Maple — Made with real maple syrup and French grey sea salt.

Available in store only! Which one will be your favorite? 🤎

Today only! 🌭 Everything bagel dogs are back! We haven’t made this flavor in ages, and it’s just as good as we remembere...
10/03/2026

Today only! 🌭 Everything bagel dogs are back! We haven’t made this flavor in ages, and it’s just as good as we remembered. Come grab one while they last!

Pumpkin spice season has landed at The Bagel Mill! 🎃🍂Cozy up with a pumpkin spice latte, chai or white mocha ☕️ We make ...
10/01/2026

Pumpkin spice season has landed at The Bagel Mill! 🎃🍂

Cozy up with a pumpkin spice latte, chai or white mocha ☕️ We make ours with real pumpkin that we roast and purée ourselves—and you can taste the difference!

Bring those fall flavors to your bagel, too, with our pumpkin spice cream cheese 🥯✨ Rich, creamy and reminiscent of decadent pumpkin cheesecake. Try it on your favorite bagel—we’re partial to sesame or cinnamon raisin!

Who runs The Bagel Mill? 🥯 Meet the people behind your favorite Petaluma bagels!It takes a whole team to keep our local ...
09/29/2026

Who runs The Bagel Mill? 🥯 Meet the people behind your favorite Petaluma bagels!

It takes a whole team to keep our local bakery slinging bagels seven days a week. Here’s the leadership crew that holds it all together:

👋 Glenda — Founder & Owner
That’s me! I handle the behind-the-scenes work: marketing, HR, business development and this social media account—for better or worse! You’ll still catch me making bagels or pulling espresso shots. I love jumping in alongside our awesome team.

I grew up in Sebastopol and moved to New York at 18 to attend NYU. That’s where my love of real, boiled bagels began! After graduation and a few years at a tech startup, I followed my love of baking into bakeries and restaurant pastry kitchens. Eventually, I moved to San Francisco, where I met my husband…

☕ Michael — General Manager
Michael runs our day-to-day operations and leads our barista team. He brings more than 20 years of hospitality experience as a server and sommelier, plus time in winemaking as a cellar supervisor.

Originally from San Diego and a UCSD grad, he loves good food, guitar, heavy metal and his record collection. He’s also dad to our two beautiful girls (I’m a little biased 😍), two dogs and a cat.

👨‍🍳 Jake — Kitchen Manager
Jake has been with us for three years and recently stepped into the Kitchen Manager role, overseeing our bakers and line cooks.

He’s the creative mind behind so many favorite specials: elote cream cheese, Valentine’s Day strawberry shortcake, the bagel French dip (my personal favorite!), the bagel banh mi, pesto cream cheese and more.

Originally from Chester, CA, Jake spent many years in Nevada, where he raised his three sons. Outside the kitchen, he’s a pool pro who plays in several local leagues 🎱

We’re proud of the whole crew that makes The Bagel Mill part of your Petaluma breakfast and lunch routine. Next time you’re in for bagels, a bagel sandwich or coffee, say hello! 💛

Which of Jake’s specials is your all-time favorite? 👇

Mitch and his seitan 🌿We’ve been making seitan in-house for the past year, and we’ve been blown away by how popular it’s...
09/22/2026

Mitch and his seitan 🌿

We’ve been making seitan in-house for the past year, and we’ve been blown away by how popular it’s become! We make it with organic vital wheat gluten, tofu, nutritional yeast, and plenty of umami-rich seasonings.

Huge kudos to Mitch for developing the recipe and teaching the rest of the team how to make it 🧑‍🍳

Have you tried Mitch’s Vegan Seitan Sandwich yet? Thanks to you, it’s now on the permanent menu ☺️

Address

212 Western Avenue
Petaluma, CA
94952

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 2pm
Tuesday 7am - 2pm
Wednesday 7am - 2pm
Thursday 7am - 2pm
Friday 7am - 2pm
Saturday 7am - 2pm
Sunday 7am - 2pm

Telephone

+17079818010

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Bagel Mill Petaluma posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Bagel Mill Petaluma:

Shortcuts

Share