The wild icing co

The wild icing co Cozy, small-batch cookies made by hand
🤍
Naturally colored with real ingredients. No artificial dyes. Warm, nostalgic, and thoughtfully made. Naturally sweet.

Family-assisted, created at a gentle pace. Wildly creative. The Wild Icing Co. is a cozy, family-assisted cookie studio built around patience, creativity, and real ingredients. What started as a gentle creative outlet during a season of healing grew into a small batch project rooted in care, nostalgia, and intentional pace. Every cookie is naturally colored using real ingredients like fruits, vege

tables, cocoa, spirulina, and caramel powders; never artificial dyes. That’s why the colors are softer and more organic, and why each batch feels a little different. Nothing here is rushed or mass produced. focuses on small batches, custom sets, seasonal treats, and simple family projects designed to feel homemade, just slightly elevated. The process is slower by design, supported by family, and centered on making something thoughtful rather than fast. This is a space for warm details, creative ideas, and sweet moments. Made with care, support, and a whole lot of heart.

The teddy bear, Santa foot prints, and highland cow were the buttercream cookies from the gold cookie tray. *the request...
07/07/2026

The teddy bear, Santa foot prints, and highland cow were the buttercream cookies from the gold cookie tray.

*the request for gold balls could not be found dye free and was requested to add onto the natural dyed cookie, frosting, other sprinkles for the heart cookie.

Did you know because they didn’t have red stars with natural dye alone? we hand separated out each red star from a Chris...
07/07/2026

Did you know because they didn’t have red stars with natural dye alone? we hand separated out each red star from a Christmas star mix to make these festive cookies.

The Story Behind the Specks ✨When I was little, my parents used to make homemade ice cream. For a long time, I didn't fu...
07/07/2026

The Story Behind the Specks ✨
When I was little, my parents used to make homemade ice cream.

For a long time, I didn't fully understand what gave it that incredible, deep flavor. Until the day my mom decided to show us.

She bought a real vanilla bean pod, brought us into the kitchen, and split it open right in front of us so we could smell the raw, intense aroma.

That day, she taught us a lesson I never forgot:
that nature’s most incredible flavors come from the rawest sources.

We learned that just like raw cacao, a taste of raw vanilla might not be the tastiest on its own, but when it is woven into a dessert, it becomes absolute magic.

She taught us how to spot the real thing, You know it’s real vanilla by the specks.
Fast forward to today, and that exact childhood fascination is the heartbeat of The Wild Icing co.
Take a look at the picture below...

🍪 Our Promise to You:
Every single batch is made 100% from scratch in our kitchen using premium King Arthur flour, organic unbleached sugar, pure butter, refined coconut oil, and a touch of molasses.

Our cookies are frosted with either a bleach free royal icing or a rich, bakery-safe buttercream. Most importantly? We color our icings exclusively using hand-formulated, plant-based natural powders.

❌ No bleached flours.
❌ No aluminum or titanium dioxide.
❌ No synthetic artificial dyes.

We use real, honest, luxury ingredients. Those beautiful little dark specks you see in our icing are real vanilla bean caviar.

🎨Our Menu & Pricing:
Because we treat every cookie like a tiny, edible canvas and use only top-tier organic ingredients, our pricing reflects the artisan care poured into every batch. We do offer vegan and gluten free options if requested, price change may apply.

🎁 Looking for a Single Treat or Party Favor?
We offer our large, 4-inch custom cookies individually heat-sealed in packaging with a clear window. Perfect for individual gifting, party favors, or a personal luxury treat!

Single Royal Icing Cookie: $7.00 each

Single Bag-Safe Buttercream Cookie: $6.50 each

👑 The Royal Icing Collection (Best for hyper-sharp details, fine-line illustrations, and corporate gifting)
Standard Holiday/Seasonal Batches: $65.00 – $75.00 per batch (13 cookies)

Custom & Corporate Logo Batches: $95.00 – $115.00+ per batch (13 cookies)

🧈 The Bag-Safe Buttercream Collection (A nostalgic, melt-in-your-mouth soft cookie with a beautifully crusted, packable buttercream)
Standard Holiday/Seasonal Batches: $60.00 – $65.00 per batch (14 cookies)

🛍️ The "Bag of..." Collection
Looking for the perfect bite-sized gift or market treat? Our themed mini-cookie window bags (like our upcoming Autumn and Holiday collections!) feature 10–12 beautifully detailed mini cookies tumbled into rustic packaging.

Per Bag: $8.00 – $10.00

👇 Drop a comment below: Are you a team Royal Icing fan, or a die-hard Buttercream lover?

-Memorial Day vegan & regular cookies-•Can you tell which ones are vegan and which ones aren’t? •Can you spot the real v...
05/30/2026

-Memorial Day vegan & regular cookies-

•Can you tell which ones are vegan and which ones aren’t?

•Can you spot the real vanilla bean?

05/30/2026

I took on a new adventure and made vegan royal icing and sugar cookies this past week on top of my normal type. I think they turned out pretty good, and tasty! Again it’s all natural dyes, and bleach free, plus real vanilla bean.

04/26/2026

Natural dyes, royal icing sugar cookies and buttercream sugar cookies

Address

Pataskala, OH
43062

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The wild icing co posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The wild icing co:

Share

Category