Benny's Ice Cream

Benny's Ice Cream Rated Best Best Ice Cream In Old Forge

Here at Benny's we serve the finest Custard, meaning that there is egg as well as a greater milk-fat percentage which allows for the creamiest and richest flavor ice cream. As a local business we see great value in buying locally, therefore, all the ice cream we serve you is from New York State Dairies and all other ingredients are from distributors in the Central New York region.

UPDATE.... The owner has been FOUND. Pick up arrangements are being made. Thank you all for helping to spread the word. ...
08/18/2025

UPDATE.... The owner has been FOUND. Pick up arrangements are being made. Thank you all for helping to spread the word.

PLEASE HELP RETURN THIS ENVELOPE!!!! Envelope of cash was found last night here at Benny's. There is a note on one side mentioning a person owing money. Identify the name and dollar amount of that debt to prove ownership. If the owner is not found by the end of September the money will be donated to our local food pantry. PLEASE SHARE!!!!

John Gardner and his wonderful wife celebrating 58 beautiful years at their favorite ice cream joint.
08/01/2025

John Gardner and his wonderful wife celebrating 58 beautiful years at their favorite ice cream joint.

05/24/2024

We can hardly wait for those late summer nights and cones at Benny's Ice Cream!

😋 Come enjoy the ☀️ sunshine with a delicious cone! 🍦

WE ARE OPEN! 🍦 Come and get a sweet treat before someone eats it all up!
05/17/2024

WE ARE OPEN! 🍦
Come and get a sweet treat before someone eats it all up!

06/01/2023

We are OPEN tonight 6/1 @ 5pm!
Come and get a tasty, cool treat! 🍦

Benny’s Ice Cream is back folks!!!Open all weekend! Friday, Saturday, Sunday and Monday11am to 10pm
05/26/2023

Benny’s Ice Cream is back folks!!!

Open all weekend!

Friday, Saturday, Sunday and Monday
11am to 10pm

A tasty treat to go along with your weekend in the ADK🏕 Pretty fitting, you think?
08/19/2022

A tasty treat to go along with your weekend in the ADK🏕

Pretty fitting, you think?

Pretty good.....
08/14/2022

Pretty good.....

wicked tasty
08/05/2022

wicked tasty

we got another lost card here found at Nutty Putty‼️
08/04/2022

we got another lost card here found at Nutty Putty‼️

get down and grab a tasty sundae made with 100% PURE locally made maple syrup from Maple Moss Sugarworks🍁🍁🍁🍁🍁🍁!!!while s...
08/04/2022

get down and grab a tasty sundae made with
100% PURE locally made maple syrup from
Maple Moss Sugarworks
🍁🍁🍁🍁🍁🍁
!!!while supplies last!!!

‼️found in Nutty Putty‼️
08/02/2022

‼️found in Nutty Putty‼️

Address

2933 RT-28
Old Forge, NY
13420

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 10pm
Tuesday 11am - 10pm
Wednesday 11am - 10pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Telephone

+13157234937

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Benny's Ice Cream posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Benny's Ice Cream:

Shortcuts

Share

Category