Valentine’s on the Lake

Valentine’s on the Lake 5959 E Main St Olcott -rear
716-638-4104
Handmade pierogi, desserts and to go dinners available

Who doesn't love an awesome sloppy Joe? ( well, to be fair, I'm sure some people don't like sloppy Joe's.) Friday ( and ...
09/22/2026

Who doesn't love an awesome sloppy Joe? ( well, to be fair, I'm sure some people don't like sloppy Joe's.) Friday ( and the weekend, if there are any left)  we will have these incredible sloppy Joe grilled cheese on croissant bread. The sloppy Joe is made from scratch, it's chipotle and brown sugar and the bread is incredible. It'll be served with hand cut fries . Check back in for our Other Friday evening and weekend specials.

09/20/2026

With the Bill's not playing today, who is everyone watching on the NFL?

I have never made such a small pot of sauce ... kept it simple , tomatoes and lots of fresh basil. Got a bit fancy for s...
09/17/2026

I have never made such a small pot of sauce ... kept it simple , tomatoes and lots of fresh basil. Got a bit fancy for some friends since we were not open . They got to sample one of Friday nights specials , chicken parm with a side of bucatini topped with fresh made "gravy"
~ Freshly pounded chicken cutlet, with melted provolone and mozzarella , accompanied by a side of bucatini pasta , garlic toast and whipped ricotta

Come see us for dinner Friday ❤️

Our newest pierogi creation , the Josh ( didnt know whether to call it the Josh or the Allen , but couldnt call it the c...
09/16/2026

Our newest pierogi creation , the Josh ( didnt know whether to call it the Josh or the Allen , but couldnt call it the combination of the 2 )
Hot , sweet and awesome~
Chicken breast , hot peppers , fresh basil, sweet tomatoes , and a few other secrets. This is a MUST try .
Had to sautee a few to try ..😋

09/15/2026
That was a nail biter ! The bills came through with the win. Our Buffalo Bills Pierogi platter was a huge hit yesterday....
09/14/2026

That was a nail biter ! The bills came through with the win. Our Buffalo Bills Pierogi platter was a huge hit yesterday. Such a huge hint that we're going to offer it again this evening for dinner.

*3 buffalo wing pierogi, 3 pepperoni pizza pierogi with carrots , celery, bleu cheese and marinara.

We will also be offering the following great specials ( check out the board❤️)

call 716-638-4104 for take out or reservations ( parties over 6 )
See you this evening in Olcott!
WAY TO GO BUFFALO🦬❤️💙

Who is ready for some football? today we're gonna have a game day pierogi platters 3 buffalo wing pierogi and 3 pepperon...
09/13/2026

Who is ready for some football?
today we're gonna have a game day pierogi platters
3 buffalo wing pierogi and 3 pepperoni pizza pierogi , with marinara , bleu cheese , celery and carrots ! Enjoy it on the patio or order one to go for halftime. Only $15 💙716-638-4104

I would love to be able to make dishes like this and have people enjoy them
09/11/2026

I would love to be able to make dishes like this and have people enjoy them

Linguine Pink Peppercorn & Rose Alfredo with Pan-Seared Shrimp

My mom always made these . I made a few today, and took One to my dad's for dinner with him. We had Josh Allen burgers f...
09/11/2026

My mom always made these . I made a few today, and took One to my dad's for dinner with him. We had Josh Allen burgers from Sloan Market , they were huge ( 17 ounces each ) I honestly cannot believe my dad finished his🤣

Address

PARKING AND ENTRANCE ARE IN THE REAR 5959 E Main Street
Olcott, NY
14126

Opening Hours

Monday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm
Sunday 2pm - 6pm

Telephone

+17166384104

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Valentine’s on the Lake posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Valentine’s on the Lake:

Shortcuts

Share

Category