10/05/2026
Let us introduce you all to The Jim Shoe, sometimes spelled Gym Shoe, this is one of Chicago's most unapologetically over the top sandwiches, and nobody has ever managed to pin down exactly where it came from, which somehow fits the sandwich itself perfectly. It's built from three separate meats, roast beef, corned beef, and Greek style gyro meat, all hard griddled together and piled onto a sub roll, then buried under lettuce, tomato, onions, cheese, giardiniera, mayo, and a tzatziki style sauce.
It's generally believed to have started somewhere on the South Side, likely born out of sandwich shops that happened to sell both Italian beef and gyros under one roof and figured out customers would be happy to get all of it at once. The name's origin is even murkier than the sandwich's birthplace. One popular, probably apocryphal story claims a very hungry late night customer told a sandwich maker to just throw everything onto the bread like it was a gym shoe, and the name stuck from there. Another theory floated by a South Side shop owner traces it instead to Pakistani immigrants from Karachi, though nobody treats either explanation as settled fact.
What is clear is that it's spread almost entirely through word of mouth and a handful of dedicated South Side spots, places like Petey's, Southtown Sub, and Stony Sub, long before it ever showed up on a menu anywhere north of downtown. It picked up real national attention once Anthony Bourdain featured it on his Chicago episode of No Reservations, introducing plenty of people outside the neighborhood to a sandwich that had already been a quiet South Side institution for years.
The Jim Shoe has started creeping into more upscale Chicago kitchens too, with chefs occasionally reinventing the components, swapping in slow cooked lamb shoulder for the gyro meat or giving the corned beef its own extended brine, while keeping the basic chaotic spirit of the original intact. For a sandwich nobody can definitively trace to one person, one shop, or even one explanation for its name, the Jim Shoe has earned its spot right alongside the Italian beef, the Chicago dog, and the Maxwell Street Polish as one of the city's genuinely homegrown culinary oddities, built entirely around the idea that more meat on one sandwich is never actually too much.
Is the coast ready for this? Let us know in the comments if we should bring this banger to the 6ix.