Grandma Penny's Pizza & Pasta

02/03/2026

🤍🤍🤍

12/31/2025

12/12/2025

Hi everyone! So many of you have been asking ever since DJ and I took over here at Long Island Pizza if we’d ever bring back our crumble sausage… and it’s officially BACK! 🎉
Come visit us at our new spot and grab your favorite slice!

You ask and you shall receive!
We now carry CRUMBLED SAUSAGE 🎉
Don’t worry — sliced sausage isn’t going anywhere!

Note when ordering:
Pizzas automatically come with sliced sausage, so just request crumbled if that’s what you want!

Have an amazing weekend, everyone! 🍕✨

08/02/2025

We open at 11 today!
Until supplies last.

We have pizza, wings, salads and Philly’s still available !!

08/01/2025

Update: We’re open until we sell out. Not sure about tomorrow (Saturday) depending if we have any food left !
Thank you everyone!!

08/01/2025

This is a tough post to write.

After facing challenges from all sides from road closures and limited access last year to another slow summer season we’ve made the difficult decision to close Grandma Penny’s.

This is actually the second time we’ve had to make this call around this time of year, and while we were able to reopen once before, the truth is that it’s just not something we can continue to sustain right now.

We considered going quietly, because this has been such a hard and emotional decision, and we never wanted to let anyone down. But we value you all too much to not be open and honest about what’s happening. You’ve been such an important part of this journey, and we wanted to share this announcement with you all.

We know many of you may have questions about the future, and the honest answer is that we’re not entirely sure what comes next. Right now, we’re focusing on taking care of ourselves and stepping back to breathe, process, and rest.

What we do know is how incredibly grateful we are for every single person who supported us whether you visited once or came in every week. Your kindness and encouragement meant more than we can ever express.

Our last day will be Saturday.

07/29/2025

Happy Tuesdayyyy!
•6 Garlic Knots & Large Cheese Pizza•
$20
3pm-9pm

07/26/2025

Happy Saturday!
10 wings & Large Cheese Pizza $30
DINE IN | TAKE OUT | DELIVERY

07/23/2025

SPECIAL 👇-Mention this post-