Jolly Rogers Pizzeria

09/24/2026

$14. Large pizzas !!
Dine in or Pick up!
Hot. Fresh. Pizza !!!
Mmmmmmmmmm
🍕❤️🍕❤️🍕❤️🍕❤️🍕

09/13/2026

Bar is opening at 3 today for the Packer game! Come cheer on the Pack with Mack💚💛🏈

09/07/2026

After a much needed rest for our staff, we’re back open and ready to serve you!

See you at 4pm for dine in, pick up, or delivery!

🍕BOGO Small pizzas when you dine in or carry out on Mondays🍕

08/07/2026

Tonight’s the night to celebrate Mackenzie!!
Hope to see you!!

08/06/2026

Hiring:
-wait staff
-bartender
-pizza cooks
-dishwashers

Stop in for an application!

07/26/2026

Mark your calendars!!
NEXT FRIDAY!!
Come celebrate Mackenzie getting old like the rest of us!! 😂😂😂

07/26/2026

THANK YOU!!
We appreciate all the love!
What an AMAZING HONOR!
THANK YOU!

The Nosh Wisconsin Pizza Champion: Jolly Roger's! 🏆🍕

THE CROWN HAS BEEN CLAIMED! ⚔️🍕 After a record-breaking month of voting and thousands of you defending your local favorites, we officially have a winner.

Congratulations to #5 Jolly Rogers Pizzeria (New London)! 🏆 In a massive upset, the New London legend took down the #2 seed to become the Nosh Wisconsin Pizza Champion.

Pizza was just the start. Nominations for the Wisconsin Fish Fry Bracket are closing soon—head to our last post to make sure your favorite spot gets a seat at the table! 🗳️🐟

07/23/2026

We need your votes!! Click on the original post & vote for us!❤️🍕

We’d LOVE to be NOSH Wisconsin’s Pizza Champion thanks to all of you!!

THIS IS FOR THE CROWN! ⚔️🍕 After 3,000+ total votes, we are down to the final two. Only one spot can be named the Nosh Wisconsin Pizza Champion.

It’s a classic battle of the Fox Valley legends!
🔥 #5 Jolly Rogers Pizzeria (New London)
vs.
🔥 #2 Stuc's Pizza (Appleton)

Drop the name of your winner in the comments! 🗳️ Who is taking the title home?

The winner will be revealed alongside the official launch of the Nosh Wisconsin website! 🌐 You’ll find the full rankings and our "must-order" guides for every spot in this bracket.

Defend your favorite and tag your pizza crew! 👇 Let’s crown a king.

07/23/2026

One more time PLEASE!!
For the sole champion!
⬇️CLICK & VOTE⬇️
Thank you!!!!’

THIS IS FOR THE CROWN! ⚔️🍕 After 3,000+ total votes, we are down to the final two. Only one spot can be named the Nosh Wisconsin Pizza Champion.

It’s a classic battle of the Fox Valley legends!
🔥 #5 Jolly Rogers Pizzeria (New London)
vs.
🔥 #2 Stuc's Pizza (Appleton)

Drop the name of your winner in the comments! 🗳️ Who is taking the title home?

The winner will be revealed alongside the official launch of the Nosh Wisconsin website! 🌐 You’ll find the full rankings and our "must-order" guides for every spot in this bracket.

Defend your favorite and tag your pizza crew! 👇 Let’s crown a king.

07/23/2026

Hey folks! We’ll be opening the kitchen at 4:30 tonight (7/23).

See you then!