Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe

Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe Penny Lane Art Gallery and Coffee Shop offers cafe style food, drinks and beautiful artwork. We are truly proud that this is our hometown.
(420)

We strive to create a relaxed, laid-back atmosphere where you can come in and take a break from the daily grind. Located in the heart of New Carlisle, Ohio, we are overwhelmed by the sense of community that has been shown to us since we opened. Come in, have a coffee or sandwich and enjoy the atmosphere. We hope to see you soon!

Spend a cozy Sunday morning with us 🩷 Our Southwest BELT is loaded with flavor and such a nice way to start your day. We...
09/20/2026

Spend a cozy Sunday morning with us 🩷 Our Southwest BELT is loaded with flavor and such a nice way to start your day. We use our homemade chipotle aioli, crispy bacon, egg, fresh lettuce and tomato, and melty pepper jack cheese on our fluffy Texas toast, then grill it to perfection! Have you tried this Penny Lane classic?

This view just never gets old 😍 Our Cinnamon Dolce is kind of a secret menu item, you can order it all year at BOTH loca...
09/19/2026

This view just never gets old 😍 Our Cinnamon Dolce is kind of a secret menu item, you can order it all year at BOTH locations! It features perfectly pulled espresso, white chocolate, cinnamon, and caramel drizzle. Simple, and perfect just the way it is!

For a very special experience you can only find at our New Carlisle location, make sure to stop by for a seasonal Flight...
09/18/2026

For a very special experience you can only find at our New Carlisle location, make sure to stop by for a seasonal Flight! ✈️ ☕️ It includes Four 9oz samples of our
✨ French Toast Latte ( a penny lane FAV 🤩)
🥜 No Bake Latte
🍌 Banana Pancake Cold Brew
🎃 Pumpkin Cookie Latte

What have you tried so far? We’re dying to know what your favorite is!!

Same delicious coffee and pastries, same smiling faces and conversation, now available at 2 locations 😇 ☕️
09/17/2026

Same delicious coffee and pastries, same smiling faces and conversation, now available at 2 locations 😇 ☕️

In a rush, but REALLY need a Pumpkin Cookie Latte and our Sriracha Bacon Avocado Toast? Did you know you can call us her...
09/16/2026

In a rush, but REALLY need a Pumpkin Cookie Latte and our Sriracha Bacon Avocado Toast? Did you know you can call us here in New Carlisle at 937-679-5304 and call your order in ahead?! 📞 We LOVE taking your call in orders and helping you be fueled and on your way!!

Swipe for the before 👀 ➡️ Same spot. A whole lot of work in between. 🤍Looking at these photos side by side is kind of un...
09/15/2026

Swipe for the before 👀 ➡️

Same spot. A whole lot of work in between. 🤍

Looking at these photos side by side is kind of unreal. What was once bare studs, concrete floors and a whole lot of imagination is now a space we get to walk into every day and call ours.

I especially want to give some love to Maria from Leo’s Laundry Co. Watching how hard she has worked to bring her vision to life alongside mine has been incredible. There were so many decisions, long days, setbacks, messes and “are we ever actually going to finish this?” moments behind what you see today.

Now we get to stand in the same spot where there were once unfinished walls, inside two businesses we poured so much of ourselves into.

I’m incredibly grateful for this building, for how far it has come, and even more grateful that I get to share this chapter with another woman who works her butt off for what she’s building.

Here’s to Leo’s Laundry Co. + Penny Lane Express, and everything still to come. 🤍

We love getting to see you at home base in New Carlisle 7 days a week, but we sure do miss you in Enon when we close on ...
09/14/2026

We love getting to see you at home base in New Carlisle 7 days a week, but we sure do miss you in Enon when we close on Sunday & Monday! Penny Lane Express is excited to see you tomorrow for coffee, breakfast, sweets, sandwiches and good vibes 😎 ☕️

Our Seasonal Flights have become quite the Penny Lane staple!! We so enjoy getting to create a variety of flavors for yo...
09/13/2026

Our Seasonal Flights have become quite the Penny Lane staple!! We so enjoy getting to create a variety of flavors for you to try, and making them with care with fresh espresso, to order, every time! ☕️ This month swing by to sample our French Toast Latte, No Bake Latte, Banana Pancake Cold Brew, and Pumpkin Cookie Latte!

Golden Milk Thai Tea 🤝 Cinnamon Roll Cookie Bold Thai tea with warm turmeric, ginger & cinnamon, brown sugar and creamy ...
09/12/2026

Golden Milk Thai Tea 🤝 Cinnamon Roll Cookie

Bold Thai tea with warm turmeric, ginger & cinnamon, brown sugar and creamy milk. Cozy, spiced & perfectly sweet. Try this beauty hot or iced!

Banana Pancake Cold Brew, Cinnamon Rolls and our Maple Mustard Pretzel Breakfast Sandwich are ALL sure to put a smile on...
09/11/2026

Banana Pancake Cold Brew, Cinnamon Rolls and our Maple Mustard Pretzel Breakfast Sandwich are ALL sure to put a smile on your face! 🤩 Find this wonderful selection at BOTH of our locations!!

Address

109 S Main Street
New Carlisle, OH
45344

Opening Hours

Monday 6:30am - 6pm
Tuesday 6:30am - 6pm
Wednesday 6:30am - 6pm
Thursday 6:30am - 6pm
Friday 6:30am - 6pm
Saturday 7:30am - 6pm
Sunday 7:30am - 6pm

Telephone

+19376795304

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category