Casey's New Buffalo

Casey's New Buffalo Kitchen Daily Open @ Noon - 10pm! Bar Open til Midnight! Last call at 1:30 A.M. on Friday and Saturday!
(1051)

We are focused on bringing you the highest quality food, sourced locally whenever possible. Casey’s is reminiscent of a traditional Chicago-style grill, with its antique tin ceiling, historic Art Deco bar and hardwood floor, but includes some decorative influences from its lakeside location. There are plenty of TV's, so you won't miss the big game and we host live entertainment every weekend. When the weather’s fine, eat and drink in Casey’s Back Yard, a delightful landscaped patio, featuring our outdoor Ice House bar (originally a building used to store ice cut from the lake in the winter). On weekends, our customers often tarry after dinner to enjoy live music with friends, old and new.

Let’s put an end to summer the right way !!
09/23/2026

Let’s put an end to summer the right way !!

09/19/2026

Casey's New Buffalo is looking for a server! This person will have open availability and experience in a full service restaurant, work well under pressure and have strong customer service skills. Please apply in person at 136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117 or send resume to: [email protected]

We are opening up for the night until 2 am EST tonight and our kitchen closes at 10 pm EST. We just wanted to take the t...
09/12/2026

We are opening up for the night until 2 am EST tonight and our kitchen closes at 10 pm EST.

We just wanted to take the time to appreciate Kilometers for Katelyn-Kiki Kelly 5K Fun Run/Walk! You guys did a fantastic job from the 5k, to the silent auction, all the way to the speech that was given towards the end. We are so proud to say that we get to be part of this ripple in our community!

Come join us today on the patio for some live music! Starts at 7 pm EST!
08/25/2026

Come join us today on the patio for some live music!

Starts at 7 pm EST!

Hello Facebook!We have a “give back” night approaching on September 3rd for Thomas Jefferson Middle School special needs...
08/24/2026

Hello Facebook!

We have a “give back” night approaching on September 3rd for Thomas Jefferson Middle School special needs teachers! Erika and Chloe are some of the teachers we will be doing this donation for, and we just have to say they work so hard for these kids as well as for our customers. So, please if you can make it Thursday to help show our appreciation for these beautiful kids and amazing staff that we have behind us.

Karaoke will start at 6 pm EST! Stop in and sing your heart out for this awesome cause!

Idk about you but we have a “little line up” for this week before the weekend hits…Jack Cunningham plays on Tuesday 7-10...
08/23/2026

Idk about you but we have a “little line up” for this week before the weekend hits…
Jack Cunningham plays on Tuesday 7-10 pm EST
&
Chad Clifford plays Wednesday 7-10 pm EST

PICTURE FOR REFERENCE

Stop by Casey’s for some laid back music on the patio. Chad Clifford starts in 10!
08/04/2026

Stop by Casey’s for some laid back music on the patio.

Chad Clifford starts in 10!

08/03/2026

Hey everybody,
Casey’s will be open by 5 PM EST for dinner and will stay open until 12 AM EST. Kitchen will close at 10PM EST. We hope to see everyone there!
We are so sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused.

Cheers 🍻

08/03/2026

Casey’s will be closed for lunch today, Monday August 3, for maintenance. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Look what Casey’s grew… 👀A new drink has sprouted from our back garden… .and it’s called the Peach-berry Bellini.What sh...
08/03/2026

Look what Casey’s grew… 👀
A new drink has sprouted from our back garden…
.and it’s called the Peach-berry Bellini.

What should we grow next?

Address

136 North Whittaker Street
New Buffalo, MI
49117

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 10pm
Tuesday 12pm - 10pm
Wednesday 12pm - 10pm
Thursday 12pm - 10pm
Friday 12pm - 10pm
Saturday 12pm - 10pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Telephone

+12694696400

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Casey's New Buffalo posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Casey's New Buffalo:

Shortcuts

Share

Category