Nancys at the Lake

09/29/2026

A huge thank you to everyone who stopped by Nancys at the Lake for their End of Season Give Back event!

We are so grateful to Nancy's and their customers for their support of New Buffalo Bison & Red Arrow Raiders Athletics and Friends Of New Buffalo Township Fire Department

Go Raiders! 🏈🚒

09/29/2026

🍕 A BIG THANK YOU TO Roma Pizza of New Buffalo!

We wrapped up an incredible season with our end-of-the-year party, and Roma’s made it unforgettable!
The pizza was incredible, the pasta was out of this world, and our crew definitely didn't go home hungry.

We love supporting local businesses that treat our team like family!

Thank you again, Roma’s! 🍕🙌

09/27/2026

It’s our last day open!
Come on down to Nancy’s.
Open 11-4

09/26/2026

Last weekend of the season!

🍦 Sweets, Treats & Game Day Eats! 🍔

Let’s pack the house for a great cause! 🏈🚒✨

Join us next Sunday at Nancys at the Lake in New Buffalo for their End of Season Giveback.

​Grab some burgers, hot dogs, & ice cream — all proceeds will be donated to the Friends Of New Buffalo Township Fire Department and the New Buffalo Bison & Red Arrow Raiders Athletics Football team (co-op team between New Buffalo and River Valley).

​📅 When: Sunday, Sept. 27th, 2026 | 11 AM - 4 PM EST

📍 Where: Nancy’s Restaurant, 142 N Whittaker St.

​Bring the family, grab a bite, and show some love for our local student-athletes and heroes! 👇

​

07/28/2026

Sandy toes, bright sunshine, and tie-dye tees are in full swing at Nancy’s at the Lake! Summer is a limited-time vibe, so let’s settle a quick beach debate:

Which lakefront combo are you grabbing at the window today?

1️⃣ Chicago Dog 🌭 + Legendary Strawberry Shake 🍓

2️⃣ Crispy Cheese Curds 🧀 + Double Scoop Waffle Cone 🍦

Drop a 1 or 2 in the comments!

Send a message to learn more

07/21/2026

Wrap up your beach day with our top-seller: Michigan Pothole! We’re talking rich chocolate ice cream loaded with thick black tar fudge and massive chunks of chocolate. 🍫

Summer won't last forever, so grab your favorite tie-dye tee and come get a scoop before the sun sets!

Summer Hours:
Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Friday & Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

07/15/2026

07/07/2026

We’ve officially extended our hours at Nancy's at the Lake!

Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM 🕒

Friday & Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM 🌙

Plus, the perfect summer night just got sweeter because we have brand-new flavors at the window! Come try the campfire-inspired S'mores or Cinnamon Churro on your next visit

05/21/2026

Summer hours are officially here, and the window is open 7 days a week! Grab your tie-dye and come see us after a perfect day at the lake.

Sunday – Thursday: 11 AM – 8 PM 🕒

Friday & Saturday: 11 AM – 9 PM 🌙

Send a message to learn more

04/30/2026

The weekend forecast is looking bright, and we’ve got the perfect way to cool down! Along with our classics, come down and try a Hawaiian Ice! 🍧

🗓️ OPEN ALL WEEKEND:
Friday – Sunday * 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM