The Pie Shell

Directions Website

The Pie Shell A sweet place to get a sweet treat! From pies, cupcakes, cheesecakes, cookies and much more!

Butterscotch Pie was our most popular meringue pie last week so we decided to do it again! We have 12 of them up for gra...
10/13/2026

Butterscotch Pie was our most popular meringue pie last week so we decided to do it again! We have 12 of them up for grabs call 419-629-2625. We will reserve one for you. 

Thinking it’s about time for another MERINGUE PIE DAY! We will be making them tomorrow, Thursday, October 8. Pick up wil...
10/07/2026

Thinking it’s about time for another MERINGUE PIE DAY! We will be making them tomorrow, Thursday, October 8. Pick up will be late afternoon. Please call 419-629-2625 to place your order for Butterscotch Pie, Coconut Cream Pie, Banana Cream Pie, or Lemon Meringue. When calling please let us know if you want meringue on top or homemade whip topping. 

Homemade bread straight out of the oven! Stop in and get yours for the weekend. We are also fully stocked with your favo...
10/02/2026

Homemade bread straight out of the oven! Stop in and get yours for the weekend. We are also fully stocked with your favorite homemade pies and other desserts! 

A few cakes from the last couple weeks!
09/26/2026

A few cakes from the last couple weeks!

It’s a great day for a cookout and homemade desserts from The Pie Shell!! Open until 3. See you soon🥧
09/26/2026

It’s a great day for a cookout and homemade desserts from The Pie Shell!! Open until 3. See you soon🥧

09/12/2026

Need buckeyes for the game tonight? Stop in, we are busy getting them ready for you!

UPDATE….reduced pies are sold!! Thank you!!We baked a little too much for Labor Day! Our loss your gain… Stop in and gra...
09/09/2026

UPDATE….reduced pies are sold!! Thank you!!

We baked a little too much for Labor Day! Our loss your gain… Stop in and grab your reduced pies today… We close at 6:30 PM 

We are open until 6:00 tonight and fully stocked with homemade desserts for Labor Day Weekend! Also, taking orders until...
09/04/2026

We are open until 6:00 tonight and fully stocked with homemade desserts for Labor Day Weekend! Also, taking orders until 11:00 tomorrow for delivery to the Russia Homecoming food tent. Call 419-629-2625 to get your name on the list for this delivery.

09/04/2026

To all my Russia friends, I have seen many of you purchasing pies for the Russia State Fair food tent. I can make it easy for you.
1- Call 419-629-2625 place your order for your pies
2- pay for them over the phone
3- I will deliver them for you! 
Please tag all of your Russia friends or share this post with them and we will fill your food tent with amazing homemade pies! 

Address

468 S Washington Street
New Bremen, OH
45869

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 6:30pm
Tuesday 7am - 6:30pm
Wednesday 7am - 6:30pm
Thursday 7am - 6:30pm
Friday 7am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Pie Shell posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share