The Pie Shell

08/26/2026

Three months ago, we welcomed a very special new member to The Pie Shell family. She started out helping with dishes, and honestly… we weren’t quite sure where her journey here would take her.

Well, today, she showed us!

She dipped nearly 200 Buckeyes for us today — and she absolutely NAILED IT!

She has worked so hard, learned new things, gained confidence, and continues to surprise us with everything she is capable of. Watching her grow over these past three months has been such a joy.

And let me tell you… those Buckeyes look pretty darn good!

She was SO excited knowing her picture was going on Facebook because she loves Facebook! So today, we’re giving her the spotlight she deserves! Please like and share this post to show Julie how much she is loved!

08/24/2026

We made a little too much last week!! Come see us this morning and treat your coworkers with a delicious pie for only $10.

08/13/2026

Today is the last day to order your Bremenfest Bundle! We will be baking tomorrow morning with delivery tomorrow afternoon. If you are too busy to stop into the store and place your order feel free to give us a call at 419-629-2625. We can take your payment over the phone and add your name to our list. 

08/11/2026

Excited to be carrying Raw and Unfiltered Honey from Dues Honey in Fort Recovery, Ohio. Choose from three sizes, quart $23, pint $13, and half pint $9

08/11/2026

Need something for the Bremenfest goody wheel. Feel free to stop into the store and purchase a Bremenfest bundle or call and make your purchase right over the phone. 

08/08/2026

Open until 3 today!! Stop in for your favorite homemade pie, cupcakes, cheesecake, scotcharoos, rice krispy treats, fresh bread, cookies and so much more!! See you soon!!!

08/07/2026

Just another great reason to stop into The Pie Shell today! This one is oh so good with all that drizzle and mini buckeyes! 

🚨 Starting TODAY... it's time to get The Whole Buckin' Kitchen! 🤤🍿

If you like your snacks a little extra, this one's for you. We took caramel popcorn and loaded it up with dark chocolate, peanut butter, white chocolate, pretzels, and mini Buckeyes... because why stop at one delicious thing? 😍

🔥 Available now only at Tin Acre Gourmet Popcorn and The Pie Shell!

We've only made a limited amount for this first launch, so grab yours before this batch disappears! 👀🍿

Now the real question is... are you ready for The Whole Buckin' Kitchen? 😉🌰

08/06/2026

UPDATE…..Turtle Pies are really selling today… I would love to hear feedback!

Introducing our NEWEST creation!! TURTLE PIE!!! You’re going to love this chocolate pie filled with pecans, layered with caramel, topped with homemade whipped topping and drizzled with caramel and chocolate and topped with chocolate caramel filled turtles.

08/05/2026

🦫🥧 Life is SWEETER with PIE! 🥧🦫

We’re feeling extra grateful for all of the wonderful people who support The Pie Shell and our little corner of New Bremen! ❤️

From pies and cheesecakes to cupcakes and all the sweet treats in between, everything is made with love right here at The Pie Shell. 🧁🍰🥧

And we’re especially proud to partner with some amazing local businesses:

❤️ Marie’s Handmade Rosaries
🍪 Cooper’s Crumbs
🍓 Aunt Anne’s House
🍿 Tin Acre Popcorn

When you support a small local business, you’re helping support a whole community of local dreams. 🥰

So stop by, say hello, grab something sweet, and support local whenever you can!

📍 The Pie Shell
468 S. Washington St.
New Bremen, OH 45869

Thank you for supporting our small business! ❤️
We’re so happy to be a part of this community! 🥧🦫