New York Pizzeria

New York Pizzeria The Baios have been blessed to share their family and their lives with the people they have served since 1982❣️ We opened on January 13, 1982. Thanks!

We have been so blessed to share our lives and families with all of you. We offer Commerce Chenango Member-to Member Discounts.

We have said it before and we’ll say it again…We live in the best corner of the world, with the most talented people any...
06/15/2026

We have said it before and we’ll say it again…

We live in the best corner of the world, with the most talented people anywhere. ❤️

If you want proof, come see Rooted in Song on June 19.

An evening filled with incredible voices, outstanding performances, and the kind of talent that makes our community shine.

Grab dinner at New York Pizzeria on your way and then enjoy a wonderful night of music and entertainment.

We can’t wait to see these stars take the stage! 🎶✨

✨ DINNER SPECIAL ✨Pasta NormaPenne pasta tossed in ricotta cheese and our house-made marinara sauce, layered with hand-b...
06/13/2026

✨ DINNER SPECIAL ✨

Pasta Norma

Penne pasta tossed in ricotta cheese and our house-made marinara sauce, layered with hand-breaded eggplant, topped with mozzarella cheese, and baked until bubbly and golden. 🍆🧀❤️

A classic Italian comfort dish, made fresh at NYP.

📞 607-847-6188
📍 New York Pizzeria | New Berlin

Family owned since 1982. ❤️

✨ FRIDAY NIGHT SPECIALS AT NYP ✨Salmon PuttanescaA perfectly grilled salmon filet topped with our homemade Puttanesca sa...
06/12/2026

✨ FRIDAY NIGHT SPECIALS AT NYP ✨

Salmon Puttanesca
A perfectly grilled salmon filet topped with our homemade Puttanesca sauce and served with a side of spaghetti tossed with asparagus, mushrooms, butter, and garlic.

And don’t forget our Friday favorite…

🐟 NYP Beer-Battered Haddock
A generous haddock filet dipped in our signature beer batter, fried golden brown, and served with seasoned fries. Crispy on the outside, flaky on the inside, and made fresh to order.

Whether you’re craving seafood, pasta, or a classic fish fry, we’ve got dinner covered tonight.

📞 607-847-6188
📍 New York Pizzeria | New Berlin

Family owned and operated since 1982. Thank you for letting us be part of your Friday nights. ❤️

🍕🐟✨

🔥 The Legendary Thursday Special 🔥Two perfect slices. One cold drink.One great price.Thursday Only:🍕 2 slices + 🥤 $5.50⏰...
06/11/2026

🔥 The Legendary Thursday Special 🔥
Two perfect slices.
One cold drink.
One great price.

Thursday Only:
🍕 2 slices + 🥤 $5.50
⏰ Until 3:30 PM

🎉🇮🇹🍕 Buon Compleanno, Rosa Elizabeth Yozzo! 🍕🇮🇹🎉The Baio family is celebrating another grandchild’s birthday today as gr...
06/08/2026

🎉🇮🇹🍕 Buon Compleanno, Rosa Elizabeth Yozzo! 🍕🇮🇹🎉

The Baio family is celebrating another grandchild’s birthday today as granddaughter #7, Rosa Elizabeth, turns 5 years old! 🎂🥳

Rosa Elizabeth was given a very special name, honoring her two grandmothers, Rosa Yozzo and Betsey Elizabeth Baio. ❤️

In true Italian fashion, the wish for Rosa today is simple: plenty of pizza, pasta, meatballs, cookies, cake, family, laughter, and lots of love around the table. 🍝🍕🎂❤️

Happy 5th Birthday, Rosa! May your day be as sweet as cannoli and as joyful as a big Italian family gathering.

🍝🔥 DINNER SPECIAL TONIGHT AT NYP 🔥🍝Mussels & Calamari Fra Diavolo served over spaghetti! 🦑🦪Tender mussels and calamari t...
06/06/2026

🍝🔥 DINNER SPECIAL TONIGHT AT NYP 🔥🍝

Mussels & Calamari Fra Diavolo served over spaghetti! 🦑🦪

Tender mussels and calamari tossed in our spicy homemade Fra Diavolo sauce and served over a bed of spaghetti. A seafood lover’s dream with just the right kick! 🌶️❤️

A warm NYP welcome to all of the dance families, Unadilla fans, and racers in town this weekend! We hope you’ll stop in and let us do the cooking for you. 🍕🍝

📍 New York Pizzeria | New Berlin
📞 607-847-6188

Fresh. Homemade. Family-owned since 1982.

✨ FRIDAY NIGHT SPECIALS AT NYP ✨Fish Friday is back and looking delicious! 🐟❤️🍑 Grilled SalmonTopped with fresh Peach Ma...
06/05/2026

✨ FRIDAY NIGHT SPECIALS AT NYP ✨

Fish Friday is back and looking delicious! 🐟❤️

🍑 Grilled Salmon
Topped with fresh Peach Mango Salsa, Avocado Cream, and Cilantro, served with Rice.

🍺 NYP Beer-Battered Haddock
Golden, crispy, flaky, and served with seasoned fries.

Fresh ingredients. Homemade favorites. The perfect way to kick off the weekend.

Dine in, take out, or call ahead—we’ll have dinner waiting for you. 😊

📞 607-847-6188
📍 New York Pizzeria | New Berlin

Family owned since 1982. Thank you for letting us be part of your Friday nights. ❤️

🍕🐟✨

It is with heavy hearts that we learned of the passing of Bill “Chap” Chaplick this past weekend.Chap was more than the ...
06/04/2026

It is with heavy hearts that we learned of the passing of Bill “Chap” Chaplick this past weekend.

Chap was more than the owner, CEO, and coach of Milford Academy—he was a great man, a respected leader, and a personal friend of the Baio family and the New York Pizzeria family for many years.

His impact on countless young people, families, and our community will not be forgotten. We are grateful for the friendship, kindness, and memories we shared with him.

Please keep his family, friends, and the entire Milford Academy community in your prayers during this difficult time.

Rest in peace, Chap. 🙏🩷🌹

— Frank, Betsey & the NYP Family

https://www.facebook.com/share/18LTTQrL6w/?mibextid=wwXIfr

🦁🎭 We’re excited to support the arts in our community! 🎭🦁This performance is extra special to us at NYP because two of t...
06/04/2026

🦁🎭 We’re excited to support the arts in our community! 🎭🦁

This performance is extra special to us at NYP because two of the Baio family’s oldest grandchildren, Sofia and Carina, will be taking the stage in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe as part of the Otsego School of Dance & Performing Arts recital.

And here’s a fun NYP connection—our chef, Matt Velardi, grew up in the dance studio world, as his parents are the owners of Otsego School of Dance & Performing Arts!

Wishing all the dancers, performers, instructors, and families a wonderful weekend of shows. We know all the hard work, dedication, and countless hours that go into bringing a production like this to life.

Break a leg, Sofia, Carina, and the entire cast! 🦁✨

❤️🍕

Address

7 S Main Street
New Berlin, NY
13411

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30am - 9pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 9pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 9pm
Thursday 10:30am - 9pm
Friday 10:30am - 9pm
Saturday 10:30am - 9pm
Sunday 10:30am - 9pm

Telephone

+16078476188

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when New York Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to New York Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category