Uncommon Cups and Cones

10/15/2026

🎄 A little ice cream. A little mystery. A whole lot of Christmas fun!

Our Ice Cream Advent Calendars are back for 2026!

Choose from 12 or 24 days of sweet surprises, with individually hand-packed ice cream tasting cups, daily scratch-off flavor reveals, and festive gift packaging.

🎁 Perfect for gifting or starting a sweet Christmas tradition of your own!

Preorders are NOW OPEN! Limited quantities available.

👇 Here are the details for pricing, pickup dates, and how to order.

10/15/2026

Only 2 more sleeps...

Ice cream season isn't over...it's just ice cream in a hoodie season now!

Who is ready for Stuff Your Stanley - fall edition? 🎉🎉

Bring your favorite insulated tumbler - any brand (does not need to be Stanley), and we'll "Stuff It" with 4 scoops of ice cream for $10 on Saturday, October 17 from 2p-8:30p.

More details:
• Any brand, 32-44 oz, wide-mouth insulated tumbler will work. (Small-mouths will not be filled.)
• Tumblers MUST be washed clean and empty.
• You pick 4 flavors. (See Uncommoncupsandcones.com for full list.)
• One per person.
• Toppings and extra scoops will be charged at regular price.
• Eat in or take home. Scoops should hold in your tumbler for 6-8 hours.
• Fun experience to share with family and friends.
• Take plenty of photos and tag us!

Let's do this!

10/14/2026

Now scooping: MINT AVALANCHE!

This award winning fresh mint ice cream is loaded with Andes Candies and Grasshopper cookies and spun off with a chocolate fudge swirl.

10/11/2026

A little spooky now, a little sweet for Christmas! 🎃🎄🍦

Our popular Ice Cream Advent Calendars are coming back! Who's ready for another holiday season full of sweet surprises?

10/10/2026

CARAMEL APPLE PIE is back in the cabinet!

10/08/2026

Ice cream season isn't over...it's just ice cream in a hoodie season now!

Who is ready for Stuff Your Stanley - fall edition? 🎉🎉

Bring your favorite insulated tumbler - any brand (does not need to be Stanley), and we'll "Stuff It" with 4 scoops of ice cream for $10 on Saturday, October 17 from 2p-8:30p.

More details:
• Any brand, 32-44 oz, wide-mouth insulated tumbler will work. (Small-mouths will not be filled.)
• Tumblers MUST be washed clean and empty.
• You pick 4 flavors. (See Uncommoncupsandcones.com for full list.)
• One per person.
• Toppings and extra scoops will be charged at regular price.
• Eat in or take home. Scoops should hold in your tumbler for 6-8 hours.
• Fun experience to share with family and friends.
• Take plenty of photos and tag us!

Let's do this!

10/02/2026

It’s PINT🍦BER at Uncommon!

For just $1 more, mix up your usual pint!

Choose up to 3 of your favorite flavors and we'll hand-pack them layer by layer in one pint.

Available through October!

10/01/2026

We're back in the shop today starting at 2pm! 🍦

Don't let the No Parking signs on Vincennes Street fool you — they're for the parade route, not because we're closed.

Yes, we're OPEN on parade day! The Harvest Homecoming Parade comes right past our front door Saturday! We open at 2 PM, and the parade starts from New Albany High School at 3 PM.

If you're heading this way to find your parade spot, swing by and grab a scoop!

09/27/2026

09/26/2026

Ultimate Oreo is scrumptious Oreo crumb ice cream packed with boat loads of whole Oreo cookies.

How many scoops for you? Cup, cone or shake?

If you're near New Albany, come see us at 518 Vincennes St.