The Brotherhood of Thieves

The Brotherhood of Thieves The legend is reborn!

The Brotherhood of Thieves has been an Island institution for 50 years, serving great food and hospitality in the heart of downtown Nantucket.

Happy Nantucket Wine & Food 2026!!Crab and Avocado, Latin Salmon, Strawberry Shortcake: selected by chef enjoyed by all...
05/29/2026

Happy Nantucket Wine & Food 2026!!
Crab and Avocado, Latin Salmon, Strawberry Shortcake: selected by chef enjoyed by all 🍽️🍷 Cheers everyone, see you at Brotherhood!!

05/27/2026

Still reflecting after a Great Memorial Day weekend! Thank you to those who served and sacrificed 🇺🇸

05/25/2026
Strawberry Shortcake days. Espresso Martini nights🍓🍸 ✨
05/17/2026

Strawberry Shortcake days. Espresso Martini nights🍓🍸 ✨

Our New Menu is Here. Nantucket Current
04/30/2026

Our New Menu is Here. Nantucket Current

The Brotherhood is open and ready to see you! Come warm up by the fire and take a break from the cold. Hot water’s on us...
02/24/2026

The Brotherhood is open and ready to see you! Come warm up by the fire and take a break from the cold. Hot water’s on us today 😉

We love you Nantucket!

Brr! It’s cold in here! I said it must be Hernando in the atmosphere! 👏🏼The Brotherhood of Thieves will be closed today ...
02/23/2026

Brr! It’s cold in here! I said it must be Hernando in the atmosphere! 👏🏼

The Brotherhood of Thieves will be closed today due to blizzard conditions. Stay warm and stay safe! We can’t wait to see you soon!

Good Food • Good Drink • Good Company • Great NachosOur seasonal winter menu will be making its return Friday, November ...
11/12/2025

Good Food • Good Drink • Good Company • Great Nachos

Our seasonal winter menu will be making its return Friday, November 14th. Your favorites are back in house along with delicious new additions! Come stay cozy with us!

Book now on Resy.Com or check us out on our website at BrotherhoodNantucket.com

Address

23 Broad Street
Nantucket, MA
02554

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am - 12am
Tuesday 11:30am - 12am
Wednesday 11:30am - 12am
Thursday 11:30am - 12am
Friday 11:30am - 12am
Saturday 11:30am - 12am
Sunday 11:30am - 12am

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Brotherhood of Thieves posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Brotherhood of Thieves:

Shortcuts

Share

Category