Crit & Crumble

Crit & Crumble Crit N Crumble is where fantasy meets flavor and chaos is always on the menu. We make lots of sweet treats that are so not the everyday!

We are a cafe that blends tabletop nerd culture with over-the-top ideas for food, drinks and treats. So if you're looking for an out of the box treat to celebrate, or just because your sweet tooth is calling...You've come to the right place!

Your next quest reward shouldn’t be gold… it should be buttercream. 🧁✨Whether you're celebrating a birthday, hosting a p...
05/29/2026

Your next quest reward shouldn’t be gold… it should be buttercream. 🧁✨

Whether you're celebrating a birthday, hosting a party, or just need a little edible magic, we craft desserts that are anything but ordinary.

From custom cakes to cupcakes and cookies, every order is built to match your theme—fantasy, fandom, or completely original.

No templates. No shortcuts. Just made-from-scratch creations designed for your party.

📩 Send us your idea and let’s turn it into something delicious.

RARE LOOT DROP: IN-HOUSE ICE CREAM RESTOCK The cooler just got hit with a legendary supply drop and the spawn rates on t...
05/24/2026

RARE LOOT DROP: IN-HOUSE ICE CREAM RESTOCK

The cooler just got hit with a legendary supply drop and the spawn rates on them have been limited.
We’ve been grinding behind the scenes to restock our in-store made ice cream and the shelves are looking like a high-tier dungeon chest.

We’ve got all your favorite builds packed and ready:

The 12oz Jars: For the players who want to see exactly what kind of top-tier layers they're working with.
The Craft Pints: Heavy-duty comfort armor for a long weekend gaming session.
The Mini Jars: Perfect for quick stat boosts between rounds.
These are small-batch, premium crafts, meaning once a flavor gets wiped from the cooler, it's officially out of rotation until the next raid cycle.
Stop by, check the flavors, and claim your loot before the local sweat lords clear out the entire inventory. What flavor are you drafting first?

We have some 8 inch tres leches available in case.
05/24/2026

We have some 8 inch tres leches available in case.

We unhitched the chains in the kitchen and gave the crew "Free Range" mode today. Usually, that’s a chaotic gamble lol b...
05/23/2026

We unhitched the chains in the kitchen and gave the crew "Free Range" mode today. Usually, that’s a chaotic gamble lol but they absolutely maxed out their decorating skills with this one.

Behold: The Lemon-Blueberry Behemoth
The build is total top-tier luxury:

The Base: Layers of soft, bright lemon cake.
The Loot: Stuffed to the brim with a rich blueberry filling.
The Shield: Encased in a textured lemon buttercream that the crew hand-piped like absolute pros.

They are officially leveling up their decoration game, and frankly, it looks too good for us to just sit here and stare at it.
Slices are officially in case now and ready to grab on the go! Come score a piece to fuel your next match. Inventory is limited to how many slices we can cut before someone eats the whole thing themselves 😂

⚔️ DOUBLE ELIMINATION BRACKET: WE CAN’T LET Remis HAVE ALL THE FUN TODAY WITH THEIR COMMANDER CUP EVENT ⚔️The case at Cr...
05/23/2026

⚔️ DOUBLE ELIMINATION BRACKET: WE CAN’T LET Remis HAVE ALL THE FUN TODAY WITH THEIR COMMANDER CUP EVENT ⚔️

The case at Crit n Crumble is currently a high-tier battleground and your table's meta is about to be tested. We have two completely separate match-ups today and frankly some of you are going to make the wrong choices. 😉

MATCH 1:
THE CITRUS CLASH of bars 🍋 vs 🍋‍🟩
Lemon Blueberry: Crisp, sharp, lemon bar topped with fresh blueberries. It’s a classic tactical build. No fluff.
Lime Strawberry: The flashy wildcard. A bright lime bar topped with fresh strawberries. It thinks it's a premium foil pull.

MATCH 2:
THE CHEESECAKE CONFRONTATION 🍪 vs 🍒
The KBOP: Rich cheesecake bar built heavy and topped with a slice of Oatmeal Creme Pie cookie. Absolute maximum stat buff. It’s total overkill and you know you want it.
The Cherry: Smooth, elegant, and drenched in sweet cherry topping. It’s sitting there pretending it’s too refined for a gaming cafe.

The inventory is limited. Stop in, draft your team, and let us know in the comments who takes the total victory today.

🇺🇸 Memorial Day weekend just got a whole lot sweeter 🇺🇸Our Tres Leches cake showed up dressed for the occasion with whip...
05/22/2026

🇺🇸 Memorial Day weekend just got a whole lot sweeter 🇺🇸

Our Tres Leches cake showed up dressed for the occasion with whipped topping, fresh strawberries and blueberries looking all patriotic and delicious.

Light, creamy, melt-in-your-mouth goodness that somehow disappears faster than your long weekend plans.

Honestly this cake is giving “one more slice won’t hurt” energy. 😉

Okay but these cheesecakes are being a little too confident today. 👀Apple Pie Cannoli Cheesecake is back for another rou...
05/19/2026

Okay but these cheesecakes are being a little too confident today. 👀

Apple Pie Cannoli Cheesecake is back for another round—
Creamy cheesecake loaded with apple pie goodness, topped with cream cheese frosting, oatmeal cookie crumble and apple pie filling like it’s trying to win awards.

Lemon Cheesecake —
Smooth cheesecake topped with cream cheese frosting, lemon pie filling and white chocolate chips. Sweet, tart and just enough attitude.

Honestly the hardest part today is choosing which one gets eaten first.

Address

1108 Grandview Avenue
Muscatine, IA
52761

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 7pm
Tuesday 9am - 7pm
Wednesday 9am - 7pm
Thursday 9am - 7pm
Friday 9am - 8pm
Saturday 9am - 8pm
Sunday 12pm - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Crit & Crumble posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Crit & Crumble:

Shortcuts

Share

Category