10/07/2026
Not All Pies Are Created Equal
Okay, we’ll admit it—we’re totally biased. But can you blame us? When it comes to pumpkin pie, we think ours is the best you’ll ever taste. And we’ve got five delicious reasons to back that up! From the perfect blend of spices to our melt-in-your-mouth crust, we promise our pumpkin pies are worth every bite.
1. Made in Mount Joy, Not a Factory – While factory-made pies rely on shortcuts and preservatives, ours are handcrafted from start to finish right here in our bakery. We can't think of a better way to preserve freshness and flavor than by making it fresh.
2. Made with Real Pumpkin – Our pumpkin pies are made with real pumpkin sourced right here in the local community, bringing you the rich, fresh flavors of the season. This local touch gives our pies an authentic taste that’s hard to beat, making each bite a true celebration of fall.
3. Crust is Key – A great pie starts from the bottom up—literally! We make our crust from scratch, blending just the right amount of ingredients for that perfect, flaky texture. Each bite delivers a delicate crunch that perfectly balances the creamy filling.
4. Not Too Spicy – Our recipe features a blend of spices that bring out the natural sweetness of the pumpkin without overwhelming your taste buds. The result is a warm, cozy flavor that’s just right—not too spicy, but full of that classic autumn goodness.
5. Made with Love – It might sound a little corny, but it’s true! Our team genuinely loves serving our customers through baking, and we believe that passion comes through in every bite. But don’t just take our word for it—we’ll let you be the judge!
Thanksgiving Book is Officially Open!
Planning for Thanksgiving? Give us a call and check dessert of your list or order anytime on our site.
Did someone say Cheesecake?
Pumpkin pie not your thing? No worries! We also offer a pumpkin-flavored cheesecake that’s rich, creamy, and decadently smooth. With just the right balance of spice and sweetness, this cheesecake is the perfect alternative for fall dessert lovers looking for something a little different.
Our current cheesecake flavors: Oreo, chocolate chip, chocolate, classic, cherry topped, raspberry swirl, and peanut butter cup.
Giving the perfect gift made easy!
Did you know that we have a growing retail space at Rise Bake Shoppe & Coffee Bar?
Take a tour of Lancaster with these brands:
Fox Meadows Ice Cream
Emma's Popcorn
Evan's Chocolate
Kitchen Kettle Village Jams
Mustard Seed accessories & Shirts
PureBlend Tea
Garden Path Soaps & Candles
New! Greeting Cards
New! Christian Art Gifts
New! Jenny Lemon Hair Clips & accessories
Cake Decorating Supplies
Tea Towels
T-Shirts & Sweatshirts
