10/08/2026
Dear Molly’s and Market Street Pizza friends, family, and customers old and new,
We have come to a difficult decision. It is with a heavy heart that we must tell you we are going to close both our restaurants in three weeks. The last day of dinner service for both restaurants will be October 24th.
This is not a decision we have taken lightly. We have agonized over it for a long time. But it is time for us to make a change.
Over the last 12 and 1/2 years we have had an incredible ride. We certainly never expected to make it this far. Our business grew from 3 employees to 35. Our dinner and cocktail menu evolved from classic dishes and drinks to innovative and elegant expressions of flavor and texture, imagined and created entirely by our incredible staff. We went from recieving all our ingredients on a large distributor's truck to sourcing most of our vegetables from amazing local produce farmers. Our dining room went from occasional busy nights to being full every weekend. We have watched our customers and our employees grow through stages of life, children becoming young adults, young adults starting careers, career professionals retiring. Through it all, we have continued to be amazed by our customers’ appreciation and support for our original mission: to provide a dining experience that truly feeds and satisfies. To create a place where we can have a moment away from our lives, where we feel taken care of and considered, where we can choose our journey, be it the cravably familiar or adventurous unknown.
We feel immense gratitude for the reliability of our regular customers, many of whom have dined with us several times a month. We feel honored to be the chosen spot for special occasions, birthdays, anniversaries. Marriage proposals have been made and accepted in the Molly’s dining room. Wedding parties have celebrated on the back patio. Simpler moments resonate too, like a first taste of a new ingredient, a discovery that can open a door to a whole new experience. None of this would have been possible without our customers, our staff, our family and our friends.
There are seasons to life, and for us this season has come to its end. Please join us in the next 3 weeks in saying goodbye, and sharing your stories.
We are forever grateful,
Ben and Molly
