Chocolate in the Oven, Bake Shop

Chocolate in the Oven, Bake Shop Handcrafted Small Batch Bakery & Sweet Shop
Tues - Saturday 8 to 7
Sunday 8 to 4
[email protected]

Full service retail bakery….specializing in custom and layer Cakes, Italian pastry, homemade cookies, small batch ice cream, Brownie, Bars, Old-Fashioned Candy, Pastry, Breads, and lots of savory items too! Everything is homemade, from scratch, using the finest ingredients. Serving a full line of espresso drinks using fresh locally roasted beans from Someday Coffee Roasters
Many Gluten-Free items are available - just ask us for some great options! If you would like to place an order, try our online ordering site, https://www.toasttab.com/chocolate-in-the-oven-53-bridge-street/v3 ,contact us at [email protected] or call 908-268-5571
Closed Monday

Sweet or savory, we’re here for it
10/02/2026

Sweet or savory, we’re here for it

In a month full of pumpkin spice, be sure to leave some room for our homemade caramel pecan cups!
10/01/2026

In a month full of pumpkin spice, be sure to leave some room for our homemade caramel pecan cups!

🎃👻 CALLING ALL HALLOWEEN BAKERS & TREAT MAKERS! 👻🎃We’re bringing a little spooky sweetness to Milford! 🧁🍪Join us for our...
09/30/2026

🎃👻 CALLING ALL HALLOWEEN BAKERS & TREAT MAKERS! 👻🎃

We’re bringing a little spooky sweetness to Milford! 🧁🍪

Join us for our Halloween Treat Contest at Chocolate in the Oven on Sunday, October 25th!

🕘 Treat drop-off: 9 AM–1 PM
🏆 Judging: 3 PM
📍 Chocolate in the Oven

Show us your most creative Halloween-inspired homemade treat! Whether it’s spooky, silly, creepy or just downright delicious—we want to see it! 🕷️🎃👻

🏆 Categories include:
🍪 Best Halloween Cookie
🧁 Best Halloween Cupcake
🎂 Best Decorated Treat
✨ Most Creative
👧 Kids’ Choice

ALL ENTRIES MUST BE HANDMADE! ❤️

So get baking, decorating and creating—and come show off your Halloween masterpiece! We can’t wait to see what Milford comes up with! 🎃🧡

BakeLocal

A new trend in wedding and event cakes…long and thin bar cakes…Keep them as simple or ornate as you like, decorate with ...
09/28/2026

A new trend in wedding and event cakes…long and thin bar cakes…Keep them as simple or ornate as you like, decorate with fresh flowers, fruit, etc. available in half (shown) and double length!

The sweetest barnyard themed birthday cake and cupcakes!
09/27/2026

The sweetest barnyard themed birthday cake and cupcakes!

Apple pie 🥧 contest will be under way at 1 pm!
09/26/2026

Apple pie 🥧 contest will be under way at 1 pm!

Here’s a reason to get out of the house today ! The return of all your fall favorites!
09/26/2026

Here’s a reason to get out of the house today ! The return of all your fall favorites!

Rain or shine get your pie recipe out today! Win a gift basket of Chocolate in the Oven, Bake Shop goodies!
09/25/2026

Rain or shine get your pie recipe out today! Win a gift basket of Chocolate in the Oven, Bake Shop goodies!

🍎🥧 CALLING ALL BAKERS! 🥧🍎

Milford Alive 2026 is looking for the best apple pie around!

Join Chocolate in the Oven’s Apple Pie Contest and show us your best homemade apple pie! 🍏🍎

Memories from our first pie contest! Dust off your best recioe and Visit Fall Apple Pie Baking Contest @ Milford Ali...
09/22/2026

Memories from our first pie contest! Dust off your best recioe and Visit Fall Apple Pie Baking Contest @ Milford Alive for info on how to join the fun this coming Saturday!

What to pair with our new cardamom (mocha or pumpkin) latte? One of our new soft pumpkin cookies with a caramelized brow...
09/20/2026

What to pair with our new cardamom (mocha or pumpkin) latte? One of our new soft pumpkin cookies with a caramelized brown sugar glaze or a classic almond croissant sounds like a great plan to me! See you Sunday 8 am to 5 pm!

Address

53 Bridge Street
Milford, NJ
08848

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 7pm
Wednesday 9am - 7pm
Thursday 9am - 7pm
Friday 8am - 7pm
Saturday 8am - 7pm
Sunday 8am - 5pm

Telephone

+19082685571

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Chocolate in the Oven, Bake Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Chocolate in the Oven, Bake Shop:

Shortcuts

Share