The Old Mill Creamery

03/16/2026

Happy St. Patrick's Day!! A new green ice cream is here! Introducing Pistachio ice cream!!

Also returning to the case, Coconut and Maple Walnut!!

Come visit us today!!

02/14/2026

Stop by with your valentine to try one of our February specials!!!

Strawberry Nutella Breve
White Chocolate Raspberry Latte
Red Raspberry Swirl Ice Cream
Spiced Cinnaburst Ice Cream

12/09/2025

Our winter specials are here!!!

Chill out with a dish or cone of Peppermint Delight or Gingerbread ice cream.

Warm up with a Peppermint Mocha!!!

Stop in and chill out or warm up!

06/13/2025

Fundraiser for the Ervin Beachy Family

We’re inviting you to join us in supporting the Ervin Beachy family. Ervin was recently diagnosed with a brain tumor and has undergone surgery to have it removed. He is now going through radiation and chemotherapy treatments, which means he is currently unable to work.

This fundraiser will help cover living expenses during this challenging time. The Beachy family are not only neighbors but also close friends of Old Mill Creamery and the Nolt family. Two of the Beachy daughters are part of our Creamery team, making this cause especially close to our hearts.

Your support means so much. Thank you for standing with our friends.

Blessings to all,
John Nolt

05/28/2025

Closer announcement!

05/19/2025

Say Aloha to summer in a scoop!
Our Pineapple Ice Cream is here—creamy, fruity, and full of tropical flavor. It’s a summer must-try available for a limited time!

04/25/2025

NEW SPRING FLAVOR > Honey Lavendar<
Come out and try some today. We are open till 8:30 pm.

04/17/2025

03/10/2025

SUMMER HOURS STARTING THIS WEEK!!!
Now open Monday-Saturday 7:30am to 8:30 pm. It’s a beautiful sunny day with some spring weather coming our way, so we are excited to be serving you later😁

02/19/2025

NEW FLAVOR!!!!
If you like big red gum, this one is for you. This “Spiced CinnaBurst” ice cream is a hot cinnamon flavored base with little cinnamon candies. It’s only here for a short time so come and get it.

01/25/2025

NEW FLAVOR!!!!! This one is for the peanut butter lovers. Peanut butter brownie swirl😋 with a peanut butter base, a fudge swirl and pieces of brownies and mini peanut butter cups. We are open till 6 tonight. Come out and try some.

09/17/2024

For those of you who are pumpkin lovers, And who have been asking and patiently waiting, GUESS WHAT?!
Our pumpkin butter swirl, seasonal ice cream is back in the dip case!!!

What is pumpkin butter swirl ice cream? it is a vanilla based ice cream with pumpkin butter swirled into it!

Don't wait any longer, come out and try it today! We can't wait to serve you.!