Coney Island Diner

05/01/2026

After many wonderful years, Coney Island Diner has officially closed its doors.

We’ve recently passed the business on to new ownership, marking the end of an incredible chapter for us. This wasn’t just a diner—it was a place filled with laughter, early mornings, late evenings, and so many familiar faces who became like family.

Serving this community has meant everything to us, and we are truly grateful for your loyalty, support, and countless memories shared over the years.

From a simple cup of coffee to full meals with loved ones, you made this place something special.

Thank you for being part of our journey 🙏🏼❤️

– The Coney Island Diner Team

02/22/2026

Due to the expected snow storm, Coney Island Diner will be CLOSED tomorrow for the safety of our customers and staff.

We appreciate your understanding and look forward to serving you again as soon as the weather clears. Stay safe, stay warm, and we’ll see you soon! ☕🍳

12/25/2025

🎄 Holiday Hours Update 🎄
Coney Island Diner will be closed on Christmas Day so our team can enjoy the holiday with their families.
We wish all of our wonderful guests a Merry Christmas and a happy holiday season! ✨

We’ll reopen with regular hours the following day. See you soon! 😊

09/14/2025

We’ve got good news, Middletown!
Coney Island Diner is now open later—Monday through Saturday until 6:00 PM (previously 4:00 PM).

Perfect for a late lunch, an early dinner, or just grabbing your favorites a little later in the day. 🍔🥤

📍 Stop by and see us—we’ll save you a seat!

04/24/2025

Paninis have officially landed at Coney Island Diner!
Hot, melty, and packed with flavor—served with fries and a side of comfort. Come try our newest menu addition today!

04/23/2025

Rise & Shine, Middletown!
Our NEW & improved Breakfast Specials are here to start your mornings right—served Monday through Friday from 6AM to 10AM at Coney Island Diner!

Fuel up with favorites like:
• 2 Eggs with homefries, toast + coffee – just $6.99
• Egg Sandwich on a hard roll or bagel + coffee – only $4.99
• Western Omelette with 3 eggs, ham, peppers, & onions + coffee – $12.99
• Pancakes or French Toast served with 2 eggs + coffee – $7.99

Make it yours!
• Add bacon, ham, or sausage
• Top pancakes or French toast with blueberries, strawberries, or chocolate chips!

Whether you’re heading to work or just craving a classic breakfast, we’ve got your morning covered.

04/21/2025

Lunchtime just got better at Coney Island Diner!
Stop by and try our mouthwatering Lunch Specials, served daily from 11AM to 3PM!

Enjoy your choice of:
• French Dip Panini
• Chicken Caesar Wrap
• Turkey Melt
• Veggie Burger Wrap
• Eggplant Wrap
• Steak Fajita Quesadillas

Each special comes with the Soup of the Day or House Salad, plus French Fries or Potato Chips.

Soup of the Day Lineup:
Monday - Tomato Basil
Tuesday - Tuscan Beef
Wednesday - Turkey Barley
Thursday - Creamy Cheddar Potato Bacon
Friday - Cheddar Broccoli
Saturday & Sunday - Chicken Noodle

05/07/2024

🌷 Celebrate Mother's Day at Coney Island Diner! 🌷

This Mother's Day, treat the special women in your life to a delightful dining experience they deserve! Whether it's breakfast, brunch, or lunch, make her day unforgettable with our delicious menu options.

👩‍👧‍👦 Special Offer: Moms dine with us and receive a complimentary dessert of their choice. Because today, it's all about her!

🍽️ Featured Items:

Decadent Oreo Pancakes
Strawberry & Banana Pancakes

🌸 We’re all set to make Mother’s Day both delicious and memorable. Join us for a meal as wonderful as she is!

🕒 Date: Sunday, May 12th
📍 Location: 10 Railroad Avenue, Middletown, NY
☎️ : 845.343.3714 / 845.344.FOOD

📌 Let's make this Mother's Day one to remember at Coney Island Diner!

05/03/2024

🌟 Sweeten Your Day at Coney Island Diner! 🌟
Save 5% up to $15 on every order using code ONLINEORDERING at nyconeyisland.com

Craving something sweet and satisfying? Dive into our decadent French toast selections, perfect for any day that needs a sprinkle of joy! 🫐🍓🍌

🥇 Featuring:
1️⃣ Classic Blueberry🫐 French Toast: Layers of golden French toast topped with lush blueberry compote and a drizzled with luscious cream cheese icing.
2️⃣ Strawberry🍓 French Toast: Delicate French toast crowned with vibrant strawberry compote and swirls of whipped cream, all drizzled with creamy cheese icing.
3️⃣ Banana Bread🍌 French Toast: A decadent twist on tradition with banana bread French toast, topped with fresh banana slices and a hazelnut drizzle.

📍 Visit us at 10 Railroad Avenue, Middletown, NY or call to order your delight: 845.343.3714 / 845.344.FOOD

👉 Dine in or Take Out! We're here to make your meal memorable.

02/07/2024

🎉 Exciting News for Our Beloved Customers! 🎉

At Coney Island Cafe, we're thrilled to introduce a more rewarding way to enjoy your favorite meals! 💻🍔 Order pickup orders DIRECTLY from us through our official website and get ready for a feast of benefits:

✨ Sign up today and get an INSTANT $5 OFF your first order! Yes, you read that right - a delicious discount just for you.

🎁 But wait, there's more! For EVERY pickup order, we're giving back 5% in points, redeemable anytime towards your next cravings fix. The more you order, the more you save!

Why order direct? Here’s why:

🚀 Faster service and personal interaction
🍴 Access to exclusive deals and our full menu
🌟 Support local business and help us provide you with even better service
Ordering is easy:

Visit https://order.nyconeyisland.com/home
Choose your favorites
Pick up and enjoy!
Swipe left on third-party platforms and join us directly where the real magic happens. Your next meal could be even more rewarding!

visit at Coney Island Cafe Middletown NY