Custom Cookies by Dawn, LLC

Custom Cookies by Dawn, LLC Offering homemade made-to-order custom designed sugar cookies. Hi and Welcome! My sugar cookies are 100% homemade in my home based kitchen. Thank you~
Dawn

Prices are quoted on design & detail. Cookies start at 48.00 per dozen with an up charge for painting of gold/silver and/or extreme detail. Each cookie is individually heat sealed to ensure freshness & safety. I’m currently booking cookie orders 4 plus months in advance & will book out to one year in advance. 50% deposit will hold your booking date. All cookie orders are pick-up only from our Mic

higan City home. At this time, I am only accepting cash payment & PayPal. Please message me with any questions -
I look forward to creating something special for you.

07/10/2026

Extra cupcakes & Buttercream floral cookies will be posted at 6:30 am tomorrow!

I cannot let today pass without letting everybody know it is National Sugar Cookie Day! Thank you for allowing me to c...
07/10/2026

I cannot let today pass without letting everybody know it is National Sugar Cookie Day!

Thank you for allowing me to create for you when the opportunity arises.

I appreciate all the love & support my community shows me!

With gratitude,
~Dawn

07/09/2026

UPDATE: Cookies are all gone! Thank you to all the taste testers!
I have extra packs of dye free cookies, available for sampling. I’m here till 5:30 PM. Come pick up a pack.

Sometimes it’s not always pretty…..here’s one truth about being a baker….sometimes you move quicker than you should…..an...
07/09/2026

Sometimes it’s not always pretty…..here’s one truth about being a baker….sometimes you move quicker than you should…..and sometimes your hands just give out. I speak from almost 20 years of experience, 3 hand surgeries with a 4th one this fall………slow down, Dawn…..you act like you can move when you were 20. I’ve got buttercream EVERYWHERE!

There will be EXTRAS! This week and next if FULL of buttercream orders, both cookies & cupcakes. Stay tuned in for extr...
07/09/2026

There will be EXTRAS!

This week and next if FULL of buttercream orders, both cookies & cupcakes.

Stay tuned in for extras being posted later tonight for pick up on Friday evening after 6 pm.

HOWDY! I’d love to chat with you for a minute if you would take the time to read about natural food dyes. Over the pas...
07/09/2026

HOWDY! I’d love to chat with you for a minute if you would take the time to read about natural food dyes.

Over the past couple of months I have been experimenting. A couple weeks ago I made some cookies using sugar art natural dyes. They are fabulous to work with and are true to color. A box went out to my husband‘s coworker, and she taste tested them along with her children and said they were fabulous. Sugar art, natural food dyes have a very short shelf life. If you click on the picture, you will see how much a set of them costs. As much as I want to use these, if I did, it would increase the price of the cookies.

So….. I purchased this other set off of Amazon and as you can see, the price difference is huge. They are not true to color as you can see in the picture of the little cookies with the dye colors behind them. However, they are very affordable.
This is what I’ll be sending out for people to sample. I would appreciate your honest opinion. It is my same cookie recipe just with this dye free option.

I will be responding to all of the messages for those who want to sample from the previous post. I would appreciate if you would respond as soon as possible as pick up will have to be tomorrow 7-9-26 from 4-5:30 pm.

Thank you~
Dawn

I’m experimenting some more with dye free colors! For those of you that eliminated dyes for your children, and would li...
07/08/2026

I’m experimenting some more with dye free colors! For those of you that eliminated dyes for your children, and would like to sample a cookie or two could you please comment?  I don’t know how many people are interested and I don’t know if I have enough cookies for everyone, but please chime in.

My new 3 year cookie planner arrived today! In 2027, my cookie world will slowing start to change. If you are like me ...
07/07/2026

My new 3 year cookie planner arrived today!

In 2027, my cookie world will slowing start to change.

If you are like me and a pre-planner, starting in September 2026, I will be booking January - July 2027 events.

There will be NO open dates August 1-September 11th 2027. However, cookie & cupcakes freeze well so you can plan accordingly.

😘
Dawn

7.5 lbs butter13 pounds flour18 large eggsPlus more….now to refrigerate for 24 hours before baking
07/07/2026

7.5 lbs butter
13 pounds flour
18 large eggs
Plus more….now to refrigerate for 24 hours before baking

Address

3801 Lexington Road
Michigan City, IN
46360

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Custom Cookies by Dawn, LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category